Search Images Maps Play YouTube News Gmail Drive More »
Sign in
Screen reader users: click this link for accessible mode. Accessible mode has the same essential features but works better with your reader.

Patents

  1. Advanced Patent Search
Publication numberUS4403012 A
Publication typeGrant
Application numberUS 06/359,975
Publication dateSep 6, 1983
Filing dateMar 19, 1982
Priority dateMar 19, 1982
Fee statusPaid
Publication number06359975, 359975, US 4403012 A, US 4403012A, US-A-4403012, US4403012 A, US4403012A
InventorsGary A. Harpell, Sheldon Kavesh, Igor Palley, Dusan C. Prevorsek
Original AssigneeAllied Corporation
Export CitationBiBTeX, EndNote, RefMan
External Links: USPTO, USPTO Assignment, Espacenet
Ballistic-resistant article
US 4403012 A
Abstract
Articles such as vests, helmets and structural elements containing a network of ultrahigh molecular weight, high strength, high modulus polyethylene or polypropylene fibers. The fibers, and especially polyethylene fibers of 15, 20, 25, 30 or more g/denier tenacity, and 300, 500, 1000, 1500 or more g/denier tensile modulus impart exceptional ballistic resistance to the articles in spite of the melting points, e.g. 145°-151° C. for the polyethylene fibers and 168°-171° C. for the polypropylene fibers, which are high for these polymers, but substantially lower than the 200° C. or more melting point previously thought necessary for good ballistic resistance.
Images(6)
Previous page
Next page
Claims(11)
We claim:
1. A ballistic-resistant article of manufacture comprising a network of polyolefin fibers having, in the case of polyethylene fibers, a weight average molecular weight of at least about 500,000, a tensile modulus of at least about 300 g/denier and a tenacity of at least about 15 g/denier, and in the case of polypropylene fibers, a weight average molecular weight of at least about 750,000, a tensile modulus of at least about 160 g/denier and a tenacity of at least about 8 g/denier, said fibers being formed into a network of sufficient thickness to absorb the energy of a projectile.
2. The ballistic-resistant article of claim 1 being in the form of a composite comprising said polyolefin fiber network and a matrix.
3. The ballistic-resistant article of claim 2 wherein said polyolefin fiber network comprises polyolefin fibers coated with an ethylene or propylene copolymer and said matrix comprises a thermoset resin, said copolymer having strong adhesion to said polyolefin fibers and to said thermoset resin matrix.
4. The ballistic-resistant article of claim 2 wherein said matrix comprises a thermoplastic having ethylene or propylene crystallinity.
5. The ballistic-resistant article of claim 4 wherein said polyolefin fiber is polyethylene and said thermoplastic matrix is polyethylene.
6. The ballistic-resistant article of claim 5 wherein said polyethylene fiber has a melting point of at least about 140° C. and said polyethylene polymer matrix has a melting point at least about 3° C. lower than the melting point of said polyethylene fiber.
7. The ballistic-resistant article of claim 5 wherein said polyethylene polymer matrix is polyethylene of a density between about 0.90 and about 0.94 g/cm3.
8. The ballistic-resistant article or claim 5 wherein said polyethylene polymer matrix is polyethylene of a density between about 0.94 and about 0.98 g/cm3.
9. The ballistic-resistant article of claim 2, 3, 4 or 5 wherein said fiber network comprises a first plurality of layers, with each layer comprising a second plurality of fibers.
10. The ballistic-resistant article of claim 9 wherein said second plurality of fibers are substantially aligned in each layer.
11. The ballistic resistant article of claim 1 consisting essentially of a flexible network of said polyolefin fibers.
Description

This application is related to four copending, commonly assigned applications filed herewith, each of which is incorporated herein by reference to the extent not inconsistent herewith:

Kavesh et al., "Producing High Tenacity, High Modulus Crystalline Thermoplastic Article Such As Fiber or Film," Ser. No. 359,020, fled Mar. 19, 1982, a continuation-in-part of Ser. No. 259,266, filed Apr. 30, 1981.

Kavesh et al., "High Tenacity, High Modulus Polyethylene and Polypropylene Fibers, And Gel Fiber Useful In The Production Thereof," Ser. No. 359,019, filed Mar. 19, 1982, a continuation-in-part of Ser. No. 259,266, filed Apr. 30, 1981;

Harpell et al., "Improved Ballistic-Resistant Article," Ser. No. 359,975, filed Mar. 19, 1982, now U.S. Pat. No. 4,403,012.

Harpell et al., "Coated Extended Chain Polyolefin Fiber," Ser. No. 359,976, filed Mar. 19, 1982.

BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION

Ballistic articles such as bulletproof vests, helmets, structural members of helicopters and other military equipment, vehicle panels, briefcases, raincoats and umbrellas containing high strength fibers are known. Fibers conventionally used include aramids such as poly(phenylenediamine terephthalamide), graphite fibers and the like. For many applications, such as vests or parts or vests, the fibers are used in a woven or knitted fabric. For many of the other applications, the fiber is encapsulated or embedded in a composite material.

