CA1059412A

CA1059412A - Sterility indicator

Info

Publication number: CA1059412A
Application number: CA249,747A
Authority: CA
Inventors: Robert J. Witonsky; Raymond P. Larsson
Original assignee: BIO-MEDICAL SCIENCES
Current assignee: BIO-MEDICAL SCIENCES
Priority date: 1975-04-14
Filing date: 1976-04-07
Publication date: 1979-07-31
Also published as: IL49401A0; DK151369B; DE7611756U1; FR2307544B1; NL7603906A; ES446983A1; AU1295376A; IT1057534B; SE411688B; IE42675B1; DK170376A; CH626652A5; SE7604280L; IE42675L; BR7602281A; DE2616366C2; DE2616366A1; MX143617A; JPS5522752B2; BE840749A

Abstract

ABSTRACT OF DISCLOSURE

A sterility indicator comprising a backing strip of a dimensionally stable material e.g. aluminum foil having mounted thereon an organic compound containing oxygen or nitrogen in intimate contact with a wicking means and a cover strip bonded to the backing strip overlaying the organic compound and wicking means. The cover strip is a polymeric rate controlling film which permits water vapor to pass through at a rate sufficient to make the device operative at a temperature to be monitored.

Description

, 10594~-Z

BACKGROUND OF INVENTION

It is well known in the art that heat will destroy microorganisms. The presence of moisture accelerates this destruction by denaturing or coagulation of the proteins making up the microorganisms. Most microorganisms contain sufficient water so that moderate heat alone, e.g. 80C-100C, will destroy the microorganism. Many bacterial spores, on the other hand, contain substantially no water and require elevated temperatures in excess of 150C for their destruction where dry heat is used. Hence, the destruction of such organisms is generally carried out in the presence of steam in autoclaves.
Such steam sterilization is generally carried out at temperatures of about 250F for at least 12 to 15 minutes or for shorter times at higher temperatures e.g. 270F. Often, to insure -a sufficient safety margin, times as long as 30 minutes are used.
Such long sterilization times give the operator a greater degree of confidence that steam has penetrated throughout the autoclave and among all of its contents. However, such long heat cycles are disadvantageous from the standpoint of economy of time, energy consumption, and severe shortening of the useful life of the sterilized material, e.g., fabric gowns, drapes, muslim products, etc.
From time to time attempts have been made to develop sterili-zation indicators which permit quality control of sterilization with the confidence that all microorganisms have been destroyed.
Presently the most satisfactory method is the use of spore strips.
Spores which are particularly difficult to destroy are selected as the control standard, e.g. Bacillus Subtillis var. Niger and Bacillus Stearothermophilus. The spore strip is placed in the ;

autoclave with the materials to be sterilized. At the end of the sterilization cycle, the spore strip is studied to determine whether it is possible to grow organisms in a suitable culture - 1 - ~ . -.

medium. Failure of the spores to reproduce indicates death of spores; and hence, adequate sterilization.
Although this control technique is accurate, it suffers from several inherent disadvantages, (1) excessive cost (2) delay between processing and control data (3) batch to batch variation of the spores and (4) heat resistance of spores decreases with storage time.
Several attempts have been made to devise chemical type sterility indicators. The crudest variety is a product known as Temp-Tube, see for example, U.S. Patents 3,313,266; 3,341,238;
and 3,652,249. The device consists of nothing more than a sealed tube containing a compound with a melting point which corresponds to the sterilization temperature. The device is capable of doing no more than indicating whether or not the autoclave was held at a temperature above or below the melting point for a period of time once the melting point is reached. Hence, the device only indicates that the desired melting point temperature was reached for a period of time sufficient to melt the indicator.
Other sterility indicators rely on a temperature accelerated chemicalreaCtion to cause color change in an indicator. Though ~ome of these devices purport to be operative at more than one temperature/time condition, they suffer from the disadvantage that -they do not match the spore kill temperature/time relationships.
The thermal resistance of spores of a particular species at any temperature is characterized by its temperature coefficient.
The symbol Qlo is used to designate the temperature coefficient over a range of 10C. It means the ratio of the death rate constant at a particular temperature to the death rate constant at a temperature 10C. lower. Generally, the measurements are made for -a fixed time interval, e.g., 9 minutes. If the constants at any two temperatures, tl, and a temperature 10C higher, t2, are known, then Qlo may be calculated from the equation:

