|Publication number||US20080070049 A1|
|Application number||US 11/898,112|
|Publication date||Mar 20, 2008|
|Filing date||Sep 10, 2007|
|Priority date||Sep 11, 2006|
|Also published as||US7833581|
|Publication number||11898112, 898112, US 2008/0070049 A1, US 2008/070049 A1, US 20080070049 A1, US 20080070049A1, US 2008070049 A1, US 2008070049A1, US-A1-20080070049, US-A1-2008070049, US2008/0070049A1, US2008/070049A1, US20080070049 A1, US20080070049A1, US2008070049 A1, US2008070049A1|
|Inventors||Liang Guo, Guohua Chen|
|Original Assignee||The Hong Kong University Of Science And Technology|
|Export Citation||BiBTeX, EndNote, RefMan|
|Referenced by (4), Classifications (17), Legal Events (3)|
|External Links: USPTO, USPTO Assignment, Espacenet|
This application claims the benefit of U.S. Provisional Patent Application No. 60/843,172, filed Sep. 11, 2006, the contents of which are hereby incorporated by reference in their entirety.
1. Field of the Invention
The present disclosure relates to the preparation of diamond films, and in particular, to the methods of deposition of diamond on valve metal substrates.
2. Related Art
High quality diamond film has become an attractive electrode material in electrochemical research and in various applications. As an example, diamond film electrodes can sustain redox reactions with more positive or negative standard potentials than those of water split, such as those with large over potentials like the evolution of chlorine, oxygen and hydrogen gases. As another example, diamond film electrodes can support the degradation of various refractory pollutants with high current efficiency, such as ammonia, cyanide, phenol, chlorophenols, aniline, TCE, various dyes, surfactants, and landfill leachate. These applications are discussed in the following articles: R. Tenne et al, J. Electroanal. Chem. 347, 409, (1993); J. Iniesta et al, Electrochem. Commun. 3, 346, (2001); X. Chen et al, Environ. Sci. Technol. 37, 5021, (2003); I. Troster et al, Diamond Relat. Mater. 11, 640, (2002); X. Chen et al, Chem. Eng. Sci. 58, 995, (2003). Moreover, diamond electrodes provide a low and stable background current, which has led to their use in the electro-analytical field.
Methods for diamond film deposition on nondiamond substrates include hot-filament chemical vapor deposition (HFCVD) and microwave plasma assisted chemical vapor deposition (MWPACVD). For these known CVD methods, low pressure (13.3-133 mbar) and high substrate temperature (600-1000° C.) are typically necessary. Commonly, these CVD methods take place in a hydrogen gas environment, which includes gases such as hydrocarbon chemicals, especially methane gas. Hydrogen molecules are decomposed into atomic hydrogen under the high energy input to the CVD system, such as the thermal energy from the filament in HFCVD system and plasma energy in MWPACVD system. The hydrogen radicals play multiple and critical roles during the process of diamond formation, and work as the main reactants and the energy source for the reactions. Low pressure in the system prolongs the retention time and increases the mean free path of the radicals produced in the gas phase. The high substrate temperature provides the energy for the surface reaction to form diamond crystals.
Some methods are known for depositing diamond film on various nondiamond substrates, including titanium, with CVD methods, but these are all problematic. In the methods using a titanium substrate, due to the high substrate temperature and the large difference of the thermal expansion coefficient between diamond and titanium, the diamond and substrate experience nearly a 7 GPa thermal stress under a substrate temperature of 1170K. Further, in these methods, intrinsic stress results from structural mismatches, such as different lattice constant between the deposited diamond film and the substrate. Moreover, residual stress in the film, resulting from thermal stress and intrinsic stress, will reduce adhesion of the diamond film to the substrate, and may even cause the diamond film to peel away from the substrate during the cooling process after deposition. Accordingly, stability of the diamond film electrode is of the highest concern, and has impeded its widespread utilization.
