CA1043123A - Use of modulated stimulus to improve detection sensitivity for signals from particles in a flow chamber - Google Patents
Use of modulated stimulus to improve detection sensitivity for signals from particles in a flow chamberInfo
- Publication number
- CA1043123A CA1043123A CA236,380A CA236380A CA1043123A CA 1043123 A CA1043123 A CA 1043123A CA 236380 A CA236380 A CA 236380A CA 1043123 A CA1043123 A CA 1043123A
- Authority
- CA
- Canada
- Prior art keywords
- particles
- interest
- light
- flow chamber
- signals
- Prior art date
- Legal status (The legal status is an assumption and is not a legal conclusion. Google has not performed a legal analysis and makes no representation as to the accuracy of the status listed.)
- Expired
Links
- 239000002245 particle Substances 0.000 title claims abstract description 88
- 238000001514 detection method Methods 0.000 title description 8
- 230000035945 sensitivity Effects 0.000 title description 5
- 230000004044 response Effects 0.000 claims abstract description 50
- 238000000034 method Methods 0.000 claims abstract description 26
- 239000000463 material Substances 0.000 claims description 21
- 239000012530 fluid Substances 0.000 claims description 20
- 230000000875 corresponding effect Effects 0.000 claims description 9
- 239000002131 composite material Substances 0.000 claims description 7
- 239000007850 fluorescent dye Substances 0.000 claims description 7
- 230000000903 blocking effect Effects 0.000 claims description 6
- 230000002596 correlated effect Effects 0.000 claims description 5
- 230000033228 biological regulation Effects 0.000 claims description 4
- 230000006835 compression Effects 0.000 claims description 3
- 238000007906 compression Methods 0.000 claims description 3
- 230000001186 cumulative effect Effects 0.000 claims 2
- 230000003111 delayed effect Effects 0.000 claims 1
- 210000004369 blood Anatomy 0.000 abstract description 5
- 239000008280 blood Substances 0.000 abstract description 5
- 239000013060 biological fluid Substances 0.000 abstract description 2
- 230000003252 repetitive effect Effects 0.000 abstract 1
- 210000004027 cell Anatomy 0.000 description 61
- 238000005286 illumination Methods 0.000 description 16
- 238000005259 measurement Methods 0.000 description 12
- 238000004458 analytical method Methods 0.000 description 8
- 230000008901 benefit Effects 0.000 description 6
- 210000000601 blood cell Anatomy 0.000 description 4
- 238000000926 separation method Methods 0.000 description 4
- 230000005540 biological transmission Effects 0.000 description 3
- 238000006243 chemical reaction Methods 0.000 description 3
- 238000006552 photochemical reaction Methods 0.000 description 3
- 238000010521 absorption reaction Methods 0.000 description 2
- 238000007796 conventional method Methods 0.000 description 2
- 230000001934 delay Effects 0.000 description 2
- 230000000694 effects Effects 0.000 description 2
- 230000006870 function Effects 0.000 description 2
- 230000010354 integration Effects 0.000 description 2
- 238000002955 isolation Methods 0.000 description 2
- 238000007557 optical granulometry Methods 0.000 description 2
- 238000005375 photometry Methods 0.000 description 2
- 206010056740 Genital discharge Diseases 0.000 description 1
- 230000002411 adverse Effects 0.000 description 1
- 238000000149 argon plasma sintering Methods 0.000 description 1
- 230000008859 change Effects 0.000 description 1
- 238000010276 construction Methods 0.000 description 1
- 230000008878 coupling Effects 0.000 description 1
- 238000010168 coupling process Methods 0.000 description 1
- 238000005859 coupling reaction Methods 0.000 description 1
- 230000007423 decrease Effects 0.000 description 1
- 230000001419 dependent effect Effects 0.000 description 1
- 238000013461 design Methods 0.000 description 1
- 230000001627 detrimental effect Effects 0.000 description 1
- 239000000975 dye Substances 0.000 description 1
- 230000005284 excitation Effects 0.000 description 1
- 230000005281 excited state Effects 0.000 description 1
- 238000003384 imaging method Methods 0.000 description 1
- 230000006872 improvement Effects 0.000 description 1
- 230000003993 interaction Effects 0.000 description 1
- 238000004519 manufacturing process Methods 0.000 description 1
- 230000007246 mechanism Effects 0.000 description 1
- 238000012986 modification Methods 0.000 description 1
- 230000004048 modification Effects 0.000 description 1
- 230000003287 optical effect Effects 0.000 description 1
- 230000010287 polarization Effects 0.000 description 1
- 229920000136 polysorbate Polymers 0.000 description 1
- 238000012545 processing Methods 0.000 description 1
- 102000004169 proteins and genes Human genes 0.000 description 1
- 108090000623 proteins and genes Proteins 0.000 description 1
- 230000010076 replication Effects 0.000 description 1
- 238000010186 staining Methods 0.000 description 1
- 230000000638 stimulation Effects 0.000 description 1
- 238000012546 transfer Methods 0.000 description 1
Classifications
-
- G—PHYSICS
- G01—MEASURING; TESTING
- G01N—INVESTIGATING OR ANALYSING MATERIALS BY DETERMINING THEIR CHEMICAL OR PHYSICAL PROPERTIES
- G01N15/00—Investigating characteristics of particles; Investigating permeability, pore-volume, or surface-area of porous materials
- G01N15/10—Investigating individual particles
- G01N15/14—Electro-optical investigation, e.g. flow cytometers
- G01N15/1434—Electro-optical investigation, e.g. flow cytometers using an analyser being characterised by its optical arrangement
-
- G01N2015/016—
-
- G—PHYSICS
- G01—MEASURING; TESTING
- G01N—INVESTIGATING OR ANALYSING MATERIALS BY DETERMINING THEIR CHEMICAL OR PHYSICAL PROPERTIES
- G01N15/00—Investigating characteristics of particles; Investigating permeability, pore-volume, or surface-area of porous materials
- G01N15/10—Investigating individual particles
- G01N15/14—Electro-optical investigation, e.g. flow cytometers
- G01N15/1434—Electro-optical investigation, e.g. flow cytometers using an analyser being characterised by its optical arrangement
- G01N2015/1447—Spatial selection
- G01N2015/145—Spatial selection by pattern of light, e.g. fringe pattern
Abstract
Abstract of the Declaration Method and apparatus for analyzing blood or other biological fluids containing cells or particles of interest by passing them sequentially through a narrow flow chamber where a repetitive physical stimulus, such as a plurality of beams of light, is spaced at intervals to form a code along the length of the flow chamber to elicit responses from the particles. These responses are then decoded and used to classify the particles according to type.
Description
~0~3~Z3 :
USE OF MODULATED STIMULUS TO IMPROVE DETECTION
SENSITIVITY FOR SIGNALS FROM PARTICLES
IN A FLOW CHAMBER
This invention relates to a method and apparatus for the analysis of blood or other biological fluids in which small particles, such as single cells, ; are detected and classified. The invention provides ; 5 a means of increasing the detection sensitivity for determining the response of particles to a physical stimulus, such as light, when the particles are passed through a narrow flow chamber. A typical example would . be in measuring the intensity of fluorescent emission from stained blood cells.
Since the particles are passed one by one, and usually quite rapidly, thru the flow chamber, the ~`-response signal is often so weak that adequate detec-tion and measurement is difficult. However, if the stimulus is repetitively, and periodically applied, and the successive responses appropriately detected, - then it is possible to add successive responses for each individual particle and obtain a single large response which is more suitable for detection and classification of the number and types of particles present in the sample.
Analysis of cells, such as blood cells, may be accomplished by staining the cells with a fluorescent dye and then detecting a fluorescent emission as individual cells pass through a narrow . ~
' ' ' ~ - . ' ' ~
.
, , illuminated flow chamber. U. S. Patents 3,788,744 and 3,819,270 illustrate conventional techniques and U. S. Patent 3,788,744 describes apparatus for such photoanalysis. This type of photoanalysis is usually performed on several million particles in any particu-lar sample. Since it is always desirable for the comp-lete sample to be measured in only a few minutes, the measurement time allowed for a single particle is in the order of micro-seconds. As a result, the total integrated signal output from a photodetector responsive to the fluorescent emissions of individual cells is ~ quite weak. If a more substantial signal is required : in order to discriminate between different classes of - particles, it is necessary to increase the measure-ment time by reducing the flow rate of particles through .- the flow chamber. Alternatively, the length of the measurment chamber may be increased and the particle concentration diluted to prevent the possibility that two particles will be in the measurement area of the flow chamber simultaneously. In either case, the total time for analysis of the entire sample is in- ;~
creased. The same problem exists whether the cell counter used is designed for photometric analysis, or - whether it operates on a principle of detecting differences other than fluorescent emission. For example, commercial blood cell counters are available ;~
which operate on the principle of distinguishing be-tween cells on the basis of electrical conductivity, light scattering, light blockage, or electrical ., ~, :
~043~z3 capacitance. U. S. Patent 3,811,841 describes a system employing light blockage in cell detection.
An object of the present invention is to provide a flow chamber measurement device incorporating pulse code techniques. Practice of the invention leads to increased sensitivity and higher counting rates than is currently possible with conventional systems.
