404. That’s an error.

The requested URL /bookmarks/mark?op=edit&bkmk=http%3A%2F%2F3dcadnews.blog.com%2F2007%2F12%2F20%2Fnew-legal-hot-water-rp-material-announced-for-v-flash%2F&title=New%20%27Legal%20Hot%20Water%27%20RP%20Material%20Announced%20for%20V-Flash%0A&annotation=%0AAnother%20round%20of%20artillery%20fire%2C%20in%20what%20seems%20to%20be%20an%20ongoing%20feud%20in%20the%20rapid%20prototyping%20industry%20was%20lobbed%20this%20week%20when%20RP%20vendor%203DSystems%20was%20granted%20a%20preliminary%20injunction%20in%20Germany%20against%20rival%20RP%20vendor%20EnvisionTEC.%20It%20was%20your%20basic%20%22shut%20your%20mouth%22%20injunction.%0A%0ATo%20work%20from%20the%20present%20and%20going%20backwards%20%28the%20story%20has%20length%20but%20is%20worth%20it%29%2C%20this%20week%203D%20Systems%20obtained%20the%20injunction%20to%20prevent%20EnvisionTEC%20from%20further%20publishing%20statements%20it%20made%20in%20a%20November%2028%2C%202007%20press%20release%2C%20which%20stated%203Dsystems%27%20%22V-flash%20unit%20system%20is%20potentially%20infringing%20on%20its%20German%20issued%20patents.%22%0A%0A3DSystems%27%20December%2018%202007%20press%20release%20about%20the%20injunction%20states%2C%0A%22The%20preliminary%20injunction%20prohibits%20EnvisionTEC%20from%20the%20further%20publication%20of%20those%20statements%20in%20Germany%20and%20stated%20that%20EnvisionTEC%20GmbH%20may%20be%20subject%20to%20a%20fine%20of%20up%20to%20%E2%82%AC250%2C000%20or%20that%20its%20legal%20representatives%20are%20subject%20to%20arrest%20and%20imprisonment%20for%20up%20to%20six%20months%20for%20each%20violation%20of%20the%20court%E2%80%99s%20prohibition%20order.%22%20%28editor%20comment%3A%20ouch%29%0A%0ABut%20this%20is%20a%20huge%20step%20forward%20from%20the%20war%20of%20words%20in%20the%20weeks%20before%3A%203DSystems%27%20December%204th%20announcement%20initially%20responding%20to%20the%20claims%20made%20by%20EnvisionTEC%20has%20the%20following%20quote%3A%0A%0A%E2%80%9CAs%20a%20company%2C%20we%20are%20keenly%20aware%20of%20the%20importance%20of%20intellectual%20property%2C%20and%20we%20make%20every%20effort%20not%20only%20to%20protect%20our%20own%20intellectual%20property%20but%20also%20to%20respect%20the%20valid%20intellectual%20property%20rights%20of%20others%2C%E2%80%9D%20said%20Abe%20Reichental%2C%20president%20and%20chief%20executive%20officer%20of%203D%20Systems.%20%E2%80%9CIn%20this%20regard%2C%20we%20are%20currently%20involved%20in%20litigation%20with%20EnvisionTEC%20in%20the%20United%20States%20charging%20that%20its%20Perfactory%20and%20Vanquish%20prototyping%20systems%20infringe%20a%20number%20of%20our%20United%20States%20Patents.%20With%20respect%20to%20EnvisionTEC%E2%80%99s%20recent%20press%20release%2C%20we%20believe%20that%20EnvisionTEC%20does%20not%20have%20sufficient%20technical%20information%20or%20a%20factual%20basis%20for%20the%20statements%20it%20makes%20in%20that%20release.%E2%80%9D%0AHere%27s%20a%20curious%20point%3A%20the%20offending%20November%2028%202007%20press%20release%20issued%20by%20EnvisionTEC%20is%20almost%20nowhere%20to%20be%20found%20on%20the%20web%2C%20anywhere%2C%20even%20on%20the%20company%27s%20web%20site.%20It%20implies%20a%20lot%20about%20EnvisionTEC%27s%20press%20release%20distribution%20ability%20and%20I%20even%20started%20to%20think%20that%20they%20may%20have%20simply%20sent%20it%20to%20their%20sibling%20rivals%20at%203DSystems%20for%20some%20fun%20and%20giggles%20near%20Christmas.%20But%20no%2C%20thank%20goodness%20for%20Ralph%20Grabowski%2C%20who%20kindly%20dug%20up%20the%20text%20from%20the%20cache%20archives%20of%20Google.