US 3903912 A
Abstract available in
Claims available in
Description (OCR text may contain errors)
United States Patent lce, Jr. et al. Sept. 9, 1975  TUBE CLEANING SYSTEM 1439376 4 1909 Nelson ct 15/317 3,448,477 6/1969 Ricordcau ct lS/HM R  Inventors: Charles 0. Ice, Jr., Long Beach;
Earis Ray Shanklin, Torrance both of Calif.
 Assignee: Hydro-Vel Services, Inc., Monahans,
 Filed: Feb. 25, I974 [2l] Appl. No; 445,250
Related U.S. Application Data  Division of Serv Nov 73130, Sept. l7. I970 Pat. No.
 U.S. Cl 134/167 C; 134/172; 15/317  Int. Cl B08b 3/02; BOSb 9/02  Field of Search w l w l34/46, 57 R, 22 C, 24, l34/l66 C I67 C, l68 C, 169 C, I72; l5/lU4ll R lO4ll6, 317; 239/I86  References Cited UNITED STATES PATENTS 690,878 I/IQUZ Roan. l l l I5/I()4.I R
2262.364 II/I94l Hugel ct al. v v v l, I5/|U4.35 N X 197L699 2/I96l Reiss l l .r 239/[86 X 3184774 5/]965 Burch v v r r r r. I5/3I7 :illfilmfi Il/l965 Chappell V r l v v l l I5/3I7 $389,713 b/l968 Pittman .v l34/I67 C Primary E.ram1'ner-Robert L. Bleutge Attorney, Agent, or Firm-Hubbard, Thurman, Turner & Tucker [5 7] ABSTRACT In a tube cleaning system, a pair of long, straight, small diameter, thin wall lances extend in parallel from a common cleaning fluid manifold to a pair of spray discharge heads The lances are automatically moved into, through, and out of a pair of heat exchanger tubes by a lance drive system. The lance drive system comprises structure for moving the lanccs through the tubes for simultaneously applying straightening forces thereto apparatus for controlling both the extent of movement of the lances and the flow of cleaning fluid through the lances. and circuitry for uutomatically reversing and re-reversing the direction of movement of the lances upon engagement of either lance with an obstruction in its respective tube The lance drive system is mounted on a frame which in cludes structure for aligning the lances with a pair of heat exchanger tubes prior to each operating cycle of the tube cleaning system 4 Claims. 7 Drawing Figures PATENTED 9i975 3 903.912
swan 1 pg 9 iii 4 SHEET 2 0F 4 ll lllll O: T l1...
TUBE CLEANING SYSTEM This is a division of application Ser. No. 073,130 filed Sep. 17, I970, now U.S. Pat. No. 3,794,051
BACKGROUND AND SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION Heat exchangers are used throughout industry to transfer heat from one fluid to another. One type of heat exchanger includes a cylindrical outer shell and a tube bundle positioned within the shell. In the use of this type of heat exchanger, one fluid is passed through the tubes from one end of the shell to another. Another fluid is passed through the central portion of the shell around the tubes to achieve heat transfer between the fluids.
The fluids flowing through the tubes of a heat exchanger are often corrosive in nature, and often contain dissolved solids, dirt, grease, etc. Any of these conditions can cause tubes ofa heat exchanger to become clogged with solid materials. Any significant accumulation of solid materials in the tubes of a heat exchanger reduces the operating efficiency of the heat exchanger, and therefore necessitates the cleaning of the interiors of the tubes.
Heretofore, the cleaning of the interiors of heat exchanger tubes has been manual in nature. For example, in accordance with a tube cleaning process that is currently in use, a small diameter, this walled length of pipe known as a lance is manipulated manually through the interior of heat exchanger tube. As the lance is moved through the tube, water is forced through the lance and out of the distal end thereof to clean the interior of the tube. If an obstruction is encountered, the lance is manuevered back and forth in the tube until the obstruction has been cleared from the tube. After the tube is clean, the lance is removed from the tube and is manually aligned with an adjacent tube for manipulation therethrough.