It is a further object of the invention to provide increased measurement sensitivity without a corresponding increase in the illumination or other physical stimulus applied to the measured cells. The most obvious way of increasing sensi~ivity in photometric analysis of blood cells would be to simply increase the light source intensity. However, a brighter source is more costly, produces extra heat, and requires more careful shielding to prevent stray illumination from reaching the fluorescent detector. In addition, detrimental side effects accompany an increase in light intensity. Undesirable photochemical reactions between the fluorescent dye and protein in the cells may be induced by the more powerful illumination intensity.
- This distorts the analysis performed and precludes any subsequent study or analysis of the cells after they have been processed through the flow chamber.
An increase in the illumination intensity applied will increase the probability of a photochemical reaction for two reasons. First, the average lifetime in the excited state for the cells of interest in the flow chamber is increased, resulting in a greater possibility of collision between the excited particle with another molecule during this time. Consequently, the rate of undesired chemical reactions increases.
In addition, except for rare instances in which there is a 100% conversion of the increased level of stimuli upon the particle of interest, the increased stimuli will tend to heat the cell, and thereby further promote : undesired chemical reactions.
Accordingly, utilization of the present in-vention provides a means to obtain increased signal-to- ~
10 noise ratio from the response detector without requiring ~-increased illumination intensity or electrical potential.
In one broad aspect, this invention is an apparatus for distinguishing between discrete particles of different materials entrained in a fluid ~- 15 which exhibit distinguishable responses to physical .
stimulus comprising a narrow channel through which fluid containing entrained particles of material flows, ~;
flow regulation means for maintaining a predetermined flow rate through said channel, means for exerting a spatially discontinuous physical stimulus at positions longitudinally spaced at predetermined intervals along said channel on said particles of material entrained in said fluid to elicit separate responses from each particle of material at each of the aforesaid positions which responses collectively comprise a coded response, transducer means for detecting the separate responses from said discrete particles of material at each of the aforesaid positions and for generating corres-. .
. I , '- ' , : ' '' ... , . . : ~
; 1043~23 ponding signals, decoding means connected to said : transducer means and correlated with the flow rate and the spacing of the aforesaid positions to decode said coded response and to combine into a single de-coded signal the separate signals corresponding to the separate responses emanating from each particle of material detected in response to the physical :- stimulus. Particles of different materials may be classified according to their responses to the physical stimulus.
In another aspect this invention is a method of distinguishing between discrete particles of interest in a fluid comprising: contacting said particles of - interest with a fluorescent dye, which will cause them to fluoresce under a beam of light, passing a fluid . . .
containing said particles of interest through a trans- I -parent flow chamber, exposing said flow chamber to a :` plurality of transverse beams of light at positions spaced at predetermined intervals along the length of said flow chamber to elicit coded signals from particles of interest in the form of discrete fluores-cent emissions therefrom in response to each beam of light, detecting said coded signals using a trans-- ducer producing outputs for each coded signal, decoding said coded signal outputs for individual particles of interest by consolidating the signals to produce a composite output signal for each particle of interest .-- detected, classifying the particles of interest in accordance with differences in the composite output : -6-, , :
:
:
signals, and quantitatively tabulating the particles of interest aceording to the classifications selected.
A method of treating the particles of interest with an appropriate dye is explained in U. S. Patent 3,819,270.
A further specialized application of the present invention involves the application of a .
plurality of physical stimuli, such as light beams ; of different wavelength, to the particles of interest.
Multiple physical stimuli may be applied to the particles, either simultaneously or sequentially, using one or more code functions to produce multiple . . .
responses from appropriate transducers. These trans-~ ducer outputs are decoded with appropriate decoding :- , means to provide multiple signals from a single -particle. Such signals may be combined in appropriate combinations and/or ratios so as to provide means of ; elassifying the sample partieles based on the outcomes of these eombinations and ratios. A teehnique for the use of light beams of different wavelength to produee a variety of eombined responses in order to identify several elasses of partieles is set forth in U. S.
Patent 3,822,095. -The invention may be more elearly understood ; 25 by referenee to the aeeompanying illustrations.
Fig. l illustrates typical photodetector response to a plurality of individual cells in a eonventlonal photoanalytie deteetor.
,'' ~'.
7 ~
: ; :
- , . .
` ~0431Z3 Fig. 2 illustrates photodetector response to a plurality of individual cells in a conventional photo- --analytic detector in which the flow rate has been in-creased.
Fig. 3 illustrates a photodetector plus de-- coding means output at the flow rate of Fig. 2 using - the techniques of the present invention.
Fig. 4 illustrates an apparatus constructed according to the present invention.
Fig. 5 illustrates an alternative embodiment of a portion of the apparatus of Fig. 4.
-~ Fig. 6 is an enlarged view of a portion of Fig. 4.
Fig. 7 illustrates the ideal photodetector output from a single cell of interest utilizing the present invention.
Fig. 8 graphically depicts the manner in which the coded signal of the present invention is decoded.
Fig. 9 graphically depicts the output of - - the decoding device of the present invention.
In a conventional photoanalytic device suitable for determining the extent to which cells of different types are present in a given blood sample, ; 25 the cells are made to flow one by one through a small capillary tube which is illuminated by imaging - a bright source of light through a microscope ob~ective lens. A single beam of light passes transversely through the capillary tube. By appro-'' ' ' priately designing the optics~ it is possible to - obtain a uniformly illuminated region within the ~, capillary tube so that when a single cell passes through this region, the fluorescent light output appears as a single output pulse. The amplitude of the pulse will vary depending upon the extent to which - the cell within the region of illumination has absorbed fluorescent dye.
In a typical application of such a conven-; 10 tional photoanalytic device, analysis is performed by taking a differential white cell count of a blood sample. Prior to analysis, the blood is mixed with a fluorescent stain as explained in detail in U. S.
Patent 3,819,270. The different types of white cells will absorb differently the amounts of stain, and will therefore yield fluorescent emissions of varying intensity or wavelength when illuminated under a fluorescent microscope. It is thereby possible to perform a similar analysis by passing the cells sequentially through a narrow flow chamber, as des-cribed previously, and to determine which type of cell is passing through the capillary tube by noting the ~ amplitude of the pulse received from the photodetector.
- This pulse amplitude from the photodetector is directly - 25 proportional to the strength of the fluorescent emission from the cell which is passed to the photodetector.
- Over a period of time the photodetector output in a differential white cell counter using a conventional photoanalytic device will be similar to -. ~
_ g_ .: '' - ~' ' .:, .
~ ~ 1043123 - that depicted in Fig. 1. From Fig. 1, the passage of three cells sequentially through the flow chamber is noted. The first two cells responded to the beam of illumination by fluorescing and producing photodetector outputs 45 of amplitude level B during the periods of time indicated. The final cell which was detected responded by producing a photodetector output 44 of a greater amplitude A. Between detected cells, an ambient noise level indicated as 43 prevailed.
From Fig. 1 it can be seen that it is possible, using conventional techniques, to count the number of cells producing detector outputs of amplitude A se-parately from the number of cells producing photodetec-tor outputs of amplitude B. The difference in cell 15 count is useful for medical diagnostic purposes. It ~ -should be pointed out, however, that only a limited flow rate through the capillary tube can be achieved with conventional cell counters. If the flow rate is increased above an upper limit, the detector becomes insensitive to the different types of cells passing through the capillary tube. The detector output in such a situation is illustrated in Fig. 2. In Fig. 2, it is virtually impossible to distinguish between cells of one type producing photodetector pulses 41 and cells of another type producing photodetector responses 40.
This is because the presence of noise (indicated by the : numeral designation 42 in Fig. 2) makes it difficult to determine which type of cell is present unless the output pulse is long enough in duration so that an :
' 1043~.Z3 ' accurate estimate of its average value can be obtained.
This requires the length of the illuminated region in -~ the flow chamber and the velocity of the cells through this region be ad~usted relative to each other in order to obtain the necessary pulse duration. To obtain discrimination between the two cell types at a higher flow rate, it is necessary to increase the amplitude of the fluorescent output signals in some manner so that the fluorescent signal differential becomes more pronounced. The most obvious solution is to simply increase the source intensity. As previously explained, however, this is not practical because of the attendant increase in probability of photochemical reaction.
Using the pulse coded technique of the present inven-tion, however, it is possible to increase signal-to-noise ; ratio without increasing illumination intensity.
If instead of a uniformly illuminated region the flow chamber contains a much longer, randomly structured region of illumination in which a plurality of beams of light pass transversely through the flow chamber at fixed positions spaced longitudinally at predetermined intervals along the length of the flow chamber, a cell passing through the flow chamber will ..
produce a different response. More specifically, a cell passing through the flow chamber will produce a series of short pulses as in Fig. 7, instead of the single long pulse. These pulses occur whenever the cell passes through one of the several beams of light.
The illumlnation pattern of the beams of light is --.
:: , so structured that there is a uniquely defined centroid which may be located even if the output signals from sequential particles partially overlap. The illumina-tion pattern formed by the plurality of light beams may be considered to be a code that is employed in the present invention. The illumination pattern of Fig. 7 is merely an illustrative example, and it will be recog-nized by those skilled in the art of signal detection theory that the embodiment described incorporates the techniques of pulse code transmission and matched filter signal detection; therefore several other possible code patterns exist and are well known.