A number of properties are generally considered to be necessary for the high strength fiber to be useful as a ballistic resistant material. Four of these factors listed by John V. E. Hansen and Roy C. Laible, in "Fiber Frontiers" ACS Conference, (June 10-12, 1974), entitled "Flexible Body Armor Materials" are higher modulus, higher melting point, higher strength and/or work-to-rupture values and higher resistance to cutting or shearing. With regard to melting point, it is indicated as desirable to retard, delay or inhibit the melting seen with nylon and polyester. In a book entitled "Ballistic Materials and Penetration Mechanics", by Roy C. Laible (1980), it is indicated that no successful treatment has been developed to bring the ballistic resistance of polypropylene up to the levels predicted from the yearn stress-strain properties (page 81) and that melting in the case of nylon and polyester fiber may limit their ballistic effectiveness. Laible indicated that NOMEX, a heat resistant polyamide fiber with modest strength, possesses fairly good ballistic resistant properties (page 88).

Furthermore, in "The Application of High Modulus Fibers to Ballistic Protection" R. C. Laible et al., J. Macromol. Sci.-Chem. A7(1), pp. 295-322 1973, it is indicated on p. 298 that a fourth requirement is that the textile material have a high degree of heat resistance; for example, a polyamide material with a melting point of 255° C. appears to possess better impact properties ballistically than does a polyolefin fiber with equivalent tensile properties but a lower melting point. In an NTIS publication, AD-A018 958 "New Materials in Construction for Improved Helmets", A. L. Alesi et al., a multilayer highly oriented polypropylene film material (without matrix) referred to as "XP" was evaluated against an aramid fiber (with a phenolic/polyvinyl butyral resin matrix). The aramid system was judged to have the most promising combination of superior performance and a minimum of problems for combat helmet development.

BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE INVENTION

It has been surprisingly found that extremely high tenacity polyethylene and polypropylene materials of ultra high molecular weight perform surprisingly well as ballistic-resistant materials, in spite of their relatively low melting points. Accordingly, the present invention includes a ballistic-resistant article of manufacture comprising a network of polyolefin fibers having, in the case of polyethylene fibers, a weight average molecular weight of at least about 500,000, a tensile modulus of at least about 300 grams/denier and a tenacity of at least about 15 grams/denier, and in the case of polypropylene fibers, a weight average molecular weight of at least about 750,000, a tensile modulus of at least about 160 grams/denier and a tenacity of at least about 8 grams/denier, said fibers being formed into a network of sufficient thickness to absorb the energy of a projectile. The invention includes such articles in which the network is either a woven or knitted fabric or is a composite or a laminated structure.

DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE INVENTION

Ballistic articles of the present invention include a fiber network, which may be an ultra high molecular weight polyethylene fiber network or an ultra high molecular weight polypropylene network.

In the case of polyethylene, suitable fibers are those of molecular weight of at least about 500,00, preferably at least about one million and more preferably between about two million and about five million. The fibers may be grown in solution spinning processes such as described in U.S. Pat. No. 4,137,394 to Meihuzen et al., or U.S. application Ser. No. 225,288 of Kavesh et al., filed Jan. 15, 1981, copending and commonly assigned, or a fiber spun from a solution to form a gel structure, as described in German Off. No. 3,004,699 and GB No. 2051667, and especially as described in application Ser. No. 259,266 of Kavesh et al. filed Apr. 30, 1981 and a continuation-in-part of Ser. No. 259,266, Ser. No. 359,020, filed herewith, both copending and commonly assigned. Examples of the gel spun fiber, and its use in preparing ballistic articles, are given in the Examples below. Depending upon the formation technique, the draw ratio and temperatures, and other conditions, a variety of properties can be imparted to these fibers. The tenacity of the fibers should be at least about 15 grams/denier, preferably at least about 20 grams/denier, more preferably at least 25 grams/denier and most preferably at least about 30 grams/denier. Similarly, the tensile modulus of the fibers is at least about 300 grams/denier, preferably at least about 500 grams/denier and more preferably at least about 1,000 grams/denier and most preferably at least about 1,500 grams/denier. These highest values for tensile modulus and tenacity are generally obtainable only by employing solution grown or gel fiber processes. Many of the fibers have melting points higher than the melting point of the polymer from which they were formed. Thus for example, ultra high molecular weight polyethylenes of 500,000, one million and two million generally have melting points in the bulk of about 138° C. As described further in Ser. No. 359,020, the highly oriented polyethylene fibers made of these materials have melting points 7°-13° C. higher, as indicated by the melting point of the fiber used in Examples 5A and 5B. Thus, a slight increase in melting point correlates with the orientation imparted to the present fibers. Nevertheless, the melting points of these fibers remain substantially below nylon; and the efficacy of these fibers for ballistic resistant articles is contrary to the various teachings cited above which indicate temperature resistance as a critical factor in selecting ballistic materials.

Similarly, highly oriented polypropylene fibers of molecular weight at least about 750,000, preferably at least about one million and more preferably at least about two million may be used. Such ultra high molecular weight polypropylene may be formed into reasonably well oriented fibers by the techniques prescribed in the various references referred to above, and especially by the technique of U.S. Ser. No. 259,266, filed Apr. 30, 1981, and the continuation-in-part thereof Ser. No. 359,020 filed herewith, both of Kavesh et al. and commonly assigned. Since polypropylene is a much less crystalline material than polyethylene, tenacity values suitable with polypropylene are generally substantially lower than the corresponding values for polyethylene. Accordingly, a suitable tensile strength is at least about 8 grams/denier, with a preferred tenacity being at least about 11 grams/denier. The tensile modulus for polypropylene is at least about 160 grams/denier, preferably at least about 200 grams/denier. The melting point of the polypropylene is generally raised several degrees by the orientation process, such that the polypropylene fiber preferably has a main melting point of at least about 168° C., more preferably at least about 170° C.

