|Publication number||US3703824 A|
|Publication date||Nov 28, 1972|
|Filing date||May 11, 1970|
|Priority date||May 11, 1970|
|Publication number||US 3703824 A, US 3703824A, US-A-3703824, US3703824 A, US3703824A|
|Inventors||Robert C Haines, John A Kilshaw, Denis A N Osborne|
|Original Assignee||Dunlop Co Ltd|
|Export Citation||BiBTeX, EndNote, RefMan|
|Patent Citations (6), Referenced by (35), Classifications (12)|
|External Links: USPTO, USPTO Assignment, Espacenet|
United States Patent Osborne a til.
 APPARATUS FOR COMPARING MOMENTS OF INER'HA OF GOLF CLUBS  inventors: Deni A. N. Olhorne, Liverpool; Robert C. Hahn, Huddersfield; John A. Kihluw. Netherton, near Wakefield llofEndlnd  Asaignee: 'l'lnIhIIopConqamyUML/om don, England  Filed: my 11, 1970 [21) Appi. No.: 36,478
Related U.S. Appliedion Data  Continuation-impart of Ser. No. 702,668, Feb.
2, i968, abandoned.
 US. Cl. "73/65  Int. Cl. ..G01Ill 1/12  Field of Search ..73/65, 456
[ Islam Cited UNTI'ED STATES PATENTS l,35i,768 9/ i920 Lawton "73/65 CLUI MOMENT OF WEIGHT-gent: IO AIOUT AXIS I. I
1451 Nov. 28, 1972 1,953,916 4/1934 Adams ..73I6S 2,349,736 5/1944 Knobei a ai. .................73/6$ 3,i06,09l 10/1963 Kon- ..73l65 3,473,370 10/1969 Marcmiak ..73l65 FOREIGN PATENTS on APPLICATIONS 38 1,129 10/1932 Great Britain.................73/65 Primary Exandner-Richard C. Queisser Assistant Examiner-C. E. Snee, [Ii Attomey-Stevens, Davis, Miller 8: Mosh/er ABSTRACT A set of golf club! is provided which is balanced on the principle of common moment of inertia" as oppouedtotheprioranaetswhicharebaimcedonthe principle of common "moment of weight." The momentinertiaaboutagivenaxis ofanyciubinthe set is no more than 5 percent, preferably 2 percent, particularly 1 percent greater than that ot'the club having the iowestmomentofirmtiaintheset. Usuailythesaid axisisonewhichpasaeshm'izontallythroughthetop endoftheahaft.
woops MOMENT or mum r t-M31110 "our ms A.
PAIENTEU m 2 8 I312 SHEEI 1 (IF 3 FIG! IRONS 6-36; 4-l7i z-sai WOODS Z Z7 Z8 29 3O MOMENT OF INERTIA cm xlo ABOUT AXIS A.
PATENTEU Nov 2 a ma SHEEI 2 0F 3 NOE APPARATUS FOR COMPARING MOMENTS F INERTIA 0F GOLF CLUBS The application is a continuation in part of application Ser. No. 702,668 filed Feb. .2, 1968, now abandoned.
This invention relates to golf clubs and is particularly concerned with a new method and apparatus for grading clubs.
in the game of golf, a set of clubs usually comprises a total of seven to fourteen woods and irons having different lengths, weights and loft of club heads, enabling the golfer to hit shots of varying distance and trajectory and with varying degrees of control. In this specification unless otherwise stated the term set of clubs" excludes the putter.
At the present, most golf sets are graded to a common moment of weight about some point for every club in the set. In one commonly used machine for balancing clubs this point is 30 cm. from the top end of the club. when the club is placed on the machine to balance it to a given moment of weight a force is applied to the top end of the club so that when the club is balanced the moment of this force about the balance point (i.e., 30 cm. from the top end of the club) plus the moment of that 30 cm. of club will be equalized by the moment of the remainder of the club about the balance point.
For any set of clubs to be balanced to a given moment of weight the force applied to the top end of each club when being balanced on the machine is constant. Thus, two clubs of the same type could be balanced by this machine but the weight of the various parts of the club (i.e., the head, shaft and grip) might be widely differing and to a golfer they would have a different "feel." It follows that within any set of clubs balanced on these swing weight machines not all clubs will have the same feel" with consequent disadvantages to the golfer's game.
We have now found according to the present invention that for golf clubs in a set to have the same feel," that is to be a balanced set, they must have the same moment of inertia about an axis round which the golfer swings the club.