* Trade Mark B
- . .................... : . ~ ......... . .. . - .
.. . . . . .

log Qlo = 10 log K2 wherein tl and t2 are as defined and Kl and K2 are the respective death rate constants. Spores generally exhibit a Qlo value of -about 10. Therefore, it is desirable to have a sterility indicator which will, in a sense, mimic spore kill. To do 80, the ratio of the effect of temperature as a function of time on a measurement taken at one temperature as compared to the same measurement at another temperature 10C lower should also be 10. To be useful as a sterility indicator, this relationship must also be dependent on the presence of moisture, since the spore kill time/temperature relationship is vastly different in the dry or wet state. In the absence of moisture spore kill at 250F - 270F is negligible, but in the presence of steam spore kill is virtually complete for the most resistant strains at these temperatures in about 12 - 2 minutes.
SVMMARY OF INVENTION
It has surprisingly been found that a suitable ~terility indicator which is dependent on the~nesen¢e of moisture can be constructed using an organic compound having a meltingpoint slightly higher than the sterility temperature to be monitored. A pellet of the compound is placed on a backing in contact with a wick and covered with a transparent polymeric covering which protects the compound and wick from direct contact with steam, as well as maintains the integrity of the device.
It is important to the function of the sterility indicator that steam may diffuse through the cover film. Additionally, the melting point of the organic compound must be depressed by the absorption of moisture into the pellet.
The cover film functions to control the rate of water vapor transmissions into the organic compound. Proper selection of organic compound and polymeric cover film determine the operative temperature as well as the time/temperature coefficient for the device.
Illustrative non-limiting examples of specific types of ~, ` - 105941Z
"
functional groups which when included in the structure of a compound results in useful organic compounds in the practice of this invention are aldehyde, carbonyl, ester keto, ether, hydroxy amino, amide, carboxy etc. Generally the organic compound should contain either oxygen or nitrogen.

BRIEF DESCRIPTION OP DRAWINGS
. . _ .
Figure 1 shows structural configuration of the sterility indicator.
Figure 2 is a bar graph representation of the integrating effect of the sterility indicator.
- Figure 3 is a graphical comparison of the time/temperature coefficient of the indicator of this invention and spore kill.

DETAILED DESCRIPTION
This invention relates to a sterility indicator. More specifically, it relates to a sterility indicator capable of giving a visual response to the integrated time/temperature exposure of a system to moist heat.
Figure 1 shows a typical structure for the sterility indicator ~ of this invention. A backing strip, 1, is coated with a thin layer ;!0 of adhesive, 2, a wicking means, 3, is positioned on the backing strip with one end in communication with a pocket, 4, embossed into '- the backing strip, 1. A pellet of organic compound, 5, is inserted ~`
into the pocket, 4, and in communication with the wicking means, 3.
A cover strip, 6j is then pressed in place on top of the device, , the cover strip, 6, being adhesively bonded in place.
The composition of the backing strip is not critical. It, ` however, must be dimensionally stable at the process temperature being monitored. Although polymeric materials can be used, in order that they have substantial dimensional stability, they must 0 be of a heavier gauge than desired from the standpoint of economics and overall thickness of the device. Additionally, the embossing ':

~' .. .. . . . . . . .. . .
.. . .. ` . . . . .
. ~ . . ` . . . .. . . . .