In ballistic articles containing fibers alone, the fibers may be formed as a felt, knitted, basket woven, or formed into a fabric in any of a variety of conventional techniques. However, within these techniques, it is preferred to use those variations commonly employed in the preparation of aramid fabrics for ballistic-resistant articles. Such techniques include those described in U.S. Pat. No. 4,181,768 and in M. R. Silyquist et al., J. Macromol. Sci.-Chem., A7(1) 203 et seq (1973).

In addition to the use of fabrics of fiber alone, it is contemplated to use fabrics of coated fibers. The present fibers may be coated with a variety of polymeric and non-polymeric materials, but are preferably coated, if at all, with a polyethylene, polypropylene, or a copolymer containing ethylene and/or propylene having at least about 10 volume percent ethylene crystallinity or at least about 10 volume percent propylene crystallinity. The determination of whether or not copolymers have this crystallinity can be readily determined by one skilled in the art either by routine experimentation or from the literature such as Encyclopedia of Polymer Science, vol. 6, page 355 (1967). Coated fibers may be arranged in the same fashion as uncoated fibers into woven, non-woven or knitted fabrics. In addition, coated fabrics may be arranged in parallel arrays and/or incorporated into laminants or composites. Furthermore, the fibers used either alone or with coatings may be monofilaments or multifilaments wound or connected in a conventional fashion.

The proportion of coating in the coated fibers may vary from relatively small amounts (e.g. 1% by weight of fibers) or relatively large amounts (e.g. 150% by weight of fibers), depending upon whether the coating material has any ballistic-resistant properties of its own (which is generally not the case) and upon the rigidity, shape, heat resistance, wear resistance and other properties desired for the ballistic-resistant article. In general, ballistic-resistant articles of the present invention containing coated fibers generally have a relatively minor (e.g. 1-25%, by weight of fibers), since the ballistic-resistant properties are almost entirely attributable to the fiber. Nevertheless, coated fibers with higher coating contents may be employed. More details concerning coated fibers are contained in a copending application of Harpell et al. Ser. No. 359,976, filed herewith and commonly assigned, the disclosure of which is hereby incorporated by reference to the extent not inconsistent herewith.

In addition to fibers and coated fibers, simple composite materials may be used in preparing the ballistic-resistant articles of the present invention. By simple composite is intended to mean combinations of the ultra high molecular weight fiber with a single major matrix material, whether or not there are other materials such as fillers, lubricants or the like. Suitable matrix materials include polyethylene, polypropylene, ethylene copolymers, propylene copolymers and other olefin polymers are copolymers, particularly those having ethylene or propylene crystallinity. Suitable matrix materials also include, however, other materials which, in general, have a poor direct adherence to the polyethylene or polypropylene fibers. Examples of such other matrix materials include unsaturated polyesters, epoxy resins and polyurethane resins and other resins curable below the melting point of the fiber. As in the case of coated fibers, the proportions of matrix to fiber is not critical for the simple composites, with matrix amounts of about 5 to about 150%, by weight of fibers, representing a broad general range. Also within this range, it is preferred to use composites having a relatively high fiber content, such as fibers having only about 10-50% matrix, by weight of fibers. One suitable technique of forming such high fiber composites is to coat the fibers with a matrix material and then to press together a plurality of such coated fibers until the coating materials fuse into a matrix, which may be continuous or discontinuous.

The simple composite materials may be arranged in a variety of forms. It is convenient to characterize the geometries of such composites by the geometries of the fibers and then to indicate that the matrix material may occupy part or all of the void space left by the network of fibers. One such suitable arrangement is layers or laminates of fibers arranged in parallel fashion within each layer, with successive layers rotated with respect to the previous layer. An example of such laminate structures are composites with the second, third, fourth and fifth layers rotated plus 45°, -45°, 90° and 0°, with respect to the first layer, but not necessarily in that order. Other examples include composites with alternating layers rotated 90° with respect to each other. Furthermore, simple composites with short fiber lengths essentially randomly arranged within the matrix may be used.

Also suitable are complex composites containing coated fibers in a matrix, with preferred complex composites having the above-described coated fibers in a thermoplastic, elastomers or thermoset matrix; with thermoset matrixes such as epoxies, unsaturated polyesters and urethanes being preferred.

EXAMPLES Preparation of Gel Fiber

A high molecular weight linear polyethylene (intrinsic viscosity of 18 in decalin at 135° C.) was dissolved in paraffin oil at 220° C. to produce a 6 wt. % solution. This solution was extruded through a sixteen-hole die (hole diameter 1 mm) at the rate of 3.2 m/minute. The oil was extracted from the fiber with trichlorotrifluoroethane (trademark Genetron® 113) and then the fiber was subsequently dried. One or more of the multifilament yarns were stretched simultaneously to the desired stretch ratio in a 100 cm tube at 145° C. Details of sample stretching are given in Table 1, along with selected fiber properties.

In addition, Fiber E had a main melting peak at 144° C. by DSC at a scanning rate of 10° C./minute.