FIG. I is a graph showing the relationship between the moment of weight and the moment of inertia of golf clubs for clubs of a number of different lengths and varying head-weights,
FIG. 2 is a diagrammatic representation of a machine for measuring moment of inertia according to the invention;
FIG. 3 is a graph showing the true moments of inertia of a set of golf clubs graded to constant moment of weight against the moments of inertia obtained using the machine of FIG. 2;
FIG. 4 is a similar graph to FIG. 3 but for a number of golf clubs of identical length but different weight.
Sets of clubs balanced to a common moment of weight" or by other previously known methods do not exhibit constant moments of inertia about any axis. We have found that the moment of inertia of clubs in golf sets balanced by previously known methods can differ by as much as 8 per cent or more.
The present invention is based on the principle of a common moment of inertia" about an axis for each golf club in the set. Any axis which is at an angle of from 45 to 90 with the shaft of the club and is positioned at or above the average midpoint where the golfer grips the club can be specified (i.e., usually 5 to 15 cm. but more usually 7.5 to 12.5 cm. from the top end of the golf club), but the following description is with particular reference to an axis perpendicular to the longitudinal axis of the golf shaft at the top end of the golf club. This axis corresponds to an axis through the wrist of the upper hand of the golfer and is the most important axis a golf club turns about during a golf stroke. Hereafter, this axis is called axis A.
Accordingly, the present invention provides a set of golf clubs (as hereinbefore defined) in which the moment of inertia of any club in the set is no more than 5 percent greater than that of a club having the lowest moment of inertia in the said set; the said moments of inertia being those about an axis through a point in the shaft of the club, said axis being at an angle of from 45 to with the shaft of the club and said point being no more than 15 cm. from the top end of the club. Preferably, the variation in the said moments of inertia is no greater than 2 percent, particularly 1 percent. If desired the putter can also be balanced to within the same tolerances.
In a modification of the invention the set balanced according to the invention may exclude the woods and in a further modification it may exclude the irons, i.e., the invention merely provides a set of irons or woods as the case may be.
As stated previously the preferred axis is perpendicular to the longitudinal axis of the shaft at the top end of the golf club (axis A) and will of course depend on where the golfer grips the club but is usually no more than 5 cm. from the end and is more usually at the very end of the shaft.
The moment of inertia of golf clubs about axis A is the sum of the moments of inertia of its component parts the golf head, the shaft and the grip about that axis.
The component parts of present day golf clubs are fairly standardized in weight and general form, and if these components are used then the moment of inertia of a particular length of shaft about axis A can be assumed constant, while the moment of inertia of the grip about this axis can be assumed negligible.
Under these conditions, the moment of inertia of an assembled golf club is dependent upon the length of the club and the weight of the head. We have found that it is possible to predict the moment of inertia of a golf club about an axis A from the value of its moment of weight about some other axis.
The moment of weight of the golf club can be measured about any axis. However, an axis near to the center of gravity of the golf grip leads to the best prediction of club moment of inertia, because in this position variations in the golf grip which have a negligible effect on the moment of inertia of the club have a negligible effect on the moment of weight of a club. An axis 9 cm. from the end is usually chosen as the most suitable point with these considerations in mind. Hereafter this axis will be referred to as axis B.
The relationship between the moment of inertia of golf clubs about axis A and their moment of weight about axis B for varying club head weights and club lengths is illustrated in FIG. 1.
The relationship shows that club head weights must be chosen on a progressive scale to give a constant moment of inertia value to clubs of different length. For a unit change in club length, the shortest clubs need a much larger change in head weight than the longest clubs if they are all to have a constant moment of inertia.
The invention includes an apparatus for measuring or comparing the moment of inertia of a golf club based on our discovery described above so that a set balanced according to the invention can be easily made up, which comprises a balancing bar carrying a cradle for the golf club, and a stop; the cradle and stop being so arranged with respect to each other and the bar that they support a golf club in a horizontal position above the bar; a pivot point for the bar which is positioned beneath a chosen axis in the golf club when the golf club is in position, the balance of the bar being adjusted by two counter-weights which move over separate scales, the first scale being positioned on part of the bar and being calibrated in units of moment of inertia or a similar empirical derivation and the second scale being positioned on another part of the bar and being calibrated in length of golf club or golf club number.
The pivot is preferably positioned to coincide with an axis near the center of gravity of the golf grip, usually about 9 cm. from the stop, (i.e., axis B).