U.S. Patent Application Publication No. 2005/0186345 suggests a pre-treatment process to obtain a uniform and high density nucleus with good reproducibility. The process includes the consecutive processes of blasting with ceramic particles, surface cleaning with an acid or base wash, heat treatment in vacuum or inert atmosphere, and ultrasonic scratching in nanodiamond particles. It is believed that these pre-treatment steps allow the formation of interlayers between the film and substrate during coating of the substrate by CVD, PVD, sputtering, or plating methods. These interlayers ideally have only small thermal coefficient differences and lattice constant differences between themselves and their adjacent layers, and thus play a positive role in improving the adhesion of the diamond film with the substrate. However, this technique is problematic. Particularly, the final pretreatment process of ultrasonic scratching with high hardness particles can leave the coated interlayer removable. Loss of the interlayer leads to peeling of the superficial film, causing the electrode to stop functioning. Further, this technique does not account for the thickness and porosity of the interlayers being formed, where think and porous interlayers are known to reduce adhesion of film to substrate. Additionally, this technique only attends to the formation of an interlayer between the diamond film and substrate, and not to the formation of useful interlayers of varying degrees of diamond content.
U.S. Pat. No. 5,587,013 is drawn to a technique for reducing residual stress between a diamond film and substrate, but this technique too is problematic. The technique involves alternately growing a potential-concave diamond layer (substrate temperature of 880° C. to 950° C. and a hydrocarbon ratio of 2.5 vol % to 3.5 vol %) and a potential-convex diamond layer (substrate temperature of 800° C. to 850° C. and a hydrocarbon ration of 0.5 vol % to 1.5 vol %). This technique fails to improve adhesion at the substrate surface, ignores the formation and nature of any interlayers, and further provides poor superficial diamond quality when the substrate temperature is reduced.
Similarly, U.S. Pat. No. 6,319,439 is drawn to a technique for compensating the intrinsic tensile stress of a diamond film with a step down control of the deposition temperature during deposition. Again, this technique fails to improve adhesion at the substrate surface, ignores the formation and nature of any interlayers, and further provides poor superficial diamond quality when the substrate temperature is reduced.
Thus, all of the known methods for vapor deposition of diamond films fail to provide both a superior superficial diamond quality and a strong adhesion to an underlying substrate.
The present subject matter addresses the above concerns by teaching the following methods and apparatuses.
The present disclosure includes a method of depositing a stable diamond film on a substrate. The method includes providing a metal substrate, pretreating the substrate surface, and placing the substrate in a reaction chamber. A diamond film is then deposited on the substrate by way of a 2-10 stage chemical vapor deposition method. First, the substrate temperature is increased from a starting temperature (TS) to a first stage temperature (T1) in a set period of time (ti1). Then, while the substrate is kept at the first stage temperature (T1) for a period of working time (t1), diamond, optionally accompanied by other elements or materials, is deposited on the pretreated surface of the substrate. Then for each further deposition stage, the substrate temperature is increased to a higher temperature (Tn) over another period of time (tin), and then while the substrate is kept at the n-th stage temperature (Tn) for a further period of working time (tn), diamond, optionally accompanied by other elements or materials, is deposited. After deposition, the substrate and the diamond film are cooled for a period of cooling time (tif).
A total number of stages N may be performed, such that N can range from 2 to 10 stages. Accordingly, the step index n increases from 2 to N. These are non-limiting examples, however, and more than N=10 stages may occur.
In some aspects, each time tin is selected from the range of about 1 minute to 30 minutes. This is a non-limiting example, however, and other ranges may be used. For example, each time tin may be selected from the range of about 1 minute to 20 minutes, from the range of about 5 minutes to 30 minutes, from the range of about 30 seconds to 30 minutes, or from the range of about 1 minute to 60 minutes.
In some aspects, each time tn is selected from the range of about 1 to 10 hours. This is a non-limiting example, however, and other ranges may be used. For example, each time tn may be selected from the range of about 1 to 5 hours, from the range of about 2 to 10 hours, from the range of about 30 minutes to 10 hours, or from the range of about 1 to 20 hours.
In some aspects, each substrate temperature Tn is selected from the range of about 300-1000° C. This is a non-limiting example, however, and other ranges may be used. For example, each substrate temperature Tn may be selected from the range of about 300-800° C., from the range of about 400-1000° C., from the range of about 100-1000° C., or from the range of about 300-1200° C.