t 1~594~Z , of the pocket requires the application of heat and pressure.
Hence, the preferred backing strip is metal foil, e.g., aluminum foil. Though the thickness of the foil is not critical it is preferred that foil of about 1 to 5 mils is used e.g., 3 mils.
Any of the polymers used as the cover strip can be used as the material of construction of the backing strip. However, the backing strip in that event is preferable at least about 10 mils -in thickness, more preferably about 20 to 30 mils. The term , "dimensionally stable" as used in the specification and claims with reference to the backing strip means that the backing strip , will not change dimensions by shrinkage, wrinkling etc. as a result of exposure to process temperatures.
The wicking means may be any suitable material through which the organic compound can migrate by capillary action. The preferred wicking means is a paper strip~ Other such wicking means such as non-woven polymeric fabrics and inorganic fibrous compositions may be used.
The dimensions of the wicking means is not critical. However, its dimensions (thickness and width) will affect the rate of wicking and determine the quantity of organic compound required to result in a suitable scale length. Hence, from an economic standpoint the ` wicking means should be as thin as practical. A suitable width for the wicking means is about 3/16 to about 1/4 of an inch.
Illustrative of the wicking means which may be used are Whatman #1 filter paper, Whatman #114 filter paper, supported microcrystalline cellulose (TLC plate), supported aluminum oxide, and supported silica gel.
The cover strip is a rate controlling film which permits moisture (gaseous) to pass through at a rate sufficient to depress the melting point of the organic compound to the sterilization temperature to be monitored. The necessary vapor transmission rate will of course depend on the operating temperature and the organic .

;.

:~. .- , . . . . . ..

~05941Z
compound selected.
It is possible to make precise determinations of vapor transmission rate as a function of temperature for various films and the effect of water vapor on melting point depression of various compounds. These data may then be used to select combinations of cover strip vapor barrier and organic compound suitable for a particular temperature to be monitored. Such a fundamental approach to component selection is neither necessary nor desirable since it is only approximate, and an actual trial must be made in any event. Hence, an Edisonian approach results in the most rapid method of selection.
In selecting the rate controlling cover strip, it is of course necessary that the polymeric composition of the cover strip is not subject to attack by the organic compound. For example, mylar (ethylene glycol terephthalic acid ester) may not be used where the organic compound is a hydroxy containing aromatic compound, e.g. alkyl substituted phenols. Illustrative examples of suitable cover strip material are mylar, polypropylene,polyethylene, poly-styrene, polymethylmethacrylate, etc. Of course it will be obvious ; 20 to those skilled in the art that the polymers may not be used above their softening point. The cover strip should be transparent and ~i preferably clear. A preferred cover strip material is polypropylene i since it has a high softening point and is relatively inert to most chemical compounds. Additionally, it has an acceptable water vapor ; transmission rate at temperatures about 250F., the temperature at which sterilization processes are usually carried out.
The thickness of the cover strip film will of course effect `i the vapor transmission rate. Preferably the film is about 0.75 to about 3 mils, more preferably about 1 to about 2 mils, e.g., 1.25 mils.
The term "rate controlling" when used in the specification and claims with respect to the cover strip means that the cover -,. . ,~

, - 105941Z
strip controls the water vapor transmission rate by virtue of its permeability to water vapor at the temperature to be monitored.
No effort is made to determine the actual vapor transmission rate or in any other way to control the vapor transmission rate.
In selecting a system for a sterility indicator, the first -step is to select a cover strip and backing strip. As a first `~
choice aluminum foil is selected as the backing strip and poly-propylene is selected as the cover strip. The wicking means is, ; typically, conventional filter paper, e.g., Whatman #l filter paper.
It then is only necessary to select a suitable organic compound.
In selecting the organic compound for the purposes of this invention, it must be a compound in which water has at least a slight degree of solubility. The compound selected should have a normal melting point about 5F to about 50F greater than the sterilization temperature to be monitored; more preferably, about 8F to about 40F; most preferably, about 10F to about 30F greater than the temperature to be monitored, e.g., 20F greater.
That water be soluble in the organic compound to a slight extent is essential to the operation of the device of this invention.;
Not wishing to be bound by theory, it is believed that the water acts as a melting point depressant. The object in selecting an organic compound having a melting point higher than the temperature to be monitored but capable of having its melting point depressed by the absorption of water is to insure that the device will be inoperative in the absence of water vapor at the control temperature.
The term "control temperature" as used in the specification and claims means the temperature to be monitored for the process in ? question, e.g. sterilization, pasteurization, etc.
Though it is possible to determine the actual degree of water solubility in the organic compound, it is not essential. In -addition to having the specified melting point as described above, the compound should contain functional groups which will result in .