The embodiment of Fig. 4 is designed to - produce the photodetector response illustrated in ~ 15 Fig. 7. A light source 1 which may be an arc lamp, -; laser, or other sufficiently bright source, is imaged !~:
by an appropriate condensor lens 2 to provide uniform illumination of a coding mask 3. This mask contains the code function as a transmission pattern. Microscope ob~ective lens 4 forms a minified image of the mask 3 - in the flow chamber or channel 14 formed by the capillary tube 13. The flow channel 14 is of sufficiently narrow width that discrete particles, such as the cell 12, are forced to flow in single file. Were this not the case, coincident signals would occur which would confuse the processing of data. The mask 3 results in the production of a plurality of beams of light Bl through B7. These beams, Bl through B7, pass trans-versely through the flow chamber 14 at flxed positions . .
1~)43123 spaced longitudinally at predetermined intervals along the length of the flow chamber. As a single cell 12 passes in the direction of flow indicated by the arrow : in Fig. 4, it ~irst encounters the beam Bl. When illuminated by beam Bl, the cell 12 emits a fluorescent output which produces a photodetector response P1 as in Fig. 7. By the same token, beam B2 produces photo-detector response P2, beam B3 produces response P3, and so on. It is to be understood that suitable flow ~ -rate regulation means of conventional design maintains a constant flow rate through the channel 14.
The fluorescent light output of Fig. 7 is collected by a second microscope ob~ective lens 15 and - is conveyed to a photodetector in the form of a photo-multiplier tube 17. The presence of a blocking filter 16 prevents direct light from the source 1 from passing -to the photomultiplier 17. The blocking filter 16-interposed between the flow chamber 14 and the photo-detector 17 selectively blocks the passage of light from the beams Bl through B7, and preferentially passes light produced by fluorescense of the cell 12 in the fluid stream in the flow chamber 14. Blocking occurs because the fluorescent output in the form of pulses Pl through P7 is at a wavelength different from that of the beams Bl through B7. Blocking filter 16 is selected to allow the passage of light of the same wavelength as the fluorescent emissions, but to block light having a wavelength corresponding to that of direct light trans-mission from the light source 1. Alternatively, in . ~
; ~043123 the case of fluorescent emission, b]ocking of the illumination beam may be effectively accomplished by the orienting the detector perpendicular to the propagation axis of the illumination light in a plane which is both transverse to the direction of flow in the flow cell and which also contains the propagation axis of the illumination light. In Fig. 4, the decoding means is in the form of a delay line 19 with delay I line taps and amplifiers 21 through 27 feeding into an addition circuit 20. The output signals from the ;~ decoder are conveyed to an electronic processor 28 which counts and classifies the cells in the desired manner and stores the tabulated counts of the particles -of interest according to the classifications selected in the registers 29, 30 and 31.
; In the embodiment of the apparatus of the invention illustrated, the mask 3 is interposed between the flow chamber 14 and the light source 1 and has apertures spaced therein at coded intervals to allow the beams of light Bl through B7 to emanate from the apertures and strike the flow chamber 14 at predeter-mined spaced positions as illustrated in Fig. 6. In the embodiment illustrated, the spacing between adjacent light beams decreases proceeding in the direction of the flow. More specifically, the distance between successive beams is determined by taking the difference of the square roots of their respective numbers in the sequence and multiplying by a scale factor. Thus the first and second beams are spaced by ~2 - ~'1 times the :, ~ 1043123 ~ ~
- scale factor, the second and third are spaced by ~3 - ~2 times the scale factor and so forth. From this pattern of spacing of the beams Bl through B7, it can be seen that for a constant flow rate through the flow chamber 14, a single cell, 12, will produce from detector 17 a train of output pulses as shown in Fig. 7. These pulses are amplified by amplifier 18, and then passed to delay line 19.
Delay line 19 has N-l taps, where N is the . l number of pulses in the code. These taps have respec-tive delays which correspond to the spacing between illumination beams B6 and B7, B5 and B6, and so forth.
In other words, for a general code, the taps on the delay line produce a delay which corresponds to the pulse spacing obtained by running the code train back- ~ -wards in time. These outputs, from delay line 19, are passed to amplifiers as indicated, and the outputs of the lines 21-27 and their associated amplifiers 26-27a are passed to adder circuit 20. The decoding means ; 20 of the invention is thereby correlated with the spacing of the beam position. It should be noted that no :
artificial delay exists on line 27.
The operative effect of the lines 21 through 27 is best lllustrated by reference to the contents of the adder circuit 20 depicted in Fig. 8. For a cell - 12 passing through the flow channel 14, a series of pulses is generated as illustrated in Fig. 7 and as previously explained. By virtue of the line 27 and the delay line taps 21 through 26, each of the pulses Pl ~; -15-' ' ~ ~. ~' , .
.
.
through P7 is replicated 7 times. Exemplary delays and pulse arrlval times are indicated on the abscissa of Fig. 8. The replication of the pulse Pl from line 27 is the first pulse to reach the adder circuit 20. The pulse Pl from delay line tap 26 is the second pulse to reach the adder circuit 20. The pulses P2 from line 27 and Pl from line 25 reach the adder circuit 27 almost simultaneously to produce a small voltage spike 36 - in Fig. 9. It should be noted, however, that no more than a maximum of two pulses are received simultaneously by the adder 20 until time Ts in Fig. 8. At time T
the pulses Pl from line 21, P2 from line 22, P3 from line 23, P4 from line 24, P5 from line 25, P6 from line 26, and P7 from line 27 all coincide in time. The result is a very large pulse spike 35 as indicated in Fig. 9. Spike-35 is much greater than the smaller ; spikes 36 produced by incidental coincidences of simultaneous pulses, such as the pulse Pl from line 25, and pulæe P2 ~rom line 27 as previously noted.
The decoding of the contents of the adder circuit 20 in Fig. 8 to produce the adder output of Fig. 9 is known as autocorrelation. Using autocorrela-tion, the response of the decoder has a single narrow voltage peak 35 with a position in time determined by the centroid in time of the original code. The total signal strength of this peak 35 depends upon the number Or pulses in the code which is controlled by the length of the flow chamber 14, while the width of the peak depends upon the width of the beams Bl through B7.
1~43123 "
These two parameters are essentially independent of each other. Thus, successive particles 12 proceeding through the capillary tube 13 need only be separated sufficiently so that the narrow peaks of thèir auto-correlated output signals do not overlap, and the ~ flow chamber may be increased to any desired length, - subject to other practical limitations, in order to obtain sufficient signal strength for the desired particle discrimination.
The code employed in the invention is care-fully chosen so that no more than 2 pulses (such as pulse Pl from line 25 and pulse P2 from line 27) coin-cidentally overlap at any time. The peak amplitude or signal strength of the voltage spike 35 from adder circuit 20 is proportional to the number of pulses in the code. That is, voltage spike 35 (unamplified) would haYe an amplitude seven times as great as any single one of the pulses in Fig. 7.
The decoded photodetector output over a period of time is illustrated in Fig. 3. Fig. 3 re-- presents the response of the device to the passage of several sequential cells of different types through . .
the capillary tubes 13. The flow rate employed with the device of the present invention to achieve the out-put of Fig. 3 is approximately the same as that used to produce the photodetector output of Fig. 2, which employs a conventional apparatus. It can be seen that contrary to the output of Fig. 2, the output of Fig. 3 can be resolved so that cells of a type A producing ~ pulse spikes 37 can be distinguished from pulses of a ; type B producing lower amplitude pulse spikes 38.
The amplitude of spikes 37 is equal to Kn . A, while the amplitude of spike 38 is equal to Kn . B, where Kn is a number greater than 1 and is proportional to the number of pulses in the code. A and B are the same amplitudes depicted in Fig. 1.
While the apparatus depicted in Fig. 4 is probably the preferred construction of the invention, an alternative form of the decoding means is illus-trated in Fig. 5. Codes that contain multiple orders, such as a square wave F.M. "chirp," can be designed so that the multiple orders do not overlap in frequency.
In this case a decoding device can be constructed by 15 passing the detector output signal from the amplifier 18 through a band pass filter 32 which selects one of the orders, usually the fundamental order. The output from the band pass filter 32 may be passed through a pulse compression means 33 in the form of a dispersive 20 delay line to produce autocorrelated output signals for individual particles. The low pass filter 32 blocks high frequency output, including most noise, from the photomultiplier 17 but passes low frequency outputs such as the pulses Pl through P7. That is, 25 the pulse compression means 33 produces a signal proportional to an integrated sum of the pulses Pl through P7 for a particular particle or cell 12 in the flow channel 14, which signal is passed to an amplifier 34.
In either embodiment, the electronic processor 28 forms a signal classification means for classifying the decoded output signals according to preselected pulse amplitude ranges. The electronic processor 28 also serves as a pulse tabulating means for counting the number of decoded output signals in each selected classification, and for tabulating these counts in the !' registers 29, 30 and 31. In this way, different types of particles of interest having definitely identifiable fluorescent characteristics may be tabulated separately.
There are a number of different operating conditions under which flow cells employing the pulse coding technique of the present invention demonstrate significant advantages over conventional flow cell arrangements. Conversely, there are some adverse conditions for flow cell measurement in which the use of this invention is not likely to produce an improve-ment, although neither will it exhibit inferior per~or- --- mance. Specifically, the pulse coded flow cell techni-que described herein produces a distinct advantage where particle discrimination is based on the outcome of several different measurements, for example, multiple fluorescence measurements, and it is desired to use a -single detector for observing all measurements. In this instance several measurements may be desired, for example fluorescence at different wavelengths, on each particle. The standard way of doing this is to image separate channels into the flow cell for each wave-length, and then image the output of each channel, thru ' :
.
isolation filters, to a separate detector. If instead, a set of orthogonal code words are utilized, then they can be imaged into the flow chamber in an overlapping pattern. The output signals can then go to a single detector, without the need of isolation filters, and the ~ . .
subsequent signals can be separated by the orthogonality property. Of course, it is necessary that there be no interaction, such as internal energy transfer, Prom simultaneous excitation of the different fluorescent mechanisms. Alternatively, the same code word could be used for each channel, and simply imaged into the flow cell with a slight offset between channels. By time gating with one extra detector, it should be possible to separate the output signals for each channel.