In some aspects, each temperature difference between each temperature Tn and its subsequent temperature Tn+1 is selected from the range of about 50-300° C. This is a non-limiting example, however, and other ranges may be used. For example, each temperature difference between each temperature Tn and its subsequent temperature Tn+1 may be selected from the range of about 50-200° C., from the range of about 100-300° C., from the range of about 20-300° C., or from the range of about 50-400° C.
In some aspects, the cooling occurs at a cooling rate from the range of about 0.5-10° C./min. This is a non-limiting example, however, and other ranges may be used. For example, the cooling may occur at a cooling rate from the range of about 2-10° C./min, from the range of about 0.5-5° C./min, from the range of about 0.2-10° C./min, or from the range of about 0.5-20° C./min.
In some aspects, reaction chamber pressure is kept in the range of about 20-120 mbar, gas flow rate in the reaction chamber is kept in the range of about 100-500 SCCM, and the hydrocarbon gas to hydrogen gas ratio is kept in the range of about 0.3 vol %-3 vol %. These are non-limiting examples, however, and other ranges may be used.
In some aspects, the substrate is titanium, a titanium alloy, or combinations of these. In some aspects, the substrate is more generally a valve metal. In some aspects, the substrate is tantalum, a tantalum alloy, tungsten, or a tungsten alloy.
In some aspects, the pretreatment process includes polishing, ultrasonic scratching with a diamond paste, surface cleaning, ultrasonic washing, or combinations of these.
In some aspects, at least some of the diamond deposited on the film is doped with boron. This is a non-limiting example, however, and other dopants may be used.
In some aspects, a first-stage temperature and time are together selected to produce a dense, thin distribution of a carbide of metal of the metal substrate, and a final stage temperature and time are together selected to produce a diamond layer having a crystal size of less than 2 μm.
In some aspects, the deposition step includes at least two stages. A first-stage temperature and time are together selected to produce a carbide of metal of the metal substrate, and a later-stage temperature and time are together selected to produce a layer of diamond and nondiamond carbon which adhesively joins the carbide layer with the superficial diamond.
In some aspects, the depositing step is performed by way of hot-filament chemical vapor deposition.
In some aspects, the substrate and the diamond film together form an electrode. Such an electrode is advantageous in electrolysis for wastewater treatment, and in the electrochemical analysis of pollutants in water. In other aspects, the substrate and the diamond film together form a tooth or blade configured for use in a cutting tool. These are non-limiting examples, and other structures with an advantageous diamond coating may be made according to the presently disclosed methods.
In at least one aspect, the metal substrate includes titanium, the starting temperature TS is room temperature, the deposition step has two stages, T1 is about 650° C., t1 is about 5 hours, T2 is about 750° C., t2 is about 5 hours, and the depositing step is performed by way of hot-filament chemical vapor deposition.
The present disclosure is also drawn to a diamond film coated electrode. The electrode includes a metal substrate, a top layer of diamond and optional other elements, and at least one buffer layer between the metal substrate and the top layer. The buffer layer includes a mixture of diamond and amorphous carbon.
In some aspects, the electrode also includes an interlayer. The interlayer includes a carbide compound of carbon and of metal of the metal substrate. The interlayer is between the buffer layer and the substrate. The buffer layer adhesively joins the interlayer to the top layer.
In some aspects, the metal substrate may include titanium, titanium alloy, iron, iron alloy, or combinations of these.
In some aspects, the electrode has a compositionally graded metal structure. This structure may or may not have distinct layers.
In some aspects, the top layer of the electrode includes boron-doped diamond.
The features, nature, and advantages of the presently disclosed methods and apparatuses will become more apparent from the detailed description set forth below when taken in conjunction with the drawings in which like reference characters identify corresponding items throughout.
The present disclosure includes a method of depositing a stable diamond film on a substrate, in a manner which forms one or more interlayers between the substrate and the superficial diamond layer. Interlayer performance is controlled by adjusting reaction conditions, to provide superior superficial diamond quality and strong adhesion to an underlying substrate. Prior to diamond deposition, a carbide layer can be deposited on the metal substrate, if the metal substrate has a high carbon affinity, such as Ti, Ta, W, and other metals or alloys. Properties of the carbide layer may be adjusted by adjusting the reaction conditions. Not all carbide layers are sufficient as a buffer to increase the adhesion of the diamond on the metal substrate. Accordingly, reaction conditions can be adjusted to avoid a rough and porous carbide layer, which would otherwise severely reduce adhesion. Although to some extent the thickness of the carbide layer can also be changed with the adjustment of the hydrocarbon chemical content in the gas phase, morphology as well as thickness of the carbide layer on the metals, especially for titanium, can be more sensitively adjusted by adjusting substrate temperature.
