Search Images Maps Play YouTube News Gmail Drive More »
Sign in
Screen reader users: click this link for accessible mode. Accessible mode has the same essential features but works better with your reader.


  1. Advanced Patent Search
Publication numberUS3895627 A
Publication typeGrant
Publication dateJul 22, 1975
Filing dateJun 21, 1973
Priority dateJul 21, 1971
Publication numberUS 3895627 A, US 3895627A, US-A-3895627, US3895627 A, US3895627A
InventorsLeight Howard S
Original AssigneeLeight Howard S
Export CitationBiBTeX, EndNote, RefMan
External Links: USPTO, USPTO Assignment, Espacenet
Ear protector
US 3895627 A
An ear protector to reduce the effect of high intensity sound upon the human ear. The protector includes a band or other resilient means extending over, under, or around the head and provided with a soft resilient pod at each end. Each pod is formed of a soft resilient material and has an air cushion portion adapted to fit into and over the opening to the ear canal.
Previous page
Next page
Claims  available in
Description  (OCR text may contain errors)

United States Patent [191 Leight 1 *July 22, 1975 1 EAR PROTECTOR [76] inventor: Howard S. Leight, 16027 Northfield St., Pacific Palisades, Calif. 90272 The portion of the term of this patent subsequent to Oct. 30, 1990, has been disclaimed.

[22] Filed: June 21, 1973 [21] Appl. No.: 372,168

Related US. Application Data [62] Division of Ser. No. 164,609, July 21, 1971, Pat. No.

[ Notice:

[52] US. Cl. 128/152 [51] Int. Cl. A6lf 11/02 [58] Field of Search 128/151, 152; 181/23, 33 R [56] References Cited UNITED STATES PATENTS 2,246,736 6/1941 Knudsen 128/152 2,441,866 5/1948 Cantor... 128/152 2,670,737 3/1954 Cantor 128/152 2,785,675 3/1957 Berkman.... 128/152 2,803,247 8/1957 Zwislocki... 128/152 2,824,558 2/1958 Michacl..... 128/152 3,768,470 10/1973 Leight 128/152 Primary Examiner-Richard A. Gaudet Assistant ExaminerHenry .1. Recla Attorney, Agent, or FirmLindenberg, Freilich, Wasserman, Rosen & Fernandez ABSTRACT An ear protector to reduce the effect of high intensity sound upon the human ear. The protector includes a band or other resilient means extending over, under, or around the head and provided with a soft resilient pod at each end. Each pod is formed of a soft resilient material and has an air cushion portion adapted to fit into and over the opening to the ear canal.

2 Claims, 10 Drawing Figures EAR PROTECTOR CROSS-REFERENCE TO RELATED APPLICATION This application is a division of patent application Ser. No. 164,609, filed July 21, 1971 and now US. Pat. No. 3,768,470.

BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION This invention relates generally to devices for protecting the ear from sound or noise of great intensity, such as may be encountered when working in the neighborhood of jet aircraft engines, certain portions of factories, etc. In its simplest form, such an ear protector may consist of a wad of cotton that is stuffed into the ear, but the efficiency of such a cotton wad leaves much to be desired.

In general, the more effective prior art devices have each comprised a resilient band that passes over the head, with a plug of one form or another to be inserted into the ear canal. For example, the patent to Cantor, US. Pat. No. 2,670,737, has a plug consisting of a ho]- low, flexible envelope that is filled with a finely-divided material, such as flaked graphite. The patent to Rosenblatt, US. Pat. No. 3,016,054, has a central ball-shaped nipple surrounded by a soft cup that fits over the ear, while the patent to Glorig, US Pat. No. 3,301,253, shows a cone-shaped member that is intended to extend into the ear canal. In each of these prior art devices, the attempt has been to plug the ear canal so that sound does not enter it. However, in doing this, the canal has been stretched, the seal has been inadequate, or the pressure exerted on the area of the ear surrounding the canal has been excessive. Consequently, less than satisfactory results have been obtained.

SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION The present invention comprises an ear protector including a pair of soft, resilient pods, each shaped to fit at least part way into the ear canal and to extend over the entrance to the canal, so that effective blocking of sound is achieved. This is done by making the pod of a thin-walled, rubber-like material that encloses air trapped within the pod so that a soft, resilient plug is provided, preferably shaped-to conform to the ear. In modified forms, the plug is provided with a small tube extending from the outside of the plug to the inner end to transmit sound, such as might be provided by head phones or the equivalent.

BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS FIG. 1 is a perspective view of a complete ear protector including the head band and pod, indicating how these are placed on the head of the wearer;

FIG. 2 is an elevational view, partly broken away, showing the construction of the pod and its cooperation with the ear;

FIG. 3 is a perspective view, generally similar to FIG. 1, and showing a simplified, light-weight form of the de vice, in which the resilient head band may be either worn under the chin or around the back of the head;

FIG. 4 is a bottom view of a pod for the left ear, indicating the way the pod may swivel to fit into the ear canal;

FIG. 5 is a perspective view of the pod and its method of attachment to the head band;

FIG. 6 is an end elevation view,'taken in the direction of the arrow 6 of FIG. 5;

DESCRIPTION OF THE PREFERRED EMBODIMENTS As seen in FIG. 1, the preferred form of my invention contemplates the provision of an ear protector that will normally be worn for a considerable period of time, is intended to block out all sounds, and has no provision for the transmission of sound, as might be the case if an ear phone, or head phones were incorporated. Such a device, as indicated in my preferred form, would normally be worn for an extended period of time, such as an hour or more, as a workman around continuously noisy machinery might do. In this form of device, a resiliently yieldable head band 10 extends over the top of the head of the wearer, and at each end holds a resilient ear plug or pod 11. Each pod 11 is individually adjustable vertically on the head band 10 so that the head band may rest upon the top of the head, and the pods may be adjusted to fit properly into each ear of the wearer.

As indicated in FIG. 2, the pod 11 consists of a solid portion or base 12 and a hollow tip portion 13 enclosing a cavity 18 having air or other gas trapped therein. The whole pod is preferably made of a single material, such as a rubber-like composition that is light-weight, flexible, and feels comfortable in the car. As seen in FIG. 2, the hollow tip 13 of the pod 11 extends part way into the ear canal 14, while the rear portion of the tip is pressed to spread around the opening of the canal so that a seal is provided, not only within the canal, but around the opening to the canal. The base 12 of the pod 11 is solid to confine the spreading to the tip 13, and also to provide a firm support for the pod. Preferably, a screw 15 is embedded in the outer end of the base 12, so that the shank of the screw may project through a slot 16 in the head band 10, while a nut 17 holds the pod in adjusted position on the head band. By making the head band 10 relatively narrow, as compared with the base of the pod 11, the pod may pivot backwards and forwards, as indicated in FIG. 4, to adjust to the best position within the ear.

Theconfiguration of the preferred form of pod is shown in some detail in FIGS. 5, 6 and 7. The pod shown in these figures is intended for the left ear, and a similar pod for the right ear will be a mirror image of the one shown. As best seen in FIGS. 5 and 6, the forward surface 20 of the pod 11 is flattened throughout substantially its entire length, both along the base 12 and the tip 13, to provide a flattened surface 20 which bears against the tragus of the ear. The flattened surface 20 conforms closely to the shape of the tragus of the ear, so there is a minimum possibility of air gaps between them through which sound could pass. Since the tragus of the ear is at the forward side, the pod 11 is held with the flattened surface facing to the front.

In crosssection, the pod I1 is generally cylindrical, with the front side 20 joining an upper curved surface 21 that merges into the rear surface 22 of greater radius, and in turn merging into a lower surface 23 of smaller radius that in turn joins the front surface 20. The general appearance is that of an ovoid cylinder whose upper surface is tipped slightly rearwardly.

The inner end of the pod 11 is generally rounded, with the extreme end of the tip having a generally hemispherical surface 24 of relatively small diameter, displaced toward the bottom of the pod and joining with a surface 25 of greater radius of curvature to form a groove 26. The protuberance 24 is thus of a size adapted to project into and close the ear canal 14, while the area 25 is larger and bears against the area surrounding the entrance to the canal.

At the entrance to the ear canal of the human ear, the ear is gradually rounded at the bottom of the ear canal entrance and more sharply cornered at the top part of the ear canal entrance. As illustrated in FIGS. 6 and 7, the pod is formed to conform to the ear canal entrance, and to this end has a groove or concave junction region at 26, where the portion entering the ear canal meets the portion that lies near the top of the entrance to the ear canal, but the pod is convex at its diametrically opposite region which lies near the bottom of the entrance to the ear canal. The bottom side 23 bulges so that it extends below the level of the solid base portion 12, or in other words, beyond the boundaries of the base portion 12. The bulging side 23 conforms closely to the shape of the bottom of the ear, and the fact that it is soft and hollow means that it can readily deform against the ear to provide a very good fit. Also, inward pressing of the pod results in deformation of the hollow tip part, and the outward bulging at 23 encourages further outward bulging against the ear.