15This invention is also particularly ad-vantageous where there is insufficient signal because of source or thermal detector noise. There is a definite gain in signal-to-noise from using pulse code techniques. The signal power per unit bandwidth is increased with increasing length of the pulse train, - while the noise power per unit bandwidth remains constant.
Flow cell measurement may be desired under conditions where there is essentially no noise, but the signal is a small change from a high bias level which may drift slowly in time. If the pulse is short, and reasonably intense, then a simple AC coupling of the detector output may be adequate for separation of signal from background. If, however, the signal pulse is not sufficiently intense, the only to increase ~043123 signal energy is by means of time integration. This 1 results in two disadvantages; first the count rate is lowered, and second, a simple AC coupled detector is no longer feasible for separating signal from background. By using a pulse code technique, the desired signal can be made to appear as a wideband signal centered about an offset carrier frequency, thus allowing both a high count rate, and easy separa- -tion of signal from background. If the signal occurs as a short pulse, then a simple AC coupled detector may be adequate. If the signal must be kept long and detected by means of time integration, then the use of a pulse coded technique allows both a high count rate and easy separation of signal and background.
On the other hand, no significant advantage is realized by employing pulse coded techniques where there is insufficient signal because of quantum lim~ta~
tions. This may occur where a background level is ~-present or where single pulses from individual particles are quantum limited, but background is essentially non-existent. In the former case there is no gain signal to noise ratio using pulse coded techniques, while in the latter case the signal to noise gain depends upon the count rate. At the maximum possible count ;~ 25 rate, there is essentially no gain using pulse coded techniques, since the constant stream of particles adjacent to the one of interest appears as a noise - producing background.
. .
.' "' ' ' 043~23 Similarly, there is no particular advantage to pulse coded techniques where the signal tends to vary because of changing particle position or orienta-`; tion during the time it is in the flow chamber.
However, if the pulse train can be made long enough for a good average on particle orientation to be obtained, then there is some gain in signal-to-noise, especially in combination with detector or source noise.
In addition, there is the advantage of easy separation of signal and background compared to a method which simply integrates in one long pulse.
Combinations of the foregoing conditions are of course possible, and the advantage, if any, of using a pulse code technique would essentially be determined by that member of the combination which tends to give the smallest gain.
~- The form of the invention depicted has been given for purposes of illustration only. Other forms of the device and the techniques in the practice of a method may be utilized to measure scattered light, absorption, or combinations of scattering absorption and fluorescence. In addition, other properties be-sides optical characteristics may be measured with appropriate instruments. These properties would in-clude electronic charge, dialectric polarization, or electrical conductivity. The embodiments of this in-vention for measuring such characteristics would necessarily include appropriate modifications in the - flow chamber, form of stimulation of a signal ,. . . . . . .
1043123 i~: :
dependent upon the desired characteristic, and means for detecting the signal so produced.
' ' ~
. - , ~, . ~ '.
~ , ~
. ~ .
,. ~.
-23- -:
.. . . . .
i, , , ~ . ,
USE OF MODULATED STIMULUS TO IMPROVE DETECTION
SENSITIVITY FOR SIGNALS FROM PARTICLES
IN A FLOW CHAMBER
This invention relates to a method and apparatus for the analysis of blood or other biological fluids in which small particles, such as single cells, ; are detected and classified. The invention provides ; 5 a means of increasing the detection sensitivity for determining the response of particles to a physical stimulus, such as light, when the particles are passed through a narrow flow chamber. A typical example would . be in measuring the intensity of fluorescent emission from stained blood cells.
Since the particles are passed one by one, and usually quite rapidly, thru the flow chamber, the ~`-response signal is often so weak that adequate detec-tion and measurement is difficult. However, if the stimulus is repetitively, and periodically applied, and the successive responses appropriately detected, - then it is possible to add successive responses for each individual particle and obtain a single large response which is more suitable for detection and classification of the number and types of particles present in the sample.
Analysis of cells, such as blood cells, may be accomplished by staining the cells with a fluorescent dye and then detecting a fluorescent emission as individual cells pass through a narrow . ~
' ' ' ~ - . ' ' ~
.
, , illuminated flow chamber. U. S. Patents 3,788,744 and 3,819,270 illustrate conventional techniques and U. S. Patent 3,788,744 describes apparatus for such photoanalysis. This type of photoanalysis is usually performed on several million particles in any particu-lar sample. Since it is always desirable for the comp-lete sample to be measured in only a few minutes, the measurement time allowed for a single particle is in the order of micro-seconds. As a result, the total integrated signal output from a photodetector responsive to the fluorescent emissions of individual cells is ~ quite weak. If a more substantial signal is required : in order to discriminate between different classes of - particles, it is necessary to increase the measure-ment time by reducing the flow rate of particles through .- the flow chamber. Alternatively, the length of the measurment chamber may be increased and the particle concentration diluted to prevent the possibility that two particles will be in the measurement area of the flow chamber simultaneously. In either case, the total time for analysis of the entire sample is in- ;~
creased. The same problem exists whether the cell counter used is designed for photometric analysis, or - whether it operates on a principle of detecting differences other than fluorescent emission. For example, commercial blood cell counters are available ;~
which operate on the principle of distinguishing be-tween cells on the basis of electrical conductivity, light scattering, light blockage, or electrical ., ~, :
~043~z3 capacitance. U. S. Patent 3,811,841 describes a system employing light blockage in cell detection.
An object of the present invention is to provide a flow chamber measurement device incorporating pulse code techniques. Practice of the invention leads to increased sensitivity and higher counting rates than is currently possible with conventional systems.
It is a further object of the invention to provide increased measurement sensitivity without a corresponding increase in the illumination or other physical stimulus applied to the measured cells. The most obvious way of increasing sensi~ivity in photometric analysis of blood cells would be to simply increase the light source intensity. However, a brighter source is more costly, produces extra heat, and requires more careful shielding to prevent stray illumination from reaching the fluorescent detector. In addition, detrimental side effects accompany an increase in light intensity. Undesirable photochemical reactions between the fluorescent dye and protein in the cells may be induced by the more powerful illumination intensity.
- This distorts the analysis performed and precludes any subsequent study or analysis of the cells after they have been processed through the flow chamber.
An increase in the illumination intensity applied will increase the probability of a photochemical reaction for two reasons. First, the average lifetime in the excited state for the cells of interest in the flow chamber is increased, resulting in a greater possibility of collision between the excited particle with another molecule during this time. Consequently, the rate of undesired chemical reactions increases.
In addition, except for rare instances in which there is a 100% conversion of the increased level of stimuli upon the particle of interest, the increased stimuli will tend to heat the cell, and thereby further promote : undesired chemical reactions.
Accordingly, utilization of the present in-vention provides a means to obtain increased signal-to- ~
10 noise ratio from the response detector without requiring ~-increased illumination intensity or electrical potential.
In one broad aspect, this invention is an apparatus for distinguishing between discrete particles of different materials entrained in a fluid ~- 15 which exhibit distinguishable responses to physical .
stimulus comprising a narrow channel through which fluid containing entrained particles of material flows, ~;
flow regulation means for maintaining a predetermined flow rate through said channel, means for exerting a spatially discontinuous physical stimulus at positions longitudinally spaced at predetermined intervals along said channel on said particles of material entrained in said fluid to elicit separate responses from each particle of material at each of the aforesaid positions which responses collectively comprise a coded response, transducer means for detecting the separate responses from said discrete particles of material at each of the aforesaid positions and for generating corres-. .
. I , '- ' , : ' '' ... , . . : ~
; 1043~23 ponding signals, decoding means connected to said : transducer means and correlated with the flow rate and the spacing of the aforesaid positions to decode said coded response and to combine into a single de-coded signal the separate signals corresponding to the separate responses emanating from each particle of material detected in response to the physical :- stimulus. Particles of different materials may be classified according to their responses to the physical stimulus.
In another aspect this invention is a method of distinguishing between discrete particles of interest in a fluid comprising: contacting said particles of - interest with a fluorescent dye, which will cause them to fluoresce under a beam of light, passing a fluid . . .
containing said particles of interest through a trans- I -parent flow chamber, exposing said flow chamber to a :` plurality of transverse beams of light at positions spaced at predetermined intervals along the length of said flow chamber to elicit coded signals from particles of interest in the form of discrete fluores-cent emissions therefrom in response to each beam of light, detecting said coded signals using a trans-- ducer producing outputs for each coded signal, decoding said coded signal outputs for individual particles of interest by consolidating the signals to produce a composite output signal for each particle of interest .-- detected, classifying the particles of interest in accordance with differences in the composite output : -6-, , :
:
:
signals, and quantitatively tabulating the particles of interest aceording to the classifications selected.
A method of treating the particles of interest with an appropriate dye is explained in U. S. Patent 3,819,270.