Manual heat exchanger tube cleaning systems are unsatisfactory for a number of reasons, For example, manual systems are generally slow in operation. Manual systems are also inefficient because the manual positioning of a tube cleaning lance in alignment with a heat exchanger tube typically requires the use of at least three workmen. Finally, due to their small diameter, thin wall nature, tube cleaning lances are easily bent, especially upon contact with an obstruction in a tube. When this occurs, it is often necessary to straighten the lance before proceeding with a cleaning operation.
The present invention relates to an automatic system for cleaning the interiors of heat exchanger tubes. In accordance with the preferred embodiment of the invention, a pair of lances are aligned with a pair of heat exchanger tubes, and are then advanced into the tubes. As the lances enter the tubes, a cleaning fluid is forced through the lances from a common cleaning fluid manifold. The lances are advanced the entire length of the tubes and are thereafter automatically retracted out of the tubes unless an obstruction is encountered in one of the tubes, in which event the direction of movement of the lances is automatically reversed and re-reversed until the obstruction is cleared. Preferably, the lances are driven by a mechanism that applies straightening forces to the lances during their movement into and out of the tubes.
DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS A more complete understanding of the invention may be had by referring to the following Detailed Description when taken in conjunction with the accompanying drawings, wherein:
FIG. I is a perspective view ofa tube cleaning system employing the invention;
FIG. 2 is an exploded view of the lance drive mechanism of the tube cleaning system shown in FIG. 1;
FIG. 3 is an end view of the lance drive mechanism;
FIG. 4a is a schematic illustration of a portion of an electrical circuit employed in the tube cleaning system shown in FIG. 1;
FIG. 4b is a schematic illustration of the remainder of the electrical circuit;
FIG. 4c is a schematic illustration of a relay that is employed in the electrical circuit, and
FIG. 5 is a schematic illustration of a hydraulic circuit employed in the tube cleaning system.
DETAILED DESCRIPTION Referring now to the drawings, and particularly to FIG. 1 thereof, a tube cleaning system 10 employing the present invention is shown positioned adjacent a heat exchanger HE. The heat exchanger HE is conven tional in design in that it is comprised of an outer cylindrical shell C and a plurality of tubes T which extend axially through the shell C. The function of the tube cleaning system 10 is to clean the interiors of the tubes T, that is to remove accumulations of solid materials that may be present within the interiors of the tubes.
The tube cleaning system 10 includes a pair of lances l2 which extend in parallel from a common cleaning fluid manifold I4 to a pair of conventional discharge nozzels (not shown). Typically, the lances 12 are about twenty feet in length and are about three-eighths inches in diameter. In order to provide maximum cleaning fluid flow into the interiors of the heat exchanger tubes, the lances I2 are preferably fabricated from thin wall pipe. This long, small diameter, thin wall lance construction has been found to be highly advantageous for heat exchanger cleaning purposes, however, it also renders the lances I2 extremely liable to bending and other damage. Thus, it is necessary to protect the lances I2 against bending, etc, during the operation of the tube cleaning system 10.
To this end, the tube cleaning system 10 includes a lance drive assembly I6 which functions to move the lances 12 into and out of the heat exchanger tubes, and also to protect the lances I2 against damage. The lance drive system 16 includes an I-beam 18 which is preferably somewhat longer than the lances 12. The lances I2 are supported for movement along the I-beam 18 by a rear lance support mechanism 20, a pair of intermediate lance support mechanisms 22 and 24, and a lance drive mechanism 26.
The rear lance support mechanism 20 includes a plurality of rollers which engage the upper and lower sides of the upper flange of the I-beam l8, and serves to support the common cleaning fluid manifold 14 and the ends of the lances 12 extending therefrom. The intermediate lance support mechanisms 22 and 24 also comprise rollers which engage the upper flange of the I-beam I8, and serve to support the intermediate portions of the lances I2. During movement of the lances 12 in the direction of the lance drive mechanism 26,
the rear lance support mechansim moves with the lances 12 until a plate 28 on the mechanism 20 engages a magnet on the mechanism 22. whereupon both the mechanism 20 and the mechanism 22 move with the lances 12. This movement continues until a magnet 32 on the forward end of the mechanism 22 engages a plate 34 on the mechanism 24, whereupon all three support mechanisms move forwardly with the lances 12.