1059~Z
-a degree of water solubility. Illustrative of the functional groups which the organic compounds must contain are aldehyde, carbonyl, ester, keto, ether, hydroxy, amino, amide, carboxy, phosphate, phosphonate sulfones, sulfate, sulfonate, etc.
Structurally, thesefunctional groups are:
O O R
.. .. ..
- C -; - C-N-; - NR2; O N 2;o - CR2-O-CR2 .. - .:
-;-CR2-O-C-; - CR2-O-C-; - C-OX; - SO3X; -SO4X; ~;
- SO3NH2: - SNH2; -SO2NH2 whenever R is H or alkyl preferably Cl-C4 alkyl and X is H, alkyl or alkylene. Preferably the alkyl or alkylene group is a Cl-C4 hydrocarbon.
Hence, the organic compounds of this invention are hetero-genous compounds which must contain oxygen or nitrogen in the ~ structure. In addition to oxygen and nitrogen, other non-reactive '~ substituents may be included such as chlorine, sulfur, phosphorus, etc.
Hence, the term "organic compound" as used in the specifica-. tion and claims means an organic compound containing in its structure at least one oxygen or nitrogen atom as well as carbon atoms. As stated above, other atoms can be included in the ~ ;
structure. Illustrative examples of organic compounds suitable for use in the practice of this invention are 2-chloracetamide, ethoxy benzamide, benzoic acid, diphenyl succinate, dichlorophenol, i dimethyl phenol, benzamide, urea, 1, 4 dihydroxybenzophenone, hydroquinone, dioxime, ethylene ester of toluene sulfonic acid, aslicylamide, and salicylic acid.
` It is preferred that the cover strip be adhered to the -' backing strip with an adhesive. Heat sealing, however, can be used instead of adhesives. Any adhesive for bonding polymers to metal ; 30 or polymers to polymers can be used. The adhesive of course must P be resistant to attack by the organic compound. The preferred adhesives are silicone adhesives, e.g., General Electric Company's .' :
r -- 8 ~

, ,, lQ5941~
*
: Sil Grip 57~. The term ~bonding~ or ~'bonded" as used in the specification and claims includes both heat sealing and adhesive lamination of the backing strip to the cover strip. In preparing a sterility indicator for a given application, as a first ; approximation, aluminum foil is used as the backing strip, and polypropylene film is used as the rate controlling cover strip.
An organic compound having a normal meltina point about 20-30F
above the control point is selected. A pocket or depression is embossed into the backing strip and a pellet of the organic ' 10 compound is placed in the pocket. The wicking means is aligned to the backing strip with a portion of one end under the pellet. For convenience of preparation the backing strip is first coated with an adhesive material. Thus the pellet and-wicking means will remain in place. The cover strip is then pressed in place.
The system is tested by placing it into a steam autoclave , held at th~ control temperature and at the corresponding saturated ~; steam pressure. After about twelve minutes the device is removed k from the autoclave and observed. No additional wicking should ,; occur after removal from the autoclave. Not wishing to be bound by theory, it i8 believed additional wicking after removal from the ~, autoclave or at temperatures below the control temperature are the result of supercooling or the formation of a supersaturated solution of water and organic compound which permits wicking below the control temperature.
If no wicking occurs after dropping the temperature and the length of wicking of organic compound along the wicking means is satisfactory to give an acceptable scale for the desired application, the screening test is continued.
, A similar test specimen is prepared and tested at about 5F
~30 below the control temperature no wicking should occur. Additional ` tests should be conducted about 5F above and below the control temperature to determine the Qlo value for the compound selected.