              TABLE 1______________________________________          Stretch       Tenacity                               Modulus                                      U.E.Fiber Example  Ratio   Denier                        g/den  g/den  %______________________________________A     1        12      1156  11.9   400    5.4.sup. B* 1,2      18      1125  9.4    400    4.0C     3,4      13      976   15.0   521    5.8D     5        17      673   21.8   877    4.0E     6        15      456   21.6   936    3.9F     7        18      136   27.6   1143   4.1______________________________________ *Fiber B apparently retained some oil after extraction, thus accounting for its inferior properties compared to Fiber F.
EXAMPLES 1-6

High density polyethylene film (PAXON®4100 high density polyethylene, an ethylene-hexene-1 copolymer having a high load melt index of 10 made and sold by Allied Corporation) was placed on both sides of a three inch by three inch (6.72 cm×6.75 cm) steel plate and then layers of parallel multistrand yarn of high tenacity polyethylene yarn (as described below) were wound around the plate and film until the film on both sides was covered with parallel fibers. Film was then again placed on both sides and the yarn was wound in a direction perpendicular to the first layer. The process was repeated with alternating film and fiber layers, and with adjacent fiber layers being perpendicular to each other until the supply of fibers was exhausted or a fiber content of 7 g for each side has achieved. The wound plate was then molded under pressure for 30 minutes at 130°-140° C. The sample was then removed and slit around the edges to produce an A and B sample of identical fiber type and areal density.

The above procedure was followed six times with the fibers indicated in Table 2. For Example 1, 37.4 weight % of the fibers used were as indicated by the line 1--1 and 62.6 weight % of the fibers were as indicated by the line 1-2.

              TABLE 2______________________________________  Fiber      Fiber  Tenacity   Modulus         Fiber Wt %Example  (g/denier) (g/denier)                       UE*   Wt    Fiber______________________________________1-1    16.3       671       4.6%  7.425 g                                   75.21-2    9.5        400       4.0%2      9.5        400       4.0%  5.333 g                                   74.63      15.0       521       5.8%  7.456 g                                   75.54      15.0       521       5.8%  7.307 g                                   76.45      21.8       877       4.0%  7.182 g                                   74.76      21.6       936       3.9%  7.353 g                                   76.6______________________________________

Bullet fragments of 22 caliber projectile (Type 2) meeting the specifications of Military Specification MIL-P-46593A (ORD) were shot at each of the composites at an approximate velocity of 347 m/sec using the geometry of:

______________________________________G        A        B        T      C      D______________________________________5 feet   3 feet   3 feet   1.5 feet                             3 feet1.52 m   0.91 m   0.91 m   0.46 m 0.91 m______________________________________

where G represents the end of the gun barrel; A, B, C and D represent four lumiline screens and T represents the center of the target plaque. Velocities before and after impact were computed from flight times A-B and C-D. In all cases, the point of penetration through screen C indicated no deviation in flight path. The difference in these kinetic energies of the fragment before and after penetration of the composite was then divided by the following areal densities of fibers to calculate an energy loss in J/(kg/m2):

______________________________________       FibralExample     Areal Density (kg/m2)______________________________________1           1.282           0.923           1.284           1.265           1.246           1.27______________________________________

              TABLE 3______________________________________                   KineticTenacity     Velocity   Energy(g/          (m/sec)    (J)        LossEx.  Run    denier)  before/after                         before                               after                                    [J/(kg/m2)]______________________________________1    A      12.0     337.7/282.2                         62.8  42.9 14.81    B      12.0     346.3/298.7                         66.0  49.1 13.22    A      9.5      346.9/317.0                         66.3  55.3 11.92    B      9.5      335.0/304.8                         61.8  51.2 11.63    A      15.0     386.2/287.1                         82.1  45.4*                                    28.73    B      15.0     335.0/277.4                         61.8  42.4 15.24    A      15.0     333.1/274.9                         61.1  41.6 15.54    B      15.0     335.3/277.7                         61.9  42.5 15.45    A      21.8     353.0/287.1                         68.6  45.4 18.75    B      21.8     343.2/277.1                         64.9  42.3 18.26    A      21.6     343.8/247.8                         65.1  33.8 24.66    B      21.6     337.4/249.0                         62.7  34.2 22.5______________________________________ *Note the unusually high initial velocity for Example 3, Run A.

Plotting the energy loss versus fiber tenacity shows a positive correlation, with the relationship being fairly linear, except for low values for both composites of Example 5 (which may have experienced fiber melting during molding).

EXAMPLE 7

The procedure of Examples 1-6 was repeated using a 26.5 g/denier fiber, except that only a single pair of composites was prepared. Then the two composites were molded together using a film of low density polyethylene between them. This composite had 68% fibers and a fiber areal density of 1.31 kg/m2. On firing, the velocities before and after impact were 1143 ft/sec and 749 ft/sec (348.4 and 228.3 m/sec). The kinetic energies before and after impact were 66.9 J and 28.7 J. The energy loss based on 1.31 kg/m2 fiber areal density was then 29.1 J/(kg/m2), which, when plotted, falls on the line drawn through points from Examples 1-4 and 6.