During movement of the lances 12 toward the end of the l-beam 18 remote from the lance drive mechansim 26, the rear lance support mechanism 20 is moved rearwardly with the lances l2. and the magnets 30 and 32 on the intermediate lance supporting mechanism 22 connect the intermediate lance supporting mechanisms 22 and 24 to the rear lance supporting mechansim 20 for movement therewith. This movement continues until the mechanism 24 engages a first fixed stop (not shown). Engagement of the mechanism 24 with the first stop breaks the magnetic connection between the magnet 32 and the plate 34, whereupon the mechanism 24 remains stationary and the mechanism 22 continues to move with the mechanism 20. Subsequentially. the mechansim 22 engages a second fixed stop (also not shown). Engagement of the mechanism 22 with the second stop breaks the magnetic connection between the magnet 30 and the plate 28 whereupon only the mechanism 20 moves with the lances 12. It will be understood that the fixed stops are so located on the lbeam 18 that the portions of the lances [2 located between the lance drive mechanism 26 and the rear lance support mechanism 24 are adequately supported at all times.
The structural details of the lance drive mechanism 26 of the lance drive assembly 16 are illustrated in H05. 2 and 3. Referring first to FIG. 2. the mechanism 26 comprises four rollers 36 each comprising a pair of lance receiving grooves 38 and a gear 40. As is best shown in FIG. 3. the rollers 36 are so arranged that the grooves 38 combine to form a pair of circular lance receiving channels 42. The gears 40 of the rollers 36 are mounted in meshing interengagement and one of the rolles is driven by a hydraulic motor 44 through a speed reducer 46. By this means. the rollers 36 drive the lances 12 into and out of the tubes of a heat exchanger.
As is best shown in FIG. 2. the rollers 36 are positioned at spaced points axially of the lances l2. and alternate rollers 36 are positioned on opposite sides of the lances 12. The upper two rollers 36 are mounted on a pair of slides 48, and a pair of adjusting mechanisms (only one of which is shown) are provided for controlling the pressure that is applied to the lances 12 by the rollers 36. Due to the foregoing construction. the drive mechanism 26 applies straightening forces to the lances 12 during the movement thereof. By this means. any tendency of the lances to bend under the action of gravity or otherwise during the use of the tube cleaning system H) is continuously corrected by the drive mechanism 26, and the lances 12 are therefore maintained prefectly straight.
Referring again to FIG. 1. the lance drive assembly [6 is supported in a frame 52. The frame 52 includes a rectangular main frame 54 comprising four interconnected box beams 56 that are supported on four hydraulic cylinders 58. The main frame 54 supports an operators station 60 which is mounted on a pair of beams 62 for horizontal movement relative to the frame 54.
The main frame 54 also supports a pair of horizontal locating assemblies 64. Each horizontal locating assembly 6 includes a pair of lead screws 66 and a platform 68 mounted on the lead screw 66 for horizontal movement relative to the frame 54. The lead screws 66 are selectively rotated by an electric motor 70 and are interconnected by a plurality of chains 72. Thus. upon operation of the motor 70, the platforms 68 of the horizontal locating assemblies 64 are moved in sychronism to position the lances l2 horizontally relative to the frame 54.
The platforms 68 of the horizontal locating assembly 64 support a pair of vertical locating assemblies 74. The vertical locating assemblies 74 each include a beam 76 which extends upwardly from one of the platforms 68 and which supports a lead screw 78. The lead screws 78 are selectively rotated by an electric motor 80 and are interconnected by a chain 82. The Lbeam 18 of the lance drive assembly 16 is supported on the lead screws 78 for vertical movement upon rotation thereof. Thus. upon actuation of the motor 80, the lances 12 are positioned vertically relative to the tubes of a heat exchanger.
In the use of the tube cleaning system 10. the axes of the lances 12 are brought into alignment with the axes of the tubes of a heat exchanger. preferably by operating the hydraulic cylinders 58 to level the main frame 54. Thereafter. the horizontal locating assemblies 64 and the vertical locating assemblies 74 of the frame 52 are actuated to bring the lances 12 into alignment with a particular pair of tubes T in the heat exchanger. The tube cleaning system I0 is equipped with a plurality of limit switches 84 which prevent actuation of the horizontal positioning mechanism 64 and the vertical positioning mechanisms 74 beyond the limits imposed by the size of the frame 52.