; * Trade Mark :, _ g _ , ~. ~oss4lZ

I~here it is desired to have a ~10 which matches a particular process, e.g. spore kill, it may be necessary to repeat the process with other organic compounds.
It has been found that the Qlo value is effected by the nature of the cover strip. For example whereas a sterility indicator which uses polypropylene as the rate controlling cover strip and ethoxy benzamide as the organic compound has a Qlo of about 18. When mylar (polyethylene glycolterepthalic acid ester) is used as the cover strip the Qlo is about 4-5. -~
Since most organic compounds are colorless, it is desirable to include a dye in the organic compound to make it visible on the wicking means. Alternately, the dye may be applied to the initial portion (nearest the pellet of organic compound) of the wicking means. As the organic compound moves along the wick it picks up dyestuff and carries it along the wicking means. Any suitable dye which is soluble in the organic compound may be used. Illustrative - ~; .
examples of such dyes are: methylene blue, crystal violet, malachite green, brilliant green, methyl violet and methyl g~een.
Where the organic compound is acid or basic it may be made vislblo by presaturating the wicking means with a suitable pH
sensitive dye. As the organic compound wicks along the wicking means it will causea color response change in the pH sensitive dye.
Illustrative examples of such pH sensitive dyes are phenol-phthalein,;
xylenol blue, Nile blue A, m-cresol purple, bromocresol green, thymol blue, bromophenol blue, alizarin, bromophenol red, methyl red, brilliant yellow, phenol red, etc.
EXAMPLE I
Sterility Indicators were prepared using aluminum foil as the backing strip and ~hatman ~1 filter paper as the wicking means.
The wick was about 1/4" x 4". Pellets of organic compound were prepared using about 50 mg of compound. General Electric Company's silicone adhesive Sil Grip 574 was used to bond the rate controlling * Trade Mark B - lo .
.. . .
, . . . . . . .

~05941Z
cover strip to the backing, the adhesive being applied to the backing only.
Each device was tested in a steam autoclave for a fixed period of time at various temperatures. The conditions and results are tabulated in Table I.

X _~ ~ N¦ N¦ --,I N¦

rl 0 ~ ~' N ~ 1 ~ ~D O ~ ~
U ~ _, ~ _, ~ ~ ~ _l ;

, . ;~' O ~ ~ O O O O O O U~OO '~
O ~U O
O ~C ~ ~ ~ ~ N ~ ~ ~ N
~ b H ~ ~ ~ ¦ O
~ ~ ~ E-~
~ ~ ~ . ';';,'" ' ~ ~ ~ h.,.~ h~I

u o ~

~ ~ ~, o ~ . .
o o ~ ~ ~ o ~ . ..
p, _ N N N ~1 Z
* ' ., ~a ~ o U ~ , o y ~ ;

~ o ¦ ~ U N ,~ ~ `
O ~.) D U~ Cl ns - , ,.,' , ' , ~.

10594~2 E ~o ¦ ~ ~ .
U~ U~

~U
~_ 0 0 ~ O ~D a~ _I CD ' ' .Y ~ 1:: ~ 1 ~ ~ _1 _1 ~ ~r ' ' 3'~ .

_I ~ ~ u~oomou~o o u~o ..o )~ O ~ u~

O ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ N~ ~ ~ ~ ~ .

E~ I oo~
~ ~ E

~ ~d ~ ~

f~ N

~ V _ ~ -ZO

~ U 'a ' ~
- :~ 1: 'a O N
o E3 U~

. ...
- 13 - ~
. .~.~ . . .
- ~

105~41Z
a~
r~ O -i:
x a-' ~ ;' ~ g I '.~

æ a o ~ " ~ U~ O O U~ O U~ O O U~ O ' -O ~ ~
~u~ ~ 3 ~

~ ~ ~ oo ''''`~
H '¢ E~ ~ e ~I ~UI 31 ~V~aI

.~.' .
, ,- , ~o . , ~ :
E ~ ~ :

~ `', a ~ - ' - ' lOSS~4~Z
The data presented in Table I shows that both the thickness of cover strip and its composition will effect the Qlo value obtained using the same organic compound.