Usually, there are at least three of the first type of scale, one for long clubs; one for medium length clubs; and one for short clubs, since the relationship between moment of inertia and moment of weight varies with clubs of different length. Thus for absolute accuracy there should be a scale for each club.
The second scale is not a linear scale but is progressively varying according to the relationship of FIG. I.
To make up a set there are chosen the requisite clubs such that their moments of inertia about the specified axis do not vary by more than the requisite amount. When making up a complete set, it is usual to correlate the moment of inertia of a substantial number of irons and then to select from that number a set of irons such that their moments of inertia do not vary by more than the requisite amount. The woods to complete the set are then taken and their moments of inertia adjusted so that they do not vary by more than the requisite amount from those of the irons.
The invention is further illustrated in FIGS. 2 to 4 of the accompanying drawings. FIG. 2 is a diagrammatic representation of a machine for measuring moment of inertia according to the invention.
It consists of a balancing bar 1 carrying a cradle 2 and a stop 3 so that when a golf club 4 is placed in position, the pivot 5 of the machine is positioned beneath axis B on the golf grip 10. The distance from the pivot point 5 to the stop 3 is usually 9 cms.
Two counterweights 6 and 7 move over scales 8 and Scale 8 is calibrated in inches length of the golf club or in golf club number. It is not a linear scale but varies according to the relationship of FIG. 1.
Scale 9 is a linear scale calibrated in units of moment of inertia. Three scales are shown, one for long clubs, one for medium length clubs and one for short.
In operation, counterweight 6 is set at the length of the p articular golf club on the machine and counterweig t 7 move until the whole system balances, this giving the value of the moment of inertia of the club on the appropriate scale.
Alternatively counterweight 7 is set at a predetermined value and the system balanced by adjusting the weight of the golf club head in any convenient way.
FIG. 3 is a plot of the true moment of inertia values (as measured by the classical oscillation method) of a set of golf clubs graded to a constant moment of weight against the moment of inertia values given by the machine described above with reference to FIG. 2.
FIG. 4 is the same plot for a number of golf clubs of identical length but different weight. No pre-selection of shafts or grips on these golf clubs had taken place. These graphs show that the machine of this invention gives accurate measurements of moment of inertia within the limits of experimental error.
1. An apparatus for comparing the moment of inertia of one golf club with that of another golf club of different length and head weight which comprises a balance beam disposed on a fulcrum, a cradle for supporting a golf club shaft carried by the beam on one side of the fulcrum, means carried by the beam on the opposite side of the fulcrum adapted to receive the grip end of a golf club, said cradle and receiving means being adapted to support a golf club with its longitudinal axis substantially parallel to the longitudinal axis of the beam, a first weight adapted to slide along the beam between the fulcrum and receiving means for counter-balancing the shaft and head of the club, and a second weight on the beam between the fulcrum and head of the golf club, a scale on the beam adjacent one of said weights graduated in club lengths and a second scale adjacent the other of said weights graduated in moments of inertia.
2. The apparatus of claim 1 wherein the fulcrum coincides with an axis near the center of gravity of the golf grip of the club.
3. The apparatus of claim I wherein the moment of inertia scale is three individual scales, one for medium length clubs, one for shorter clubs and one for longer clubs.
4. The apparatus of claim I wherein the moment of inertia scale is a plurality of scales, one for each club of a set of clubs.
