Groupthink
 

 

Groupthink

Tendency for members of a group to move towards agreement with one another – can result in erroneous decisions and vast overconfidence.

 

Some symptoms of groupthink:

 

u

Shared overoptimism and excessive risk-taking by most or all group members;

u

Collective discounting of warnings and rationalizing away of inconvenient or contradictory information decision-makers feed off each other’s certainty of their mutual good judgement;

u

Stereotyping of opponents and adversaries, with group members seeing adversaries as too untrustworthy for negotiation or too stupid to pose a significant threat, and opponents or critics as too foolish or ill-informed for their alternative viewpoints to be taken seriously;

u

Pressuring or bullying (subtle and otherwise) of any group members showing signs of dissent;

u

Self-censoring by group members of misgivings about or conflicts with the seeming group consensus;

u

Emergence of self-appointed gatekeepers to protect the group from information and considerations which might challenge the group’s decision posture.

 

Correctives for or tacks to lessen groupthink include:

 

n

making strenuous efforts to seek information from a variety of sources outside the group;

n

of such outside sources, these should especially involve the presence of or contributions from people expected to disagree with the group;

n

there should be a thorough and fair-minded questioning of these outside parties and sources;

 

and

n

there should be at least one group member assigned as Devil’s advocate to full-bloodedly advance the best available arguments against the group’s preferred position or the course-of-action favoured, and whose offerings might provoke other group members to dig deeper and think more carefully about the issues, proposals, and alternatives which ought to be considered.

 

Whilst these correctives won’t guarantee its elimination, they make it likely that the risk of groupthink will diminish markedly.

 

(see also: Risky Shift effect, Groupthink, Social influences, Confirmation bias)

 

Back to: Glossary A-Z

 

Glossary of selected Judgement & Decision-making, Belief-related, and other Psychology terms A-Z »

 

» Return to belief, judgement, and clear thinking »

 
 
Labels: groupthink, Janis' 'groupthink', Irving Janis, tendency for members of a group to move towards agreement with one another, fair-minded questioning, 'correctives' and tacks to lessen Groupthink, thinking critically, independent-minded
The content on this page is provided by a Google Notebook user, and Google assumes no responsibility for this content.