Accordingly, the presently disclosed method makes use of a 2-10 stage chemical vapor deposition process. First, the substrate temperature is increased from a starting temperature (TS) to a first stage temperature (T1) in a set period of time (ti1). Then, while the substrate is kept at the first stage temperature (T1) for a period of working time (t1), diamond, optionally accompanied by other elements or materials, is deposited on the pretreated surface of the substrate. Then for each further deposition stage, the substrate temperature is increased to a higher temperature (Tn) over another period of time (tin), and then while the substrate is kept at the n-th stage temperature (Tn) for a further period of working time (tn), diamond, optionally accompanied by other elements or materials, is deposited. After deposition, the substrate and the diamond film are cooled for a period of cooling time (tf). A total number of stages N may be performed, such that N can range from 2 to 10 stages. Accordingly, the step index n increases from 2 to N. This method is schematically illustrated in
To better illustrate how substrate temperature affects bonding of an applied film,
As in the present fabrication, TiC is formed before diamond deposition and works as the interlayer due to the high carbon affinity of Ti. TiC plays a positive role in reducing the thermal stress due to lower thermal expansion coefficient of 7×10−6/K than Ti of 9.5×10−6/K. However, only 26% of the thermal stress can be reduced by this method, and performance of the TiC interlayer, e.g. morphology and thickness, may be changed by modifying the conditions of fabrication, and especially the substrate temperature as described herein. The TiC layer can be as thick as 150 μm or too thin to detect. It can be porous or with dense crystal shape. As noted above, a thick and porous TiC interlayer will definitely reduce adhesion of diamond film with the substrate.
While adhesion is essential for the usefulness and longevity of a diamond film electrode, the crystal quality of the superficial diamond layer also has a great influence on the overall electrochemical properties of the electrode. Unlike adhesion, which can be negatively affected by high-temperature deposition, crystal quality can in fact be negatively affected by low-temperature deposition. A high quality electrode requires high diamond crystal quality. Raman spectroscopy has been a powerful tool and a commonly used method in analysis of carbon films due to its ability to distinguish different bonding types and quantify the relative phase to each peak. Full-width-half-maximum (FWHM) value of a peak can show the crystallinity of the relative phase. The Raman peaks located at the center of 1332 cm−1, 1550 cm−1 and 1590 cm−1 refer to diamond and nondiamond carbon, including graphite and amorphous carbon, respectively.
A stable diamond film electrode requires a superficial layer of diamond with high quality and high adhesion with the substrate. Under a high substrate temperature, high superficial diamond quality can be obtained, but the adhesion will be reduced due to the formation of a rough and porous carbide layer. Comparatively, under a low substrate temperature, high adhesion of the diamond layer with the substrate can be obtained due to the formation of a dense carbide buffer layer, but the crystal quality of the deposited diamond will be reduced. Therefore, the problem for using a high substrate temperature is the low working life time of the fabricated diamond film electrode, and the problem for the low substrate temperature is the low electrochemical performance.
Accordingly, the presently disclosed method result in a high quality top diamond layer, without sacrificing good adhesion with the substrate. The method integrates the advantages of the high and low substrate temperature deposition process. The high quality top diamond layer is fabricated under a high substrate temperature, and the adhesive interlayer is made under a low substrate temperature prior to the top layer formation process.
Deposition performed according to the above description (and more generally to those methods disclosed herein) have successfully resulted in high quality diamond film coated objects. Due to the relatively low substrate temperatures during the initial deposition process, high adhesion of the diamond film with the substrate is achieved. During the early stages, under low substrate temperature, a dense carbide layer is coated on the metal substrate, and a layer of diamond and nondiamond carbon mixture covers the carbide layer. The dense carbide layer possesses high adhesion with the substrate and the mixture layer of diamond and nondaimond carbon, working as cement, can improve the adhesion with the coated diamond layer. Due to the relatively high substrate temperature during the final deposition process, the top diamond layer is fabricated with high quality. Low nondiamond carbon content is found in the diamond phase, which shows high crystallinity. The high quality diamond top layer possesses high electrochemical properties.