A further specialized application of the present invention involves the application of a .
plurality of physical stimuli, such as light beams ; of different wavelength, to the particles of interest.
Multiple physical stimuli may be applied to the particles, either simultaneously or sequentially, using one or more code functions to produce multiple . . .
responses from appropriate transducers. These trans-~ ducer outputs are decoded with appropriate decoding :- , means to provide multiple signals from a single -particle. Such signals may be combined in appropriate combinations and/or ratios so as to provide means of ; elassifying the sample partieles based on the outcomes of these eombinations and ratios. A teehnique for the use of light beams of different wavelength to produee a variety of eombined responses in order to identify several elasses of partieles is set forth in U. S.
Patent 3,822,095. -The invention may be more elearly understood ; 25 by referenee to the aeeompanying illustrations.
Fig. l illustrates typical photodetector response to a plurality of individual cells in a eonventlonal photoanalytie deteetor.
,'' ~'.
7 ~
: ; :
- , . .
` ~0431Z3 Fig. 2 illustrates photodetector response to a plurality of individual cells in a conventional photo- --analytic detector in which the flow rate has been in-creased.
Fig. 3 illustrates a photodetector plus de-- coding means output at the flow rate of Fig. 2 using - the techniques of the present invention.
Fig. 4 illustrates an apparatus constructed according to the present invention.
Fig. 5 illustrates an alternative embodiment of a portion of the apparatus of Fig. 4.
-~ Fig. 6 is an enlarged view of a portion of Fig. 4.
Fig. 7 illustrates the ideal photodetector output from a single cell of interest utilizing the present invention.
Fig. 8 graphically depicts the manner in which the coded signal of the present invention is decoded.
Fig. 9 graphically depicts the output of - - the decoding device of the present invention.
In a conventional photoanalytic device suitable for determining the extent to which cells of different types are present in a given blood sample, ; 25 the cells are made to flow one by one through a small capillary tube which is illuminated by imaging - a bright source of light through a microscope ob~ective lens. A single beam of light passes transversely through the capillary tube. By appro-'' ' ' priately designing the optics~ it is possible to - obtain a uniformly illuminated region within the ~, capillary tube so that when a single cell passes through this region, the fluorescent light output appears as a single output pulse. The amplitude of the pulse will vary depending upon the extent to which - the cell within the region of illumination has absorbed fluorescent dye.
In a typical application of such a conven-; 10 tional photoanalytic device, analysis is performed by taking a differential white cell count of a blood sample. Prior to analysis, the blood is mixed with a fluorescent stain as explained in detail in U. S.
Patent 3,819,270. The different types of white cells will absorb differently the amounts of stain, and will therefore yield fluorescent emissions of varying intensity or wavelength when illuminated under a fluorescent microscope. It is thereby possible to perform a similar analysis by passing the cells sequentially through a narrow flow chamber, as des-cribed previously, and to determine which type of cell is passing through the capillary tube by noting the ~ amplitude of the pulse received from the photodetector.
- This pulse amplitude from the photodetector is directly - 25 proportional to the strength of the fluorescent emission from the cell which is passed to the photodetector.
- Over a period of time the photodetector output in a differential white cell counter using a conventional photoanalytic device will be similar to -. ~
_ g_ .: '' - ~' ' .:, .
~ ~ 1043123 - that depicted in Fig. 1. From Fig. 1, the passage of three cells sequentially through the flow chamber is noted. The first two cells responded to the beam of illumination by fluorescing and producing photodetector outputs 45 of amplitude level B during the periods of time indicated. The final cell which was detected responded by producing a photodetector output 44 of a greater amplitude A. Between detected cells, an ambient noise level indicated as 43 prevailed.
From Fig. 1 it can be seen that it is possible, using conventional techniques, to count the number of cells producing detector outputs of amplitude A se-parately from the number of cells producing photodetec-tor outputs of amplitude B. The difference in cell 15 count is useful for medical diagnostic purposes. It ~ -should be pointed out, however, that only a limited flow rate through the capillary tube can be achieved with conventional cell counters. If the flow rate is increased above an upper limit, the detector becomes insensitive to the different types of cells passing through the capillary tube. The detector output in such a situation is illustrated in Fig. 2. In Fig. 2, it is virtually impossible to distinguish between cells of one type producing photodetector pulses 41 and cells of another type producing photodetector responses 40.
This is because the presence of noise (indicated by the : numeral designation 42 in Fig. 2) makes it difficult to determine which type of cell is present unless the output pulse is long enough in duration so that an :
' 1043~.Z3 ' accurate estimate of its average value can be obtained.
This requires the length of the illuminated region in -~ the flow chamber and the velocity of the cells through this region be ad~usted relative to each other in order to obtain the necessary pulse duration. To obtain discrimination between the two cell types at a higher flow rate, it is necessary to increase the amplitude of the fluorescent output signals in some manner so that the fluorescent signal differential becomes more pronounced. The most obvious solution is to simply increase the source intensity. As previously explained, however, this is not practical because of the attendant increase in probability of photochemical reaction.
Using the pulse coded technique of the present inven-tion, however, it is possible to increase signal-to-noise ; ratio without increasing illumination intensity.
If instead of a uniformly illuminated region the flow chamber contains a much longer, randomly structured region of illumination in which a plurality of beams of light pass transversely through the flow chamber at fixed positions spaced longitudinally at predetermined intervals along the length of the flow chamber, a cell passing through the flow chamber will ..
produce a different response. More specifically, a cell passing through the flow chamber will produce a series of short pulses as in Fig. 7, instead of the single long pulse. These pulses occur whenever the cell passes through one of the several beams of light.
The illumlnation pattern of the beams of light is --.
:: , so structured that there is a uniquely defined centroid which may be located even if the output signals from sequential particles partially overlap. The illumina-tion pattern formed by the plurality of light beams may be considered to be a code that is employed in the present invention. The illumination pattern of Fig. 7 is merely an illustrative example, and it will be recog-nized by those skilled in the art of signal detection theory that the embodiment described incorporates the techniques of pulse code transmission and matched filter signal detection; therefore several other possible code patterns exist and are well known.
The embodiment of Fig. 4 is designed to - produce the photodetector response illustrated in ~ 15 Fig. 7. A light source 1 which may be an arc lamp, -; laser, or other sufficiently bright source, is imaged !~:
by an appropriate condensor lens 2 to provide uniform illumination of a coding mask 3. This mask contains the code function as a transmission pattern. Microscope ob~ective lens 4 forms a minified image of the mask 3 - in the flow chamber or channel 14 formed by the capillary tube 13. The flow channel 14 is of sufficiently narrow width that discrete particles, such as the cell 12, are forced to flow in single file. Were this not the case, coincident signals would occur which would confuse the processing of data. The mask 3 results in the production of a plurality of beams of light Bl through B7. These beams, Bl through B7, pass trans-versely through the flow chamber 14 at flxed positions . .
1~)43123 spaced longitudinally at predetermined intervals along the length of the flow chamber. As a single cell 12 passes in the direction of flow indicated by the arrow : in Fig. 4, it ~irst encounters the beam Bl. When illuminated by beam Bl, the cell 12 emits a fluorescent output which produces a photodetector response P1 as in Fig. 7. By the same token, beam B2 produces photo-detector response P2, beam B3 produces response P3, and so on. It is to be understood that suitable flow ~ -rate regulation means of conventional design maintains a constant flow rate through the channel 14.
The fluorescent light output of Fig. 7 is collected by a second microscope ob~ective lens 15 and - is conveyed to a photodetector in the form of a photo-multiplier tube 17. The presence of a blocking filter 16 prevents direct light from the source 1 from passing -to the photomultiplier 17. The blocking filter 16-interposed between the flow chamber 14 and the photo-detector 17 selectively blocks the passage of light from the beams Bl through B7, and preferentially passes light produced by fluorescense of the cell 12 in the fluid stream in the flow chamber 14. Blocking occurs because the fluorescent output in the form of pulses Pl through P7 is at a wavelength different from that of the beams Bl through B7. Blocking filter 16 is selected to allow the passage of light of the same wavelength as the fluorescent emissions, but to block light having a wavelength corresponding to that of direct light trans-mission from the light source 1. Alternatively, in . ~
; ~043123 the case of fluorescent emission, b]ocking of the illumination beam may be effectively accomplished by the orienting the detector perpendicular to the propagation axis of the illumination light in a plane which is both transverse to the direction of flow in the flow cell and which also contains the propagation axis of the illumination light. In Fig. 4, the decoding means is in the form of a delay line 19 with delay I line taps and amplifiers 21 through 27 feeding into an addition circuit 20. The output signals from the ;~ decoder are conveyed to an electronic processor 28 which counts and classifies the cells in the desired manner and stores the tabulated counts of the particles -of interest according to the classifications selected in the registers 29, 30 and 31.
; In the embodiment of the apparatus of the invention illustrated, the mask 3 is interposed between the flow chamber 14 and the light source 1 and has apertures spaced therein at coded intervals to allow the beams of light Bl through B7 to emanate from the apertures and strike the flow chamber 14 at predeter-mined spaced positions as illustrated in Fig. 6. In the embodiment illustrated, the spacing between adjacent light beams decreases proceeding in the direction of the flow. More specifically, the distance between successive beams is determined by taking the difference of the square roots of their respective numbers in the sequence and multiplying by a scale factor. Thus the first and second beams are spaced by ~2 - ~'1 times the :, ~ 1043123 ~ ~
- scale factor, the second and third are spaced by ~3 - ~2 times the scale factor and so forth. From this pattern of spacing of the beams Bl through B7, it can be seen that for a constant flow rate through the flow chamber 14, a single cell, 12, will produce from detector 17 a train of output pulses as shown in Fig. 7. These pulses are amplified by amplifier 18, and then passed to delay line 19.