COMPARATIVE EXAMPLE 8

Composites were prepared as in Examples 1-6 using a melt-spun polyethylene fiber having a tenacity of 5.6 g/denier. Some fiber melting occurred during molding due to the close melting points of the melt spun fiber and the high density polyethylene fiber. On firing a projectile the velocities measured before and after impact were 342.3 and 320.3 m/sec (1123 ft/sec and 1051 ft/sec), for energies before and after of 64.51 J and 56.5 J. The energy loss, based on a fibral areal density of 1.31 kg/m2 is 6.35 J/(kg/m2). substantially lower than the values for Examples 3-6 (being within the scope of the present invention), and lower even than values for Examples 1 and 2, where the fiber tenacity was under 15 g/denier.

EXAMPLES 9 AND 10 AND COMPARATIVE EXAMPLE 11 EXAMPLE 9

A high tenacity polyethylene fiber (tenacity 18.4 g/denier, tensile modulus 673 g/denier) was coated with low density polyethylene from a toluene solution. The polyethylene (tradename Union Carbide PE-DPA 6169 NT) had a melt index of 6 and a density of 0.931 g/cm3. The coated fibers were wound on a three inch by three inch (6.75 cm×6.75 cm) steel plate, with each layer wound perpendicular to the previous layer. The wound plate was molded for 30 minutes at 120°-130° C. The composite was then cut around the edges and the two halves molded together with a thin film of low density polyethylene in the center to obtain a single plaque having 86.6 weight % fiber content. Ballistics testing of this plaque is described below.

EXAMPLE 10

Example 9 was repeated using a high tenacity polyethylene fiber (tenacity 19.0 g/denier, modulus 732 g/denier) coated with high density polyethylene (tradename EA-55-100, melt index=10, density 0.955 g/cm3). After molding for 30 minutes at 130°-140° C., two composite plaques were produced (10A and 10B) each with 72.6 weight % fiber contact. Ballistic testing is described below.

COMPARATIVE EXAMPLE 11

For comparison, a 1500 denier KEVLAR® 29 aramid yarn (22 g/denier) woven roving fabric prepregged with phenolic polyvinyl butyral resin (resin content 20 weight %) was molded for 20 minutes at 166° C. Three such plaques (11A, 11B and 11C) were prepared with a fiber areal density of 1.04 kg/m2 each.

BALLISTIC TESTING 11-13

The six composites of Examples 11 and 12 and of Comparative Example 13 were taped over a 2.2 inch by 2.1 inch (5.6 cm×5.6 cm) cut in a three-eighths inch (1 cm) plywood sheet. Bullet fragments (0.22 type 2) according to Military Specification MIL-P-46593A (ORD) were fired through the plaques using the geometry of:

______________________________________G        A        B        T      C      D______________________________________5 feet   3 feet   3 feet   1.5 feet                             3 feet1.52 m   0.91 m   0.91 m   0.46 m 0.91 m______________________________________

where G represents the end of the gun barrel; A, B, C and D represent four lumiline screens and T represents the center of the target plaque. Velocities before and after impact were computed from flight times A-B and C-D. In all cases, the point of penetration through screen C indicated no deviation in flight path. The results are displayed in Table 4.

              TABLE 4______________________________________  Areal  Den-    Velocity              EnergyCom-   sity    (m/sec)     KE(J)     Lossposite kg/m2          Before  After Before                              After [J(kg/m2)]______________________________________9      1.11    327.7   226.2 59.1  28.2  27.910A    0.797   335.6   283.5 62.0  44.3  22.310B    0.797   331.3   278.3 60.5  42.7  22.311A    1.04    300.5   205.7 49.8  23.3  25.411B    1.04    342.6   273.4 64.7  41.2  22.611C    1.04    338.0   257.9 62.9  36.6  25.3controls       336.2   324.9 62.3  58.2  --(no com-       337.7   327.4 62.8  59.0  --posites)______________________________________

These results indicate comparable performance for composites prepared from polyethylene fibers of 18.4-19.0 g/denier tenacity and composites prepared from aramid fibers of 22 g/denier. Since the process of Kavesh et al. can produce fibers of tenacity 30 g/denier, 40 g/denier or higher, it is expected that these fibers would substantially outperform aramid fibers for ballistic applications.

EXAMPLES 12-13

Four 16 filament polyethylene xerogels were prepared according to the procedure described above before Example 1, but with 16 spinnerettes. One of the yarns (having been prepared from a 22.6 IV polymer) was stretched using one end at 140° C. (18:1); the other three yarns were stretched together (48 filaments) at 140° C. (17:1). The properties of these two yarns were measured and are displayed in Table 5 with published data on KEVLAR®-29 aramid yarn.

              TABLE 5______________________________________    16 Fil    48 Fil  KEVLAR-29______________________________________Denier     201         790     1043Tenacity (g/den)      21          18      22Modulus (g/den)      780         650     480Elongation 3.9%        4.7%    3-4%______________________________________

An aluminum plate; three inches×three inches×four-tenths inch (7.6 cm×7.6 cm×1 cm) was wound with one yarn, then covered with a 1.4 mil (0.036 mm) thick high density polyethylene film (Allied Corporation's 060-003), then wound in a perpendicular direction with yarn, then coated with film. After 10 fiber layers and 10 film were present on each side of the plate, the covered plate was cured at 136.6° C. for 15 minutes at 400 psi (2.76 MPa) pressure.