A specific sequence of steps performed in fabricating a diamond film electrode will now be described. The electrode was grown on a pure titanium substrate according to the presently disclosed multi-stage hot-filament chemical vapor deposition (HFCVD) method. In order to increase the conductivity, boron element was doped into the diamond film by adding boron containing chemicals into the gas phase.
In order to enhance the practical application, selection of a proper substrate material is important. Titanium is a preferred choice due to its relatively low price, high anti-corrosion and quick repassivation behavior, compared with silicon and some other valve metals, such as tantalum and niobium. However, in some circumstances it may be advantageous to use these and other valve metals, which may be used as substrates in any of the presently disclosed methods. A boron doped diamond film coated on titanium substrate (Ti/BDD) electrode has attracted much attention as one of the most ideal electrodes, especially when used as an anode.
Thus, in the present instance, ultrahigh pure hydrogen and methane gases were mixed and directed into a HFCVD reactor chamber. The gas flow rate was controlled by a mass flow controller, and the ratio of the hydrocarbon gas to hydrogen gas was adjusted by changing the gas flow rates. Trimethyl-Borate (B(OCH3)3) was used as a boron doping source, and Dimethyl-Methane (CH2(OCH3)2) was added into the gas phase to promote diamond nucleation and growth process. The coil-shaped Φ6 mm×35 mm filament was made with Φ0.5 mm tantalum wire. The substrate was a Ti disk with dimension of Φ12 mm×2 mm. The distance between the substrate and the center of the filament coil was kept at 9 mm. Substrate temperature and filament temperature were monitored by a thermal couple and an infrared thermometer, respectively.
In order to improve the adhesion of diamond film to substrates, diamond nucleation may be increased and interlayers may be built. Ultrasonic scratching of a substrate with a colloid of micro-sized diamond particles is an effective way to improve the nucleation rate, due to the high energy sites left on the surface after scratching with the high hardness particles. Thus, in the present instance, the Ti substrate was firstly treated with ultrasonic scratching using a diamond paste, a mixture of 1 gram of 1 μm sized diamond powder in 10 ml of acetone, for 30 minutes. Afterwards, the substrate was cleaned with an ultrasonic wash in de-ionized water for 5 minutes, to remove the diamond particles adhered on the sample surface. The optimal conditions were determined to be as follows, except for the substrate temperature: CH4 in H2 ratio=1%, H2 gas flow rate=300 sccm, Tfil=2000-2300° C., and chamber pressure=40 mbar (see L. Guo et al, Diam. Relat. Mater. submitted).
The diamond film electrode was thus fabricated under a two-stage (N=2) method. During the deposition period, the CH4 in H2 ratio, H2 gas flow rate, and chamber pressure were kept stable. The substrate temperature was kept at 650° C. (T1) in the first stage and the working time was 5 hours (t1). The substrate temperature in the second stage (T2) was 750° C., and the working time (t2) was 5 hours. For comparison purposes, another diamond film electrode was fabricated under a constant temperature condition (not according to the presently disclosed multi-stage method; Tsub=750° C.) for 10 hours.
Electrode stability was tested, both for the electrode fabricated according to the presently disclosed two-stage method, and for the electrode fabricated according to a constant temperature method. Each diamond film electrode was subjected to an accelerated life test, in which the electrode was anodically polarized under galvanostatic condition with a current density of 1 A/cm2 in 3M H2SO4 solution. It is noted that these are extreme conditions, and the real service life of either electrode would be much longer under normal operation conditions. All chemicals were commercial analytical grade and the solution was prepared with ultrapure deionzed water (17.9 MΩcm). The accelerated life end-point was deemed to have been reached when a sharp increase in the voltage, 5 volts, was observed. This point is also taken as the point of electrode failure, believed to be mainly due to film delamination. The working lives of the constant temperature electrode and the two-stage electrode, respectively, were 244 hours and 804 hours. The constant temperature electrode, which failed earlier, was analyzed and deemed to have many more sites where the diamond film split away than the two-stage electrode.