When the lances 12 are properly positioned, the lance drive assembly 16 is actuated to move the lances 12 into. through. and out of the selected pair of tubes in the heat exchanger. The lance drive assembly 16 is provided with three limit switches 86. 88 and 90 which control the flow of cleaning fluid through the lances 12, the extent of inward movement of the lances 12, and the extent of outward movement of the lances 12. respectively. The limit switches 86. 88 and 90 are preferably mounted for selective positioning on the l-beam 18 of the lance drive system 16 in accordance with the physical size of a particular heat exchanger and in accordance with the location of the heat exchanger relative to the tube cleaning system 10.
The operation of the lance drive assembly l6 in moving the lances l2 into and out of a pair of heat exchanger tubes is controlled by clectric and hydraulic circuits of the type illustrated in FIGS. 4 and 5. respectively. Referring first to PK]. 5, a hydraulic circuit 98 for operating the motor 44 of the lance drive mecha nism 26 in forward and reverse directions and at high and low speeds is schematically shown. The circuit 98 includes a pump 100 which draws hydraulic fluid from a sump I02 through a filter 104. A relief valve 106 eontrolst'he pressure of the circuit 98, and a needle valve 108 provides adjustment of the high speed operation of the motor 44. A pair of normally open. solenoid operated valves 110 and 112 are selectively closed for low speed operation and high pressure operation. respectively. A needle valve 114 provides adjustment of the low speed operation of the motor 44.
The hydraulic circuit 98 further includes a three position, four way, solenoid operated valve 116 which is actuated by the electrical circuit of the tube cleaning systern to control the direction of flow of hydraulic fluid from the pump 100 to the motor 44. A pressure responsive switch H8 is located in the return line from the motor 44 and is responsive to a predetermined decrease in the return line pressure to generate an electrical signal. Since the return line pressure from the motor 44 tends to decrease as the motor stalls, a signal from the switch 118 indicates interference with the move ment of at least one of the lances 12.
Referring now to FIGS. 41!, 4b and 4c, an electrical circuit 120 that is employed to control various functions of the lance drive assembly 16 is schematically i]- lustrated. The circuit 120 comprises a plurality of identical relays. one of which is shown in FIG. 40. That is, each relay in the circuit I20 comprises two normally closed contact pairs which are opened upon energization of the relay, two normally open contact pairs which are closed upon energization of the relay, and a relay coil, and the various components of each relay are connected to terminal pins in the manner illustrated in FIG. 4c.
Referring now to H08. and 4b, conventional l 15 Volt, Hertz line current is directed to the circuit 120 through a power cord 122. A pair of three position switches 124 and 126 provide main power control and pump power control, respectively. A pushbutton 128 is selectively actuated to begin automatic operation of the tube cleaning system 10.
A pair of switches 130 and 132 are mounted for manual operation from the operator's station 60 of the tube cleaning system 10. The switch 130 cooperates with the limit switches 84, the limit switch 90, and a plurality of relays 134 to control the operation of the motors and 80. That is, upon operation of the switch 130, the horizontal and vertical locating assemblies are selectively actuated to adjust the horizontal and vertical positioning of the lances 12. The switch 130 and the limit switch are preferably interconnected in such a way that the horizontal and vertical positioning assemblies 64 and 74 cannot be actuated except when the lances 12 are fully retracted.
The switch 132 cooperates with the limit switches 88 and 90 and with a plurality of relays 136 to control the direction and speed of operation of the motor 44 of the lance drive mechanism 26. Also, the switch 132 operates through the solenoid operated valve 130 of the hydraulic circuit 98 to selectively apply high pressure to the motor 44. The latter function is preferably interconnected with the direction control function of the switch 132 in such a way that high pressure can only be applied to retract the lances 12. It should be noted that the application of high pressure to the motor 44 is not required in the normal operation of the tube cleaning system ll), and is only required in the event the lances l2 become stuck in the tubes of a heat exchanger.