After molding, the composite ensemble was split around its edges to remove the aluminum plate. One of the 10 layer composites was retained for ballistic testing and the other was used as a central core for winding an additional 6 yarn/film layers to prepare a composite containing a total of 22 yarn layers (both 16 fil yarn and 48 fil yarn were used). The areal densities and the fiber areal densities of the 10 layer and 22 layer ECPE composites are given in Table 2, below. The fiber volume fraction was about 75% in each.

Ballistics testing of these composites are described below.

EXAMPLE 14

A fourteen layer composite similar to the twenty-two layer composite of Example 13 was prepared by winding two fiber/film layers onto each side of a similar ten layer composite. The fourteen layer composite had a total areal density of 0.274 kg/m3 and fibral areal density of 0.167 kg/m3. The same 16 and 48 fiber yarn was used.

COMPARATIVE EXAMPLE 15

Composites of Kevlar-29 aramid and polyester resin were prepared in a similar manner except that the matrix polyester system was doctored onto each Kevlar layer to impregnate the ensemble. The polyester system was Vestopal-W plus 1% tertiary butyl perbenzoate and 0.5% cobalt naphthenate. The ensembles were cured at 100°±5° C., for one hour at approximately 400 PSI (2.76 MPa) pressure. The areal densities and fiber areal densities are given in Table II. The fiber volume fractions were 75%.

BALLISTIC TESTING

Ballistic testing of the composites of examples 12-14 and the Kevlar-29/polyester 3"×3" composite plaques of comparative Example 15 were performed in a identical manner. The plaques were placed against a backing material consisting of a polyethylene covered water-filled urethane foam block. The density of the backing material was 0.93 g/cm3. The ammunition fired was 22 caliber, longrifle, high velocity, solid nose, lead bullets. The rounds were fired from a handgun of six inch (15 cm) barrel length at a distance of six feet (1.8 m), impacting perpendicular to the plaque surface. Impact velocity was approximately 1150 ft/sec (353 m/sec) (Ref: "Gunners Bible", Doubleday and Co., Garden City, NY 1965).

The qualitative results are displayed in Table 6. In the column labeled "Penetration" the word "Yes" means that the bullet passed completely through the plaque; the work "No" means that the bullet was stopped within the plaque.

              TABLE 6______________________________________          Composite Areal                       Fiber Areal                                 Pene-Example  Layers  Density (g/cm3)                       Density (g/cm3)                                 tration______________________________________12     10      0.122        0.097     Yes13     22      0.367        0.248     No14     14      0.274        0.167     No15A     7      0.131        0.097     Yes15B    12      0.225        0.167     No15C    18      0.360        0.256     No______________________________________

These results indicate that the composites using polyethylene fibers of 18-21 g/denier tenacity required roughly the same areal density (0.167±0.05 g/cm3) as the aramid composite to defeat the 22 caliber projectile.

EXAMPLE 16 Mode of Failure

The fragment exit side of Example 7 was examined by scanning electron microscopy and found to have a fibrillar structure similar to that reported for Kevlar® fibers (Ballistic Materials and Penetration Mechanics--R. C. Laible--Elsevier Scientific Publishing Company--1980). Fibers exhibited extensive longitudinal splitting similar to that found when fibers were broken in an Instron Tensile Tester using a 10 inch (25.4 cm) length of fiber pulled at 10 in./min (25.4 cm/min). There was no evidence of the smooth knobs shown at the end of impacted polyester fibers shown in FIG. 6, Page 84--Ballistic Materials and Penetration Mechanics. (The knob-like structure at the end of the impacted polyester is attributed to melting).

Example 2B (see Table 3) exhibited similar morphology after ballistic impact, but the fibrillation was less extensive, and there was evidence of a minor amount of melting.