Three factors are believed to cause diamond film delamination: electrochemical corrosion, mechanical force on the diamond film due to the gas bubble evolution under serious polarization in severe environment, and residual stress left in the as-deposited film. The above delamination is believed to have arisen from the latter two sources. This is because diamond crystal, which is very stable under various severe conditions, is calculated to have a corrosion rate in 3M H2SO4 of 7.7×10−4 μm/hr, according to electrochemical polarization measurements and extrapolations in the Tafel regime. Since the thickness of the above sample formed according to the presently disclosed two-stage method is 2 μm, and that of the sample formed at constant temperature is 5 μm, with the calculated corrosion rate no diamond film spallation should be visible after the mentioned accelerated life test period. Thus, mechanical force due to gas bubble evolution and residual stress in the film should be the main reasons for failure. As mentioned in the background information, residual stress itself in the film mainly comes from two sources: (a) strain mismatch due to the difference of lattice constants of substrate and thin film; (b) thermal stress for the different thermal expansion coefficients of substrate and thin film.
Although the above disclosure is drawn to electrodes, the disclosed methods may be applied in other areas where diamond coating is desired or advantageous. Thus, the present methods are useful not only in the fabrication of electrodes such as those used in electrolysis for wastewater treatment, and in the electrochemical analysis of pollutants in water. As a non-limiting example, the substrate and the diamond film may together form a tooth or blade configured for use in a cutting tool, where high external stress and internal temperature fluctuations lead to delamination, and thus where the improved adhesive properties disclosed herein may be advantageous.
Also, although the above disclosure is drawn to two stage processes, the same benefits conferred by a two-step deposition process may be achieved in a process of three, four, or even more stages. As non-limiting examples, three or more deposition stages at successively higher temperatures can provide more layers of diamond and amorphous carbon at varying ratios, smoothing the transition between layers and further reducing delamination. Similarly, the use of three or more deposition stages can allow the final stage to occur at even higher temperatures than those described herein, and thus provide better superficial qualities, without jeopardizing the adhesion to the underlying layer. Thus, the present disclosure is not limited to two-stage deposition, but is directed to multi-stage deposition generally, as shown, described, and claimed.
The previous description of some aspects is provided to enable any person skilled in the art to make or use the presently disclosed methods and apparatuses. Various modifications to these aspects will be readily apparent to those skilled in the art, and the generic principles defined herein may be applied to other aspects without departing from the spirit or scope of the invention. For example, one or more elements can be rearranged and/or combined, or additional elements may be added. Thus, the present invention is not intended to be limited to the aspects shown herein but is to be accorded the widest scope consistent with the principles and novel features disclosed herein.
|Citing Patent||Filing date||Publication date||Applicant||Title|
|US7866342||Apr 9, 2007||Jan 11, 2011||Vapor Technologies, Inc.||Valve component for faucet|
|US7866343||Jun 18, 2008||Jan 11, 2011||Masco Corporation Of Indiana||Faucet|
|US8727201 *||Mar 12, 2013||May 20, 2014||Telsonic Holding Ag||Tool for ultrasonic welding device|
|WO2015081159A1 *||Nov 26, 2014||Jun 4, 2015||Uab Research Foundation||Composites comprising nanostructured diamond and metal boride films and methods for producing same|
|U.S. Classification||428/457, 427/249.7|
|International Classification||B32B15/04, C23C16/00|
|Cooperative Classification||Y10T428/31678, C02F2001/46147, C23C16/278, C23C16/27, C23C16/272, C23C16/0272, C23C16/279, C25B11/0478|
|European Classification||C23C16/27Q, C23C16/27, C23C16/27E, C23C16/27S, C23C16/02H|
|Sep 10, 2007||AS||Assignment|
Owner name: THE HONG KONG UNIVERSITY OF SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY
Free format text: ASSIGNMENT OF ASSIGNORS INTEREST;ASSIGNORS:GUO, LIANG;CHEN, GUOHUA;REEL/FRAME:019853/0789
Effective date: 20070907
|Jan 11, 2011||CC||Certificate of correction|
|Dec 5, 2013||FPAY||Fee payment|
Year of fee payment: 4