Delay line 19 has N-l taps, where N is the . l number of pulses in the code. These taps have respec-tive delays which correspond to the spacing between illumination beams B6 and B7, B5 and B6, and so forth.
In other words, for a general code, the taps on the delay line produce a delay which corresponds to the pulse spacing obtained by running the code train back- ~ -wards in time. These outputs, from delay line 19, are passed to amplifiers as indicated, and the outputs of the lines 21-27 and their associated amplifiers 26-27a are passed to adder circuit 20. The decoding means ; 20 of the invention is thereby correlated with the spacing of the beam position. It should be noted that no :
artificial delay exists on line 27.
The operative effect of the lines 21 through 27 is best lllustrated by reference to the contents of the adder circuit 20 depicted in Fig. 8. For a cell - 12 passing through the flow channel 14, a series of pulses is generated as illustrated in Fig. 7 and as previously explained. By virtue of the line 27 and the delay line taps 21 through 26, each of the pulses Pl ~; -15-' ' ~ ~. ~' , .
.
.
through P7 is replicated 7 times. Exemplary delays and pulse arrlval times are indicated on the abscissa of Fig. 8. The replication of the pulse Pl from line 27 is the first pulse to reach the adder circuit 20. The pulse Pl from delay line tap 26 is the second pulse to reach the adder circuit 20. The pulses P2 from line 27 and Pl from line 25 reach the adder circuit 27 almost simultaneously to produce a small voltage spike 36 - in Fig. 9. It should be noted, however, that no more than a maximum of two pulses are received simultaneously by the adder 20 until time Ts in Fig. 8. At time T
the pulses Pl from line 21, P2 from line 22, P3 from line 23, P4 from line 24, P5 from line 25, P6 from line 26, and P7 from line 27 all coincide in time. The result is a very large pulse spike 35 as indicated in Fig. 9. Spike-35 is much greater than the smaller ; spikes 36 produced by incidental coincidences of simultaneous pulses, such as the pulse Pl from line 25, and pulæe P2 ~rom line 27 as previously noted.
The decoding of the contents of the adder circuit 20 in Fig. 8 to produce the adder output of Fig. 9 is known as autocorrelation. Using autocorrela-tion, the response of the decoder has a single narrow voltage peak 35 with a position in time determined by the centroid in time of the original code. The total signal strength of this peak 35 depends upon the number Or pulses in the code which is controlled by the length of the flow chamber 14, while the width of the peak depends upon the width of the beams Bl through B7.
1~43123 "
These two parameters are essentially independent of each other. Thus, successive particles 12 proceeding through the capillary tube 13 need only be separated sufficiently so that the narrow peaks of thèir auto-correlated output signals do not overlap, and the ~ flow chamber may be increased to any desired length, - subject to other practical limitations, in order to obtain sufficient signal strength for the desired particle discrimination.
The code employed in the invention is care-fully chosen so that no more than 2 pulses (such as pulse Pl from line 25 and pulse P2 from line 27) coin-cidentally overlap at any time. The peak amplitude or signal strength of the voltage spike 35 from adder circuit 20 is proportional to the number of pulses in the code. That is, voltage spike 35 (unamplified) would haYe an amplitude seven times as great as any single one of the pulses in Fig. 7.
The decoded photodetector output over a period of time is illustrated in Fig. 3. Fig. 3 re-- presents the response of the device to the passage of several sequential cells of different types through . .
the capillary tubes 13. The flow rate employed with the device of the present invention to achieve the out-put of Fig. 3 is approximately the same as that used to produce the photodetector output of Fig. 2, which employs a conventional apparatus. It can be seen that contrary to the output of Fig. 2, the output of Fig. 3 can be resolved so that cells of a type A producing ~ pulse spikes 37 can be distinguished from pulses of a ; type B producing lower amplitude pulse spikes 38.
The amplitude of spikes 37 is equal to Kn . A, while the amplitude of spike 38 is equal to Kn . B, where Kn is a number greater than 1 and is proportional to the number of pulses in the code. A and B are the same amplitudes depicted in Fig. 1.
While the apparatus depicted in Fig. 4 is probably the preferred construction of the invention, an alternative form of the decoding means is illus-trated in Fig. 5. Codes that contain multiple orders, such as a square wave F.M. "chirp," can be designed so that the multiple orders do not overlap in frequency.
In this case a decoding device can be constructed by 15 passing the detector output signal from the amplifier 18 through a band pass filter 32 which selects one of the orders, usually the fundamental order. The output from the band pass filter 32 may be passed through a pulse compression means 33 in the form of a dispersive 20 delay line to produce autocorrelated output signals for individual particles. The low pass filter 32 blocks high frequency output, including most noise, from the photomultiplier 17 but passes low frequency outputs such as the pulses Pl through P7. That is, 25 the pulse compression means 33 produces a signal proportional to an integrated sum of the pulses Pl through P7 for a particular particle or cell 12 in the flow channel 14, which signal is passed to an amplifier 34.
In either embodiment, the electronic processor 28 forms a signal classification means for classifying the decoded output signals according to preselected pulse amplitude ranges. The electronic processor 28 also serves as a pulse tabulating means for counting the number of decoded output signals in each selected classification, and for tabulating these counts in the !' registers 29, 30 and 31. In this way, different types of particles of interest having definitely identifiable fluorescent characteristics may be tabulated separately.
There are a number of different operating conditions under which flow cells employing the pulse coding technique of the present invention demonstrate significant advantages over conventional flow cell arrangements. Conversely, there are some adverse conditions for flow cell measurement in which the use of this invention is not likely to produce an improve-ment, although neither will it exhibit inferior per~or- --- mance. Specifically, the pulse coded flow cell techni-que described herein produces a distinct advantage where particle discrimination is based on the outcome of several different measurements, for example, multiple fluorescence measurements, and it is desired to use a -single detector for observing all measurements. In this instance several measurements may be desired, for example fluorescence at different wavelengths, on each particle. The standard way of doing this is to image separate channels into the flow cell for each wave-length, and then image the output of each channel, thru ' :
.
isolation filters, to a separate detector. If instead, a set of orthogonal code words are utilized, then they can be imaged into the flow chamber in an overlapping pattern. The output signals can then go to a single detector, without the need of isolation filters, and the ~ . .
subsequent signals can be separated by the orthogonality property. Of course, it is necessary that there be no interaction, such as internal energy transfer, Prom simultaneous excitation of the different fluorescent mechanisms. Alternatively, the same code word could be used for each channel, and simply imaged into the flow cell with a slight offset between channels. By time gating with one extra detector, it should be possible to separate the output signals for each channel.
15This invention is also particularly ad-vantageous where there is insufficient signal because of source or thermal detector noise. There is a definite gain in signal-to-noise from using pulse code techniques. The signal power per unit bandwidth is increased with increasing length of the pulse train, - while the noise power per unit bandwidth remains constant.
Flow cell measurement may be desired under conditions where there is essentially no noise, but the signal is a small change from a high bias level which may drift slowly in time. If the pulse is short, and reasonably intense, then a simple AC coupling of the detector output may be adequate for separation of signal from background. If, however, the signal pulse is not sufficiently intense, the only to increase ~043123 signal energy is by means of time integration. This 1 results in two disadvantages; first the count rate is lowered, and second, a simple AC coupled detector is no longer feasible for separating signal from background. By using a pulse code technique, the desired signal can be made to appear as a wideband signal centered about an offset carrier frequency, thus allowing both a high count rate, and easy separa- -tion of signal from background. If the signal occurs as a short pulse, then a simple AC coupled detector may be adequate. If the signal must be kept long and detected by means of time integration, then the use of a pulse coded technique allows both a high count rate and easy separation of signal and background.
On the other hand, no significant advantage is realized by employing pulse coded techniques where there is insufficient signal because of quantum lim~ta~
tions. This may occur where a background level is ~-present or where single pulses from individual particles are quantum limited, but background is essentially non-existent. In the former case there is no gain signal to noise ratio using pulse coded techniques, while in the latter case the signal to noise gain depends upon the count rate. At the maximum possible count ;~ 25 rate, there is essentially no gain using pulse coded techniques, since the constant stream of particles adjacent to the one of interest appears as a noise - producing background.
. .
.' "' ' ' 043~23 Similarly, there is no particular advantage to pulse coded techniques where the signal tends to vary because of changing particle position or orienta-`; tion during the time it is in the flow chamber.
However, if the pulse train can be made long enough for a good average on particle orientation to be obtained, then there is some gain in signal-to-noise, especially in combination with detector or source noise.
In addition, there is the advantage of easy separation of signal and background compared to a method which simply integrates in one long pulse.
Combinations of the foregoing conditions are of course possible, and the advantage, if any, of using a pulse code technique would essentially be determined by that member of the combination which tends to give the smallest gain.
~- The form of the invention depicted has been given for purposes of illustration only. Other forms of the device and the techniques in the practice of a method may be utilized to measure scattered light, absorption, or combinations of scattering absorption and fluorescence. In addition, other properties be-sides optical characteristics may be measured with appropriate instruments. These properties would in-clude electronic charge, dialectric polarization, or electrical conductivity. The embodiments of this in-vention for measuring such characteristics would necessarily include appropriate modifications in the - flow chamber, form of stimulation of a signal ,. . . . . . .