%20It%20reads%20as%20follows%3A%0A%0ABREAKING%20NEWS%20-%20EnvisionTEC%20Gmbh%20Claim%20Patent%20Infringement%0A%0ANovember%2028th%2C%202007%20-%20EnvisionTEC%20Gmbh%20has%20officially%20notified%20the%0AGerman%20distributor%20of%20the%20V-flash%20system%20manufactured%20by%203D%20Systems%0Acompany%20that%20the%20V-flash%20unit%20system%20is%20potentially%20infringing%20on%0Aits%20German%20issued%20patents.%0A%0A%22Our%20intellectual%20property%20is%20very%20essential%20to%20our%20strength%20in%0Adelivering%20innovative%20solutions%20to%20our%20customers%2C%20and%20growing%20our%0Amarket%20share%20in%20the%20Rapid%20Prototyping%20and%20Manufacturing%20market.%20We%0Aintend%20to%20vigorously%20defend%20our%20patents%20when%20we%20believe%20that%20they%20are%0Abeing%20infringed%20upon%22%20said%20Mr.%20Siblani%2C%20CEO%20of%20EnvisionTEC%20Gmbh.%0A%0AEnvisionTEC%20Gmbh%20is%20based%20in%20Gladbeck%20Germany%20and%20manufactures%20a%0Acomplete%20line%20of%20rapid%20prototyping%20and%20rapid%20manufacturing%20systems%0Aknown%20as%20the%20Perfactory%20Standard%2C%20MINI%20%2C%20and%20Desktop.%20It%20also%0Amanufactures%20the%20Perfactory%20Vanquish%20Flashcure%20System%20as%20well%20as%20its%0Alatest%20offering%2C%20the%20Perfactory%20Xede.%0A%0ABut%20the%20squabble%20doesn%27t%20end%20there.%20In%20a%20clear%20pattern%20of%20feudal%20hissing%20and%20squabbling%20in%20the%20RP%20family%2C%203DSystems%20is%20currently%20involved%20in%20litigation%20in%20the%20US%20regarding%20EnvisionTEC%27s%20possible%20infringement%20of%203DSystems%27%20US%20patents.%20That%20began%20in%202006%3B%203D%20Systems%20issued%20a%20press%20release%20on%20March%209.%20Part%20of%20it%20reads%3A%0A%0A%223D%20Systems%E2%80%99%20complaint%20asserts%20that%20the%20defendants%20are%20infringing%20these%20U.S.%20patents%20by%20importing%2C%20marketing%20or%20selling%20prototyping%20systems%2C%20including%20their%20PERFACTORY%20and%20VANQUISH%20modeling%20systems%2C%20used%20for%20creating%20physical%20three-dimensional%20models%20of%20objects.%22%20This%20legal%20action%20is%20still%20ongoing%20and%20is%20referred%20to%20in%20the%20Dec%204%2C%202007%20press%20release%20by%203DSystems.%0A%0ABut%20then%20the%20story%20twists.%20In%20a%20moment%20of%20what%20we%20at%203D%20CAD%20News%20see%20as%20pure%20hypocrisy%2C%203DSystems%20asserted%20the%20following%20in%20its%20December%204th%202007%20press%20release%3A%0A%0A%22%E2%80%9CIt%20is%20regrettable%20that%20EnvisionTEC%20has%20chosen%20to%20issue%20a%20press%20release%20concerning%20its%20views%20with%20respect%20to%20its%20patents%20and%20our%20V-Flash%E2%84%A2%20Desktop%20Modeler.%20We%20prefer%20that%20legal%20issues%20be%20confined%20to%20the%20appropriate%20legal%20forum%20and%20that%20companies%20compete%20fairly%20in%20the%20marketplace%2C%E2%80%9D%20concluded%20Reichental.%20%E2%80%9CUnfortunately%2C%20EnvisionTEC%E2%80%99s%20public%20statements%20have%20left%20us%20with%20no%20alternative%20but%20to%20respond%20in%20order%20to%20make%20our%20distributors%20and%20customers%20aware%20of%20the%20facts%20and%20our%20position.%E2%80%9D%0A%0ANow%20then%2C%20who%20issued%20that%20first%20opening%20shot%2C%20publicized%20via%20press%20release%2C%20on%20March%209%2C%202006%3F%20It%20could%2C%20just%20perhaps%2C%20have%20been%203DSystems%2C%20non%3F%0A%0AAnd%20while%20members%20of%20the%20RP%20family%20continue%20to%20lob%20grenades%20back%20and%20forth%20as%20a%20form%20of%20distraction%20from%20the%20job%20at%20hand%2C%20rich%20cousin%20Stratasys%20continues%20to%20experience%20record%20growth.%20You%20can%20see%20more%20about%20the%20financial%20health%20of%20Stratasys%20and%203Dsystems%20at%20CADCAMNet%27s%20lead%20story%20last%20week%2C%20at%20www.cadcamnet.com.%20%28Free%20trial%20subscription%20or%20paid%20subscription%20required.%29%20%0A was not found on this server. That’s all we know.