Non-Patent Citations
Reference
1 *A. L. Alesi et al., "New Materials and Construction for Improved Helmets," Nov. 1975, pp. 1-11.
2 *J. V. Hansen et al., "Flexible Body Armor Materials," 10th National State of the Art Symposium, Washington, D.C., Jun. 1974.
3 *R. C. Liable et al., "The Application of High-Modulus Fibers to Ballistic Protection," J. Macromol. Sci.-Chem., A7(1), pp. 295-298, 312-314, 320-322 ('73).
4 *R. C. Liable, "Ballistic Materials and Penetration Mechanics," Methods and Phenomena: Their Applications in Sci. and Tech., 1980, vol. 5, pp. 72-115.
Referenced by
Citing PatentFiling datePublication dateApplicantTitle
US4457985 *Feb 18, 1983Jul 3, 1984Allied CorporationBallistic-resistant article
US4543286 *Nov 22, 1983Sep 24, 1985Allied CorporationComposite containing coated extended chain polyolefin fibers
US4613535 *Feb 28, 1985Sep 23, 1986Allied CorporationComplex composite article having improved impact resistance
US4623574 *Jan 14, 1985Nov 18, 1986Allied CorporationBallistic-resistant composite article
US4639387 *Jan 18, 1985Jan 27, 1987Budd CompanyFibrous armor material
US4650710 *Dec 9, 1985Mar 17, 1987Allied CorporationBallistic-resistant fabric article
US4681792 *Dec 9, 1985Jul 21, 1987Allied CorporationMulti-layered flexible fiber-containing articles
US4732803 *Oct 7, 1986Mar 22, 1988Smith Novis W JrLight weight armor
US4737401 *Dec 9, 1985Apr 12, 1988Allied CorporationBallistic-resistant fine weave fabric article
US4737402 *Dec 9, 1985Apr 12, 1988Allied CorporationComplex composite article having improved impact resistance
US4748064 *Dec 9, 1985May 31, 1988Allied CorporationBallistic-resistant composite article
US4819458 *Sep 30, 1982Apr 11, 1989Allied-Signal Inc.Heat shrunk fabrics provided from ultra-high tenacity and modulus fibers and methods for producing same
US4820568 *Aug 3, 1987Apr 11, 1989Allied-Signal Inc.Composite and article using short length fibers
US4822439 *Aug 24, 1987Apr 18, 1989Owens-Corning Fiberglas CorporationProcess for forming thick ballistic resistant materials
US4842923 *Jul 27, 1987Jun 27, 1989Owens-Corning Fiberglas CorporationBallistic materials
US4876774 *Sep 1, 1983Oct 31, 1989Allied-Signal Inc.Method for preparing heat set fabrics
US4883700 *Aug 3, 1987Nov 28, 1989Allied-Signal Inc.Composite and article using short length fibers at oblique angles
US4916000 *Jul 13, 1987Apr 10, 1990Allied-Signal Inc.Ballistic-resistant composite article
US4929651 *Nov 10, 1988May 29, 1990Owens-Corning Fiberglas CorporationProcess for forming thick ballistic resistant materials
US4944974 *Oct 26, 1988Jul 31, 1990Zachariades Anagnostis EComposite structures of ultra-high-molecular-weight polymers, such as ultra-high-molecular-weight polyethylene products, and method of producing such structures
US4952361 *Oct 14, 1988Aug 28, 1990Dyneema V.O.F.Surface treatment of polyolefin objects
US4953234 *Jul 10, 1989Sep 4, 1990Allied-Signal Inc.Impact resistant helmet
US4963299 *Jun 24, 1988Oct 16, 1990Stamicarbon B.V.Surface treatment of polyolefin objects
US5006293 *Feb 2, 1989Apr 9, 1991Owens-Corning Fiberglas CorporationProcess for forming flat plate ballistic resistant materials
US5006296 *Sep 1, 1988Apr 9, 1991The Dow Chemical CompanyProcess for the preparation of fibers of stereoregular polystyrene
US5006390 *Jun 19, 1989Apr 9, 1991Allied-SignalRigid polyethylene reinforced composites having improved short beam shear strength
US5035111 *Sep 30, 1988Jul 30, 1991Stamicarbon B.V.Combinations of polymer filaments or yarns having a low coefficient of friction and filaments or yarns having a high coefficient of friction, and use thereof
US5071917 *Aug 20, 1990Dec 10, 1991The Dow Chemical CompanyHigh strength fibers of stereoregular polystrene
US5093158 *Nov 28, 1988Mar 3, 1992Allied-Signal Inc.Method to make fiber/polymer composite with nonuniformly distributed polymer matrix
US5160472 *Feb 9, 1990Nov 3, 1992Zachariades Anagnostis EMethod of producing composite structures of ultra-high-molecular-weight polymers, such as ultra-high-molecular-weight polyethylene products
US5160776 *Jun 24, 1991Nov 3, 1992Allied-Signal Inc.Ballistic-resistant composite article
US5167876 *Dec 7, 1990Dec 1, 1992Allied-Signal Inc.Flame resistant ballistic composite
US5173138 *Aug 8, 1990Dec 22, 1992Blauch Denise AMethod and apparatus for the continuous production of cross-plied material
US5182155 *Apr 15, 1991Jan 26, 1993Itt CorporationRadome structure providing high ballistic protection with low signal loss
US5185195 *Nov 19, 1990Feb 9, 1993Allied-Signal Inc.Constructions having improved penetration resistance
US5196252 *Nov 19, 1990Mar 23, 1993Allied-SignalBallistic resistant fabric articles
US5221432 *Feb 1, 1991Jun 22, 1993Korea Institute Of Science And TechnologyMethod for adhesion promotion of an ultra high modulus polyethylene fiber/epoxy resin composite
US5254383 *Sep 14, 1992Oct 19, 1993Allied-Signal Inc.Composites having improved penetration resistance and articles fabricated from same
US5316820 *Jun 7, 1993May 31, 1994Alliedsignal Inc.Flexible composites having flexing rigid panels and articles fabricated from same