1043123 i~: :
dependent upon the desired characteristic, and means for detecting the signal so produced.
' ' ~
. - , ~, . ~ '.
~ , ~
. ~ .
,. ~.
-23- -:
.. . . . .
i, , , ~ . ,
Claims (13)
1. An apparatus for distinguishing between discrete particles of different materials entrained in a fluid which exhibit distinguishable responses to physical stimulus comprising a narrow channel through which fluid containing entrained particles of material flows, flow regulation means for maintaining a pre-determined flow rate through said channel, means for exerting a spatially discontinuous physical stimulus at positions longitudinally spaced at predetermined intervals along said channel on said particles of material entrained in said fluid to elicit separate res-ponses from each particle of material at each of the aforesaid positions which responses collectively comprise a coded response, transducer means for detecting the separate responses from said discrete particles of material at each of the aforesaid positions and for generating corresponding signals, decoding means connected to said transducer means and corre-lated with the flow rate and the spacing of the afore-said positions to decode said coded response and to combine into a single decoded signal the separate signals corresponding to the separate responses emanating from each particle of material detected in response to the physical stimulus.
2. The apparatus according to Claim 1 wherein said decoding means comprises a band pass filter connected to the transducer output and pulse compression means connected to the aforesaid band pass filter to produce a decoded signal of amplitude proportional to the cumulative amplitude sum of signals emanating from said band pass filter.
3. An apparatus for use in detecting the presence of particles of interest in a fluid which are treated to fluoresce under the influence of a beam of light comprising: a transparent, narrow flow chamber having a length significantly greater than its width, a means for directing a plurality of beams of light transversely through the flow chamber at fixed positions spaced longitudinally at predetermined intervals along the length of said flow chamber, means for main-taining a constant flow rate of the fluid to be analyzed through said flow chamber, photodetector means viewing said flow chamber and generating electrical pulses in response to detected light emissions, blocking filter means interposed between said flow chamber and said photo-detector means at the aforesaid spaced positions for selectively blocking the passage of light directly emanating from said beams of light and preferentially passing light produced by fluorescence of the afore-said particles of interest in the fluid to be analyzed in said flow chamber, and decoding means correlated with the aforesaid constant flow rate and the intervals between the aforesaid spaced positions connected to said photodetector means to produce decoded output signals indicative of the cumulative light output from fluorescence of particles of interest passing through said flow chamber.
4. The apparatus according to Claim 3 wherein said decoding means comprises a pulse delaying means connected to the output of said photodetector means, separate output lines respectively corresponding to a single one of said fixed positions along said flow chamber wherein a period of delay is associated with each output line, each such period being proportional to the location of the associated position in the sequence of positions encountered by particles of interest in fluid passing through said flow chamber.
5. The apparatus according to Claim 3 wherein said means for directing a plurality of beams of light is comprised of a single light source and a mask inter-posed between said flow chamber and said light source and having apertures spaced therein at coded intervals to allow the aforesaid beams of light to emanate from said apertures and strike said flow chamber at the aforesaid spaced positions.
6. The apparatus of Claim 3 further comprising signal classification means for classifying said decoded output signals according to preselected pulse amplitude ranges, and pulse tabulating means for counting the number of decoded output signals in each selected classification, whereby different types of particles of interest having identifiable fluorescence character-istics may be tabulated separately.
7. An apparatus for distinguishing between discrete particles of different materials entrained in a fluid which exhibit distinguishable responses to different physical stimuli comprising a narrow channel through which fluid containing entrained particles of material flows, flow regulation means for maintaining a predetermined flow rate through said channel, means for exerting a plurality of spatially discontinuous physical stimuli at positions longitudinally spaced at predetermined intervals along said channel on said particles of material entrained in said fluid to elicit separate responses from each particle of material at each of the aforesaid positions which responses to each physical stimulus collectively comprise a coded response to that stimulus, transducer means for detect-ing the separate responses to said stimuli from said discrete particles of material at each of the afore-said positions and for generating corresponding signals which differ according to the associated stimulus, decoding means connected to said transducer means and correlated with the flow rate and the spacing of the aforesaid positions to decode each of said coded res-ponses and to combine into a single decoded signal the separate signals corresponding to the separate responses emanating from each particle of material detected in response to each physical stimulus.
8. The apparatus of Claim 7 wherein said transducer means is constructed to further combine all of the aforesaid separate signals corresponding to the separate responses to all of said stimuli from each particle of material detected to produce a distinguishing composite signal for the associated material.
9. A method of distinguishing between discrete particles of interest in a fluid comprising:
contacting said particles of interest with a fluorescent dye which will cause them to fluoresce under a beam of light, passing a fluid containing said particles of interest through a transparent flow chamber, exposing said flow chamber to a plurality of transverse beams of light at positions spaced at predetermined intervals along the length of said flow chamber to elicit coded signals from particles of interest in the form of discrete fluorescent emissions therefrom in response to each beam of light, detecting said coded signals using a transducer producing outputs for each coded signal, decoding said coded signal outputs for indivi-dual particles of interest by consolidating the signals to produce a composite output signal for each particle of interest detected, classifying the particles of interest in accordance with differences in the composite output signals, and quantitatively tabulating the particles of interest according to the classifica-tions selected.
contacting said particles of interest with a fluorescent dye which will cause them to fluoresce under a beam of light, passing a fluid containing said particles of interest through a transparent flow chamber, exposing said flow chamber to a plurality of transverse beams of light at positions spaced at predetermined intervals along the length of said flow chamber to elicit coded signals from particles of interest in the form of discrete fluorescent emissions therefrom in response to each beam of light, detecting said coded signals using a transducer producing outputs for each coded signal, decoding said coded signal outputs for indivi-dual particles of interest by consolidating the signals to produce a composite output signal for each particle of interest detected, classifying the particles of interest in accordance with differences in the composite output signals, and quantitatively tabulating the particles of interest according to the classifica-tions selected.
10. The method of Claim 8 wherein the coded signal outputs are delayed for an interval of time proportional to the relative longitudinal position along the flow chamber of the beam of light associated therewith.
11. A method of distinguishing between dis-crete particles of interest in a fluid comprising:
contacting said particles of interest with a fluorescent dye which will cause them to fluoresce under a beam of light in a manner determined by the wavelength of the light, passing a fluid containing said particles of interest through a transparent flow chamber, ex-posing said flow chamber to a plurality of transverse beams of light of different wavelengths at positions spaced at predetermined intervals along the length of said flow chamber to elicit coded signals from particles of interest in the form of fluorescent emissions there-from in response to each beam of light and distinguished by the wavelength thereof, isolating and detecting said coded signals using a transducer producing outputs for each coded signal, decoding said coded signal outputs for individual particles of interest by consolidating the signals to produce a composite output signal for each particle of interest detected, classifying the particles of interest in accordance with differences in the composite output signals, and quantitatively tabulating the particles of interest according to the classifications selected.
contacting said particles of interest with a fluorescent dye which will cause them to fluoresce under a beam of light in a manner determined by the wavelength of the light, passing a fluid containing said particles of interest through a transparent flow chamber, ex-posing said flow chamber to a plurality of transverse beams of light of different wavelengths at positions spaced at predetermined intervals along the length of said flow chamber to elicit coded signals from particles of interest in the form of fluorescent emissions there-from in response to each beam of light and distinguished by the wavelength thereof, isolating and detecting said coded signals using a transducer producing outputs for each coded signal, decoding said coded signal outputs for individual particles of interest by consolidating the signals to produce a composite output signal for each particle of interest detected, classifying the particles of interest in accordance with differences in the composite output signals, and quantitatively tabulating the particles of interest according to the classifications selected.
12. The method of Claim 11 wherein beams of light of different wavelength are concurrently applied to said particles.
13. The method of Claim 11 wherein beams of light of different wavelength are successively applied to each of said particles.