The electrical circuit further includes a subcircuit 140 including the pressure sensitive switch 118 of the hydraulic circuit 98, a relay I42 that is energized in response to closure of the switch 118, a plurality of time delay switches 144 that are sequentially operated in response to encrgization of the relay 142, and a relay 146 that is actuated in response to operation of one of the switches 144. Upon engagement of either of the lances 12 with an obstruction or other interference in one of the tubes ofa heat exchanger, the subcircuit 140 immediately reverses the direction of movement of the lances 12. When the lances have moved a short distance in the reverse direction. lance movement is stopped for a brief period of time so that cleaning fluid flowing through the lances can remove the obstruction, etc. Then, the direction of movement of the lances is re-reversed, that is, movement of the lances 12 through the tubes is re-initiated. If the tubes have been cleared of all obstructions, the lances continue to move through the tubes without further operation of the subcircuit 140. If however, the same or another obstruc tion is encountered, the subcircuit 140 again operates to reverse and the re-reverse the direction of movement of the lances until all obstructions are cleared from the tubes.
Operation Initially, the tube cleaning system 10 is positioned adjaccnt a heat exchanger to be cleaned. It has been found that if the major structural components of a tube cleaning system employing the invention are fabricated from aluminum, the system is easily manipulated by four workmen. The tube cleaning system is then connected to the heat exchanger. preferably by rods connected between the heat exchanger and the frame 52 of the tube cleaning systemv As previously indicated, the lances are then aligned with the axes of the tubes of the heat exchanger by operating the hydraulic cylinders 58 of the frame 52. Next, the horizontal and vertical locating assemblies 64 and 74 are operated under the control of the switch to position the lances 12 in alignment with a particular pair of tubes in the heat exchanger. A final check on the alignment of the lances 12 is achieved by operating the switch 132 to advance the lances 12 very slowly toward the selected pair of tubes.
When the lances 12 are properly aligned, the pushbutton 128 is actuated to begin operation of the tube cleaning system 10. Thereafter, the lance drive assembly [16 operates under control of the limit switches 88 and 90 to advance the lances 12 into and through the selected pair of tubes, and to thereafter retract the lances 12 out of the tubes. During this action, the limit switch 86 initiates the flow of cleaning fluid through the lances 12 upon entry of the lances [2 into the tubes, and terminates the flow of cleaning fluid through the lances 12 upon withdrawal of the lances from the tubes. As is shown in FIG. 4a, the latter function is accomplished by means of a solenoid controlled device 148 that controls the flow of cleaning fluid through the common cleaning fluid manifold 14 and into the lances 12.
If either lances l2 encounters any obstruction or other interference in a tube of the heat exhanger. the switch H8 closes, whereupon the subcircuit I40 immediately terminates lance movement. This is very important in that it prevents bending of the lances due to application of excessive compressive forces. Thereafter. the subscircuit actuates the lance drive mechanism 26 to withdraw the lances 12 a short distance in order to permit the cleaning fluid flowing through the lances to dislodge the interfering matter from the interior of the tube. Finally, lance movement in the original direction is re-initated by the subcircuit I40, and is continued subject to termination by the subcircuit [40 in the event either lance encounters interference.
It will be understood that due to the extremely long, small diameter, thin wall construction of the lances 12. the lances are subjected to bending forces throughout the operation of the tube cleaning system 10. To this end, the portions of the lances [2 extending between the rear lance support mechanism 20 and the lance drive mcchansim 26 are supported by the intermediate lance support mechanism 22 and 24. Also, the lance drive mechanism 26 applies straightening forces to the lances l2 throughout the movement of the lances 12 into and out of the tubes of a heat exchanger. The latter function is very important in that it assures the straightness of the lances 12 throughout the operation of the tube cleaning system 10.
Upon completion of the movement of the lances 12 into and out of the selected pair of tubes, the horizontal and vertical locating assemblies 64 and 74 are actuated to position the lances 12 in alignment with a second pair of tubes in the heat exchanger. Then, another automatic cycle of the tube cleaning system 10 is initiated by depressing the pushbutton 128. When all of the tubes of the heat exchanger have been cleaned, the tube cleaning system 10 is moved into alignment with another heat exchanger, and the foregoing process is repeated.