Example 2 Data was obtained on samples prepared in the manner of Example I using ethoxy benzamide as the organic compound and 1 1/4 mil polypropylene as the cover strip.
The results for various time exposures at different ~-temperatures are shown in terms of a bar graph in Figure 2. The length of the bar represents the wicking distance for the time , and temperature shown. The vertical line shows the wicking distance required for 100~ spore kill in a steam sterilization process. The data presented demonstrates that the device of this invention is capable of intergrating the time/temperature exposure to a saturated steam atmosphere.

Example 3 The device of Example 2 was subjected to temperatures below 270F, the normal melting point of ethoxy benzamide using an oil bath. No wicking occured. The same experiment was repeated at temperatures as high as 275F. Wicking was very slow as compared to in a steam atmosphere. These results show that `
the device of this invention is inoperative at normal sterilization temperatures in the absence of saturated steam. Under such conditions, therefore, the device would indicate inadequate sterilization.
Figure 3 shows a comparison of the device of this invention as described in Example 3 against spore strips as a sterility indicator. It is noted that the time/temperature coefficient of the sterility indicator of this invention mimics spore kill.
Furthermore, for a given temperature the safe reading for the recommended sterilization is always slightly more than the time required forsporekill. Hence, the device will fail safe if exposure times are insufficient.

' , : ,.

1.059412 Although the invention is described in terms of a sterility indicator, it will be obvious to those skilled in the art that it -:
will have other applications such as pasteurization e.g. beer :~
pasteurization at 140F.

.:

:
' - 16 - . ~

Claims

The embodiments of the invention in which an exclusive property or privilege is claimed are defined as follows:

1. A sterility indicator device for use in a steam autoclave comprising:
a. a backing strip b. an organic compound having a normal melting point which is greater than a predetermined control temperature said melting point being depressed below said control temperature by the absorption of water into the organic compound when said organic-compound is exposed to saturated water vapor at the control temperature, said control temperature being below the normal melting point of the organic compound, said compound being mounted on said backing strip c. a wicking means having one end of said wicking means in intimate contact with said compound, said wicking means extending away from said compound and being mounted on said backing strip; and d. a water vapor transmission rate controlling cover strip overlayer covering said compound and wicking means said cover strip being bonded to said backing strip and being permeable to water vapor and having a water permeability coefficient at the control temperature such that sufficient water vapor will permeate the cover strip to reduce the melting point of the organic compound from its normal melting point to the control temperature; said device being inoperative at the predetermined control temper-ature in the absence of saturated steam and displaying a visual response of the integrated time/temperature exposure of a system to moist heat.

2. The indicator according to claim 1 wherein the backing strip is aluminum foil.

3. The indicator according to claim 1 wherein the organic compound selected from the group consisting of ethoxy benzamide, 2-chloro acetamide, dihydroxy benzaphenone and benzoic acid.

4. The indicator according to claim 1 wherein the cover strip is a film of material selected from the group con-sisting of Mylar*, polypropylene, and cellulose acetate.

5. The indicator according to claim 1 wherein the organic compound is ethoxy benzamide, the cover strip is poly-propylene film and the backing strip is aluminum foil.

6. The indicator according to claim 1 wherein the wicking means is paper.

7. The indicator according to claim 1 wherein a dye is incorporated into the organic compound.

8. The indicator according to claim 7 wherein the dye is selected from the group consisting of methylene blue, malachite green and brilliant green.

9. The indicator according to claim 5 wherein a dye is incorporated into the ethoxy benzamide.

10. The indicator according to claim 9 wherein the dye is methylene blue.

11. The indicator of claim 1 wherein the wicking means is impregnated with a dye at an end of said wicking means near the organic compound.

12. The indicator of claim 11 wherein the dye is methylene blue.

* Trade Mark

13. The indicator of claim 1 wherein the wicking means is adhesively bonded to the backing strip.

14. The indicator of claim 1 wherein the cover strip is adhesively bonded to the backing strip.

15. The indicator of claim 14 wherein the adhesive is a silicone adhesive.

16. The indicator according to claim 1 wherein the organic compound is an acidic compound and the wicking means is presaturated with a pH sensitive dye.

17. The indicator of claim 1 wherein the organic compound is a basic compound and the wicking means is pre-saturated with a suitable pH sensitive dye.