Applications Claiming Priority (1)
| Application Number | Priority Date | Filing Date | Title |
|---|---|---|---|
| US05/509,360 US3941479A (en) | 1974-09-26 | 1974-09-26 | Use of modulated stimulus to improve detection sensitivity for signals from particles in a flow chamber |
Publications (1)
| Publication Number | Publication Date |
|---|---|
| CA1043123A true CA1043123A (en) | 1978-11-28 |
Family
ID=24026338
Family Applications (1)
| Application Number | Title | Priority Date | Filing Date |
|---|---|---|---|
| CA236,380A Expired CA1043123A (en) | 1974-09-26 | 1975-09-25 | Use of modulated stimulus to improve detection sensitivity for signals from particles in a flow chamber |
Country Status (7)
| Country | Link |
|---|---|
| US (1) | US3941479A (en) |
| JP (1) | JPS5163669A (en) |
| CA (1) | CA1043123A (en) |
| DE (1) | DE2543124A1 (en) |
| FR (1) | FR2286380A1 (en) |
| GB (1) | GB1519312A (en) |
| NL (1) | NL7511303A (en) |
Families Citing this family (33)
| Publication number | Priority date | Publication date | Assignee | Title |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| US4011459A (en) * | 1975-12-05 | 1977-03-08 | Particle Measuring Systems, Inc. | Method and apparatus for determining valid sample volume |
| US4103229A (en) * | 1977-01-28 | 1978-07-25 | The University Of Virginia | Continuous-flow, resistive-particle counting apparatus |
| US4400353A (en) * | 1977-09-23 | 1983-08-23 | Akro-Medic Engineering, Inc. | Electro-optical system for use in evaluating immunological reactions |
| US4249244A (en) * | 1978-05-03 | 1981-02-03 | Ppm, Inc. | Electro-optical system and method and apparatus for providing automatically-compensating, traceable calibration and zeroing for light scattering devices |
| SE7806922L (en) * | 1978-06-15 | 1979-12-16 | Svenska Traeforskningsinst | PROCEDURE AND DEVICE FOR INDICATING THE SIZE DISTRIBUTION OF PARTICLES EXISTING IN A FLOWING MEDIUM |
| US4260258A (en) * | 1978-08-14 | 1981-04-07 | Pacific Scientific Company | Compact, rugged sensor for optical measurement of the size of particles suspended in a fluid |
| US4202625A (en) * | 1978-08-18 | 1980-05-13 | Ortho Diagnostics, Inc. | Method and apparatus for discriminating red blood cells from platelets |
| US4318481A (en) * | 1979-08-20 | 1982-03-09 | Ortho Diagnostics, Inc. | Method for automatically setting the correct phase of the charge pulses in an electrostatic flow sorter |
| US4318483A (en) * | 1979-08-20 | 1982-03-09 | Ortho Diagnostics, Inc. | Automatic relative droplet charging time delay system for an electrostatic particle sorting system using a relatively moveable stream surface sensing system |
| US4317520A (en) * | 1979-08-20 | 1982-03-02 | Ortho Diagnostics, Inc. | Servo system to control the spatial position of droplet formation of a fluid jet in a cell sorting apparatus |
| US4318480A (en) * | 1979-08-20 | 1982-03-09 | Ortho Diagnostics, Inc. | Method and apparatus for positioning the point of droplet formation in the jetting fluid of an electrostatic sorting device |
| US4325483A (en) * | 1979-08-20 | 1982-04-20 | Ortho Diagnostics, Inc. | Method for detecting and controlling flow rates of the droplet forming stream of an electrostatic particle sorting apparatus |
| US4318482A (en) * | 1979-08-20 | 1982-03-09 | Ortho Diagnostics, Inc. | Method for measuring the velocity of a perturbed jetting fluid in an electrostatic particle sorting system |
| US4298836A (en) * | 1979-11-23 | 1981-11-03 | Coulter Electronics, Inc. | Particle shape determination |
| US4341993A (en) * | 1980-08-25 | 1982-07-27 | Coulter Electronics, Inc. | Reflector optics with impedance sensing orifice |
| US4393466A (en) * | 1980-09-12 | 1983-07-12 | International Remote Imaging Systems | Method of analyzing particles in a dilute fluid sample |
| JPS5832138A (en) * | 1981-08-19 | 1983-02-25 | Toshiba Corp | Inspection apparatus of blood |
| FR2521294A1 (en) * | 1982-02-05 | 1983-08-12 | Bajard Jean | GLOBAL INTERFERENTIAL GRANULOMETRY METHOD APPLICABLE IN PARTICULAR TO POLYDISPERSE BIOLOGICAL PARTICLES |
| US4576477A (en) * | 1982-06-22 | 1986-03-18 | The United States Of America As Represented By The Department Of Health And Human Services | Method and apparatus for measuring density profiles in microscopic tube flow |
| US4676640A (en) * | 1984-09-12 | 1987-06-30 | Syntex (U.S.A.) Inc. | Fluctuation analysis for enhanced particle detection |
| US4987539A (en) * | 1987-08-05 | 1991-01-22 | Stanford University | Apparatus and method for multidimensional characterization of objects in real time |
| US5278626A (en) * | 1991-09-05 | 1994-01-11 | Amherst Process Instruments, Inc. | Non-volatile residue system for monitoring impurities in a liquid |
| US5999256A (en) * | 1992-02-12 | 1999-12-07 | Cambridge Consultants Limited | Particle measurement system |
| GB9202887D0 (en) * | 1992-02-12 | 1992-03-25 | Cambridge Consultants | A particle sizing system based on incoherent structured illumination |
| DE60012989T2 (en) * | 2000-01-21 | 2005-09-08 | The University Of Western Ontario, London | FRICTION CHARGING AND ELECTROSTATIC SEPARATION OF MIXED ELECTRICALLY INSULATED PARTICLES |
| JP3745947B2 (en) * | 2000-08-23 | 2006-02-15 | ミクニキカイ株式会社 | Method and apparatus for measuring particle size of fine particles in fluid |
| US20040091850A1 (en) * | 2002-11-08 | 2004-05-13 | Travis Boone | Single cell analysis of membrane molecules |
| US7667838B2 (en) * | 2005-06-16 | 2010-02-23 | Thermo Gamma-Metrics Llc | In-stream spectroscopic elemental analysis of particles being conducted within a gaseous stream |
| JP4918771B2 (en) * | 2005-09-26 | 2012-04-18 | 住友電気工業株式会社 | Particle classifying device and adhesive containing particles classified by the device |
| US7854158B2 (en) * | 2006-12-28 | 2010-12-21 | Perry Equipment Corporation | Systems and methods for measurement and analysis of pipeline contaminants |
| US7948621B2 (en) * | 2007-06-28 | 2011-05-24 | Perry Equipment Corporation | Systems and methods for remote monitoring of contaminants in fluids |
| CN102119116A (en) * | 2008-07-31 | 2011-07-06 | 范思特艾布力斯卡股份有限公司 | Fuel quality traceable and remote system |
| EP3279635B1 (en) * | 2016-08-04 | 2022-06-01 | Malvern Panalytical Limited | Method, processor and machine-readable, non-transient storage medium for characterising particles suspended in a fluid dispersant |
Family Cites Families (3)
| Publication number | Priority date | Publication date | Assignee | Title |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| US3680961A (en) * | 1970-06-01 | 1972-08-01 | British Aircraft Corp Ltd | Measurement of particle sizes |
| US3819270A (en) * | 1972-10-02 | 1974-06-25 | Block Engineering | Blood cell analyzer |
| US3830568A (en) * | 1973-05-25 | 1974-08-20 | Texas Instruments Inc | Multiple detection volume laser doppler velocimeter |
-
1974
- 1974-09-26 US US05/509,360 patent/US3941479A/en not_active Expired - Lifetime
-
1975
- 1975-09-24 FR FR7529296A patent/FR2286380A1/en not_active Withdrawn
- 1975-09-25 CA CA236,380A patent/CA1043123A/en not_active Expired
- 1975-09-25 JP JP50114934A patent/JPS5163669A/ja active Pending
- 1975-09-25 NL NL7511303A patent/NL7511303A/en unknown
- 1975-09-25 GB GB39310/75A patent/GB1519312A/en not_active Expired
- 1975-09-26 DE DE19752543124 patent/DE2543124A1/en active Pending
Also Published As
| Publication number | Publication date |
|---|---|
| DE2543124A1 (en) | 1976-04-08 |
| FR2286380A1 (en) | 1976-04-23 |
| NL7511303A (en) | 1976-03-30 |
| US3941479A (en) | 1976-03-02 |
| JPS5163669A (en) | 1976-06-02 |
| GB1519312A (en) | 1978-07-26 |
Similar Documents
| Publication | Publication Date | Title |
|---|---|---|
| CA1043123A (en) | Use of modulated stimulus to improve detection sensitivity for signals from particles in a flow chamber | |
| EP0442025B1 (en) | Optical particle analyzing apparatus having two types of light sources | |
| US4172227A (en) | Flow microfluorometer | |
| US9029800B2 (en) | Compact analyzer with spatial modulation and multiple intensity modulated excitation sources | |
| US6816257B2 (en) | Method and apparatus for detecting microparticles in fluid samples | |
| US5292483A (en) | Detecting a radiation signal | |
| US7973294B2 (en) | Methods and devices for characterizing particles in clear and turbid media | |
| Horan et al. | Quantitative Single Cell Analysis and Sorting: Rapid analysis and sorting of cells is emerging as an important new technology in research and medicine. | |
| US7280204B2 (en) | Multi-spectral detector and analysis system | |
| US5644388A (en) | Imaging flow cytometer nearly simultaneously capturing a plurality of images | |
| EP2219021B1 (en) | Particle or cell analyzer and method | |
| US8723140B2 (en) | Particle analyzer with spatial modulation and long lifetime bioprobes | |
| EP0988525B1 (en) | A method for characterizing samples on the basis of intermediate statistical data | |
| US4676640A (en) | Fluctuation analysis for enhanced particle detection | |
| US3824402A (en) | Dual parameter flow photometric apparatus and method | |
| CA2293426C (en) | Method and apparatus for detecting microparticles in fluid samples | |
| FI943732A (en) | Method and apparatus for determining the number of particles in a flow cytometer | |
| CN107003239B (en) | Self-triggering flow cytometer | |
| US3872312A (en) | Method and apparatus for detecting and classifying nucleic acid particles | |
| EP0465534A1 (en) | Method and apparatus for the identification of particles. | |
| JPS6151569A (en) | Cell identifying device | |
| CA2329031C (en) | High numerical aperture flow cytometer and method of using same | |
| JPS59102139A (en) | Blood corpuscle counter | |
| Center | Introduction to Flow Cytometry | |
| JPH0226054Y2 (en) |