It will be understood that various substitutions and modifications can be made in the structure of the tube cleaning system shown in the drawings. For example, an internal combustion engine can be employed as the basic prime mover in the system. Similarly, the hydraulic motor 44 of the lance drive system 26 can be replaced with an electric motor, and the elecrtic motors 70 and 80 of the horizontal and vertical locating assemblies 64 and 74 can be replaced with hydraulic motors. Other substitutions that will be readily apparent to those skilled in the art include the use of equivalent fluidic, pneumatic or electronic control circuits in place of the electrical and hydraulic control circuits that have been disclosed,
Perhaps more importantly, there are several mechanisms that can be employed in lieu of the pressure sen sitive switch H8 detect interference with the movement of the lances 12 through the tubes of a heat exchanger. One such alternative mechanism comprises a tachometer or other speed responsive apparatus positioned to sense either the rotational speed of the rollers 136 or the speed of advance of the lances [2. Another alternative mechanism comprises strain gauges positioned to detect the magnitude of the compressive forces that are applied to the lances l2 by the lance drive mechanism 26. Still another alternative mecha nism comprises a torque meter responsive to the torque that is imposed on the rollers 36 by the motor 44. Other mechanisms for detecting resistance to the movement of the lances through the tubes of a heat exchanger will occur to those skilled in the art, any of the alternative mechanisms may be employed in the tube cleaning system 10 instead of or in addition to the pressure sensitive switch 118, if desired.
From the foregoing, it will be understood that the present invention relates to a tube cleaning system in which a pair of lances are automatically moved into, through, and out of a heat exchanger tubes. Preferably, straightening forces are applied to the lances as they are moved, and the movement of the lances is automatically reversed and then re-reversed whenever either lances encounters interference. The use of the invention is advantageous over the use of manual tube cleaning systems in that it cleans the tubes of a heat exchanger considerably more rapidly than is possible with manual systems, and in that after a tube cleaning system employing the invention has been positioned adjacent a heat exchanger, the system can be operated by a single workman. Also, the features of the present invention relating to the application of straightening forces to the lances and to the termination of lance movement whenever either lance encounters interference combine to completely eliminate the problem of lance bending.
Although the preferred embodiment of the invention has been illustrated in the drawings and described in the foregoing specification, it will be understood that the invention is not limited to the embodiment disclosed, but is capable of rearrangement, modification and substitution of parts and elements without departing from the spirit of the invention.
What is claimed is: I
l. The tube cleaning system comprising: an elongate, straight, tube cleaning lance, and means for reciprocating the lance into and out of tubes to be cleaned and for simultaneously maintaining the straightness of the lance wherein the lance reciprocating and straightness maintaining means including a pair of rollers which engage the lance at spaced points on one side thereof, and a third roller that engages the lance on the opposite side thereof at a point positioned between the first two points axially of the lance.
2. The tube cleaning system according to claim l further characterized by a fourth roller positioned on the same side of the lance as the third roller and at a point spaced axially from both of the first two rollers.
3. The tube cleaning system according to claim 1 wherein the lance reciprocating and straightness maintaining means is further characterized by means for rotating all of the rollers and thereby reciprocating the lance.
4. The tube cleaning system according to claim 3 wherein each of the rollers includes a gear portion, wherein the gear portions of the respective rollers are mounted in meshing interengagement, and further including means for rotating one of the rollers and thereby rotating all of the rollers through the gear por tions.
UNITED STATES PATENT OFFICE CERTIFICATE OF CORRECTION PATENT NO. 2 3,903,912
DATED September 9, 1975 INVENTOR( I Charles 0. Ice, Jr. and Earis Ray Shanklin It is certified that error appears in the above-identified patent and that said Letters Patent are hereby corrected as shown below:
Column 1, line 30, between "of" and "heat" insert --a--.
Column 1, line 52, "automatic" should be --automated--.
Column 3, line 8, before "support" insert --lance--.
Column 7, line 43, after "118" insert --to--.
Column 7, line 57, after "art," insert --and--.
Column 8, line 7, after "of" delete --a--.
Signed and Scaled this second D3) Of March 1976 [SEAL] Arrest:
RUTH c. MASON c. MARSHALL DANN Arresting Officer t Commissioner uflalents and Trademarks