* F i t i
|Cited Patent||Filing date||Publication date||Applicant||Title|
|US1351768 *||Mar 22, 1920||Sep 7, 1920||Charles L Lawton||Testing device for golf-clubs|
|US1953916 *||May 15, 1931||Apr 10, 1934||Apparatus fob measuring moments|
|US2349736 *||Oct 28, 1940||May 23, 1944||Spalding A G & Bros Inc||Method and apparatus for testing|
|US3106091 *||Nov 30, 1960||Oct 8, 1963||Korr Abraham L||Systems for measuring moments of inertia|
|US3473370 *||May 20, 1968||Oct 21, 1969||Spalding A G & Bros Inc||Correlated set of golf clubs having the same moment of inertia|
|GB381729A *||Title not available|
|Citing Patent||Filing date||Publication date||Applicant||Title|
|US4058312 *||Sep 5, 1974||Nov 15, 1977||The Square Two Golf Corporation||Golf club|
|US4415156 *||Aug 26, 1981||Nov 15, 1983||Jorgensen Theodore P||Matched set of golf clubs|
|US4603577 *||Dec 21, 1984||Aug 5, 1986||Johnson Louis W||Apparatus for determining the swing inertia of golf clubs|
|US5094101 *||Jun 20, 1990||Mar 10, 1992||Chastonay Herman A||Method for dynamically balancing golf clubs|
|US5152527 *||Dec 28, 1990||Oct 6, 1992||Sports Technology & Research Limited||Sporting equipment|
|US5309753 *||Apr 8, 1993||May 10, 1994||U.S. Golf Association||Apparatus and method for determining the inertia matrix of a rigid body|
|US5318296 *||Nov 12, 1992||Jun 7, 1994||Adams Golf Inc.||Matched sets for golf clubs having maximum effective moment of inertia|
|US5351953 *||Mar 18, 1993||Oct 4, 1994||Mase George T||Dynamically matched set of golf clubs and method and apparatus for designing the same using the inertia tensor|
|US5377978 *||Jul 5, 1994||Jan 3, 1995||Lee; Michael C. W.||Golf club hosel shift|
|US5540090 *||Nov 15, 1994||Jul 30, 1996||Wheatley Golf, Inc.||Head balancing fixture and method of using same|
|US5769733 *||Apr 22, 1996||Jun 23, 1998||Williams; Stan A.||Method for balancing a set of golf clubs|
|US5792946 *||Feb 21, 1997||Aug 11, 1998||Chastonay; Herman A.||Pendulum length balancing of golf clubs including graphite shafted golf clubs|
|US5814773 *||Dec 16, 1996||Sep 29, 1998||Latiri; Mondher||Golf club survey instrument with variable fulcrum|
|US6045455 *||Jan 22, 1997||Apr 4, 2000||Callaway Golf Company||Inertially tailored golf club heads|
|US6186905||Jan 22, 1997||Feb 13, 2001||Callaway Golf Company||Methods for designing golf club heads|
|US6290607||Apr 5, 1999||Sep 18, 2001||Acushnet Company||Set of golf clubs|
|US6482104||Jun 26, 2000||Nov 19, 2002||Acushnet Company||Set of golf clubs|
|US6830519||Apr 23, 2003||Dec 14, 2004||Adams Golf Ip, Lp||Set of iron type golf clubs|
|US6860819||Nov 12, 2002||Mar 1, 2005||Achushnet Company||Set of golf clubs|
|US7416495||Dec 29, 2005||Aug 26, 2008||Bridgestone Sports Co., Ltd.||Golf club|
|US7473184||Dec 29, 2005||Jan 6, 2009||Bridgestone Sports Co., Ltd.||Golf club|
|US7507165||Dec 29, 2005||Mar 24, 2009||Bridgestone Sports Co., Ltd.||Golf club|
|US7509843 *||Oct 27, 2005||Mar 31, 2009||Kostuj William A||Waggle weight|
|US7568981||May 21, 2008||Aug 4, 2009||Bridgestone Sports Co., Ltd.||Golf club|
|US8444501||Dec 17, 2008||May 21, 2013||Isaren Ab||Set of golf clubs|
|US20040214655 *||Apr 23, 2003||Oct 28, 2004||Tim Reed||Set of iron type golf clubs|
|US20060090548 *||Oct 27, 2005||May 4, 2006||Kostuj William A||Waggle weight|
|US20060090549 *||Oct 27, 2005||May 4, 2006||Kostuj William A||Waggle weight|
|US20070105642 *||Dec 29, 2005||May 10, 2007||Bridgestone Sports Co., Ltd.||Golf club|
|US20080234065 *||May 21, 2008||Sep 25, 2008||Bridgestone Sports Co., Ltd.||Golf club|
|US20100255925 *||Dec 17, 2008||Oct 7, 2010||Breit Olsson||Set of golf clubs|
|EP1782862A1 *||Mar 16, 2006||May 9, 2007||Bridgestone Sports Co., Ltd.||Golf club|
|EP1782863A1 *||Mar 16, 2006||May 9, 2007||Bridgestone Sports Co., Ltd.||Golf club|
|EP1782864A1 *||Mar 16, 2006||May 9, 2007||Bridgestone Sports Co., Ltd.||Golf club|
|WO2009082323A1 *||Dec 17, 2008||Jul 2, 2009||Isaren Ab||Set of golf clubs|
|U.S. Classification||73/65.3, 473/291|
|International Classification||G01M1/10, G01M1/00|
|Cooperative Classification||G01M1/10, A63B2053/005, A63B53/04, A63B53/00, A63B59/0074|
|European Classification||G01M1/10, A63B53/00, A63B59/00M|