7 At this point, it becomes clear that the material forming the tip 13 must be quite soft so that it conforms to the shape of the ear, instead of forcing the ear to conform to the shape of the tip. Certain prior devices have had a stiffness or hardness such that instead of the tip of the ear protector conforming to the ear, the ear was required to conform to the shape of the ear protector, and this caused discomfort and pain, and prevented the ear protector from being worn over any extended period of time.

It is also apparent that in addition to having a soft portion 13, the ear protector must have a sufficient stiffness to insure that the tip seats firmly within the canal 14 and around the area surrounding the canal. By first conforming to the shape of the ear and by then applying a sufficient, but not excessive, pressure to hold the pod firmly against the ear, a comfortable ear protector is provided that effectively reduces the intensity of sound.

It is sometimes desirable to wear the ear protectors for only relatively short periods of time, with the protectors being removed the remainder of the time for ease of communication. Thus, an employee working in the vicinity of the passenger terminal of an airport may wish to be able to converse with other employees, passengers and crew members in a normal manner, but still needs the protection of the ear protectors when jet engines are operated in his immediate vicinity. Under these conditions, the form of protector shown in FIG. 3 is very convenient.

In this form, the pods are identical to those previously described, but the head band 30 is different from the head band 10 previously described.

Instead of resting upon the top of the head as the head band 10 does, the head band 30 is arranged to go under the chin or around the back of the head, as indicated in FIG. 3. As in the case of the head band 10, the head band 30 urges the pods l1 inwardly into the ears to effect the necessary seal, and the pods then support the light-weight head band 30. Since the head band does not rest upon the head, but is spaced from it, there is no need for adjustment of the pods 11 with respect to the head band 30.

To provide this light-weight head band 30, I prefer to use a light-weight tube or rod, such as a light-weight plastic tube having a wire stiffener therein.

With this form of construction, it is a simple matter to remove the pods 11 from the ears and to allow the ear protector to drop around the neck when the sound or noise level drops to a value where the ear protectors are no longer needed. When the need again arises, they may be easily reinserted in the ears, and the protector is thus immediately available at all times without any danger of harming the ears or tiring the head of the wearer.

The form shown in FIG. 3 can also be easily adjusted for wearing with the head band 30 extending around the rear of the head instead of below the chin, since the pod 11 is attached to the head band by means of the shank 15 of the retaining screw, and the pod can be rotated about the shank to the desired position. In each case, of course, whether the head band 30 goes under the chin or behind the head, or even above the head, it is important that the pods 11 be positioned, as previously described, so that the flat surface 20 is located on the forward side to bear against the tragus.

In some instances, it is important that extraneous sound be kept out, but that certain sounds be transmitted to the ear. Thus, in some instances it is important that external sounds, such as the noise of an aircraft engine, be kept from the ears of the pilot so that he can hear and understand the words that are coming to him over the airplane radio or intercommunicating system. The pod 31 has been designed to meet these requirements, while retaining the advantages of the preferred forms. The pod 31 is basically similar to the pod 11, having a solid portion or base 32 with a hollow resilient tip 33, both the base and the tip being formed of a soft resilient material, such as rubber or other rubber-like products, and with a sealed chamber or cavity 40 within the tip having a quantity of air sealed therein to provide the desired resilience.

A light-weight flexible tube 41 is generally axially located in the pod 31, extending along the length of the pod from the outer end of the base 32 to the inner end of the tip 33. The cavity 40 within the tip 33 is thus of a generally annular shape surrounding the tube 41. A transducer 42, such as a crystal or dynamic sound reproducing means, is provided with a hollow boss 43 that projects through the head band 10 and fits into the outer end of the pod 31. A similar combination of pod 31 and transducer 42 may be provided for the other ear, or if desired, the other ear may be provided with the previously described pod 11.

While the head band 30 could be used in connection with the pod 31 and transducer 42, it is generally pref erable to use the head band 10. While the pod 31 will be approximately the same weight as the pod 11, the transducer 42 adds additional weight to the assembly, and greater comfort is generally achieved if the weight of the assembly is supported by the head band 10.

The alternate form of pod just described is adaptable for use with the ear-phone sets furnished passengers in airplanes to permit them to listen to music, sound motion pictures, etc. Such a headphone set, illustrated in FIG. 9, includes a pair of pods 31 supported by a head band 30 and connected by the presently used flexible tubes 45 that extend to the sound transducers usually located in the seats of the aircraft. The pods 31 are generally similar to the pods previously described, including the base 32 and the flexible tip portion 33. The annular cavity 40 surrounds the tubular member 41, and the whole device may be attached to the head band 30 by a small piece of relatively stiff tubing 46 that is inserted into the outer end of the tubular member 41 and extends through the head band 30 to receive the flexible tube 45.

When using the pod 31 in conjunction with either the transducer 42 or the flexible tubes 45 and associated transducers, the result is that the ambient noise surrounding the person is prevented from entering the ear canal 14, while the desired sound from the transducer is directed down the tubular member 41 and into the ear canal. The soft and yieldable tip 33 is comfortable and does not cause pain to the wearer, even after being worn for several hours.

It will be realized that various types of supporting means may be used to hold the pods 11 and 31 in place, and the forms and 30 that have been shown are merely illustrative of various elements that may be used to hold the pods in the proper manner, Additionally, the pod 11 has been shown and described as having a particular form, but this form may be varied, so long as the major considerations of general size, approximate shape, and resilient cushioning are provided.

What is claimed is: 1. An ear protector comprising: a pair of sound-attenuating pods and means for holding said pods against the ears of a wearer; each pod being of generally cylindrical shape and having a base portion attached to said holding means and a tip portion adapted to enter the ear canal, at least one side of said tip portion bulging so that it extends radially beyond the boundaries of the base portion and said tip portion forming a smooth continuous curve along the bulging portion and up to the extreme tip of the pod, said pod being solid up to a region near the beginning of said bulging tip portion and said tip portion being hollow and of soft resilient material so that said bulging portion can readily deform against the region of the ear surrounding the ear canal to thereby form a good sound-tight seal therewith. 2. The ear protector described in claim 1 wherein: each of said pods is of non-circular cross-section at said bulging tip portion, and said pod holding means is constructed to hold the pods in a predetermined orientation in which said bulging side of each pod faces primarily downwardly.

Patent Citations
Cited PatentFiling datePublication dateApplicantTitle
US2246736 *Aug 13, 1938Jun 24, 1941Knudsen Vern OEar stopper
US2441866 *Jun 4, 1943May 18, 1948Jacob J CantorDevice for protecting the ear drum
US2670737 *Sep 11, 1950Mar 2, 1954Cantor Jacob JEar protector
US2785675 *Apr 14, 1951Mar 19, 1957Boris BerkmanEar protecting devices
US2803247 *Dec 2, 1954Aug 20, 1957Josef J ZwislockiEarplug
US2824558 *May 24, 1956Feb 25, 1958Mine Safety Appliances CoEar plug
US3768470 *Jul 21, 1971Oct 30, 1973Leight HEar protector
Referenced by
Citing PatentFiling datePublication dateApplicantTitle
US4461290 *Nov 29, 1982Jul 24, 1984Cabot CorporationHearing protectors
US4852684 *Sep 30, 1988Aug 1, 1989Minnesota Mining And Manufacturing CompanyCompressible ear tip
US4880076 *Dec 5, 1986Nov 14, 1989Minnesota Mining And Manufacturing CompanyHearing aid ear piece having disposable compressible polymeric foam sleeve
US4913259 *May 30, 1989Apr 3, 1990Minnesota Mining And Manufacturing CompanyCompressible ear tip
US5002151 *Oct 4, 1989Mar 26, 1991Minnesota Mining And Manufacturing CompanyEar piece having disposable, compressible polymeric foam sleeve
US5449865 *Jan 28, 1994Sep 12, 1995Minnesota Mining And Manufacturing CompanyEar tips having molded-in recesses for attachment to a stethoscope
US5824968 *Sep 3, 1997Oct 20, 1998Minnesota Mining And Manufacturing CompanyEar tips having a plurality of ear contacting surfaces
US6056082 *May 9, 1997May 2, 20003M Innovative Properties CompanyErgonomic banded ear plug
US8109359 *Oct 8, 2008Feb 7, 2012Moldex-Metric, Inc.Ear protector
US20040096077 *Apr 24, 2003May 20, 2004Csensich Peter J.Hearing coupler shells of soft pliable thermoplastic material
EP0321150A2 *Dec 8, 1988Jun 21, 1989Minnesota Mining And Manufacturing CompanyCollapsible ear tip
EP0587925A1 *Sep 14, 1992Mar 23, 1994LEIGHT & ASSOCIATESSoiling resistant earplug
EP0591197A1 *Aug 16, 1991Apr 13, 1994Cabot Safety CorporationHearing protective earplug having alternative modes of insertion
WO2015094855A1Dec 10, 2014Jun 25, 20153M Innovative Properties CompanyEar canal sealing stethoscope ear tips
U.S. Classification128/865, 128/866
International ClassificationA61F11/08, A61F11/12, A61F11/00
Cooperative ClassificationA61F11/12, A61F11/08
European ClassificationA61F11/12, A61F11/08