US5318575 *Feb 3, 1992Jun 7, 1994United States Surgical CorporationMethod of using a surgical repair suture product
US5330820 *Nov 6, 1989Jul 19, 1994Alliedsignal Inc.Ballistic resistant composition article having improved matrix system
US5343796 *Aug 5, 1992Sep 6, 1994Allied-Signal Inc.Armor systems
US5376426 *Dec 9, 1993Dec 27, 1994Alliedsignal Inc.Penetration and blast resistant composites and articles
US5395671 *Jun 15, 1993Mar 7, 1995Coppage, Jr.; Edward A.Protective fabric
US5440965 *Aug 30, 1993Aug 15, 1995Alliedsignal Inc.Armor systems
US5480706 *Jun 16, 1994Jan 2, 1996Alliedsignal Inc.Fire resistant ballistic resistant composite armor
US5536553 *Apr 21, 1995Jul 16, 1996Safariland, Ltd., Inc.Protective fabric comprising calendered sub-plies of woven fabric joined together by stitching
US5545455 *Jan 24, 1995Aug 13, 1996Alliedsignal Inc.Constructions having improved penetration resistance
US5552208 *Oct 29, 1993Sep 3, 1996Alliedsignal Inc.High strength composite
US5567498 *Sep 24, 1993Oct 22, 1996Alliedsignal Inc.Textured ballistic article
US5573850 *Mar 24, 1995Nov 12, 1996Alliedsignal Inc.Abrasion resistant quasi monofilament and sheathing composition
US5576358 *Feb 3, 1995Nov 19, 1996Alliedsignal Inc.Composition for use in friction materials and articles formed therefrom
US5579628 *Jan 24, 1995Dec 3, 1996Alliedsignal Inc.Entangled high strength yarn
US5587230 *Jun 2, 1995Dec 24, 1996Alliedsignal Inc.High strength composite
US5601775 *Mar 24, 1995Feb 11, 1997Alliedsignal Inc.Process for making an abrasion resistant quasi monofilament
US5612125 *Dec 12, 1994Mar 18, 1997Nippon Oil Co., Ltd.Process for producing prepreg
US5619748 *Mar 18, 1996Apr 15, 1997Safariland Ltd., Inc.Ballistic vest
US5628946 *Sep 30, 1994May 13, 1997British Technology Group LimitedProcess for producing polymeric materials
US5690526 *Jul 3, 1996Nov 25, 1997Lin; Chi-Tsun LeroyHigh strength, ballistic resistant composites
US5723388 *Jan 7, 1997Mar 3, 1998Nippon Oil Co., Ltd.Prepreg of ultra-high-molecular-weight polyethylene
US5724670 *Oct 3, 1996Mar 10, 1998Safariland Ltd., Inc.Multi-component ballistic vest
US5736244 *Aug 28, 1995Apr 7, 1998Alliedsignal Inc.Shaped polyethylene articles of intermediate molecular weight and high modulus
US5773370 *Feb 15, 1996Jun 30, 1998Alliedsignal Inc.Entangled high strength yarn
US5788907 *Mar 15, 1996Aug 4, 1998Clark-Schwebel, Inc.Fabrics having improved ballistic performance and processes for making the same
US5789327 *Aug 27, 1996Aug 4, 1998Rousseau; Wm. RichardArmor panel
US5804015 *Jun 7, 1995Sep 8, 1998Alliedsignal Inc.Textured ballistic article
US5926842 *Oct 2, 1996Jul 27, 1999Safariland Ltd., Inc.Ballistic vest
US5958804 *May 27, 1997Sep 28, 1999Hexcel Cs CorporationFabrics having improved ballistic performance and processes for making the same
US5972498 *Mar 23, 1998Oct 26, 1999Alliedsignal Inc.Shaped polyethylene articles of intermediate molecular weight and high modulus
US6017834 *Jan 27, 1997Jan 25, 2000Btg International LimitedMonoliyhic polymeric product
US6268301Mar 25, 1992Jul 31, 2001Toyobo Co., Ltd.Ballistic-resistant article and process for making the same
US6276254Jun 3, 1999Aug 21, 2001Alliedsignal Inc.Armor systems
US6277773Dec 13, 1999Aug 21, 2001Btg International LimitedPolymeric materials
US6312638Apr 2, 1999Nov 6, 2001Btg InternationalProcess of making a compacted polyolefin article
US6328923Apr 2, 1999Dec 11, 2001Btg International LimitedProcess of making a compacted polyolefin article
US6458727Jul 31, 2000Oct 1, 2002University Of Leeds Innovative LimitedOlefin polymers
US6543055Jan 26, 2001Apr 8, 2003Warwick Mills, Inc.Penetration resistant garment
US6548430Dec 3, 1999Apr 15, 2003Warwick Mills, Inc.Protective fabric having high penetration resistance
US6562435Mar 17, 2000May 13, 2003Survival, IncorporatedMethod for forming or securing unindirectionally-oriented fiber strands in sheet form, such as for use in a ballistic-resistant panel
US6642159Aug 16, 2000Nov 4, 2003Honeywell International Inc.Impact resistant rigid composite and method for manufacture
US6693052Dec 14, 2000Feb 17, 2004Warwick Mills, Inc.Garment including protective fabric
US6720277 *Apr 9, 1999Apr 13, 2004Warwick Mills, Inc.Protective fabric having high penetration resistance
US6764764May 23, 2003Jul 20, 2004Honeywell International Inc.Polyethylene protective yarn
US6824863 *Sep 28, 2000Nov 30, 2004Sumitomo Chemical Company, LimitedFiber reinforced polypropylene-based composite material
US6841492Jun 25, 2002Jan 11, 2005Honeywell International Inc.Bi-directional and multi-axial fabrics and fabric composites
US6846548Feb 19, 1999Jan 25, 2005Honeywell International Inc.Flexible fabric from fibrous web and discontinuous domain matrix
US6846758Apr 19, 2002Jan 25, 2005Honeywell International Inc.Ballistic fabric laminates
US6945155Jul 18, 2001Sep 20, 2005Honeywell International Inc.Armor systems
US6979660Apr 8, 2004Dec 27, 2005Honeywell International Inc.Polyethylene protective yarn
US7073538Oct 19, 2004Jul 11, 2006Honeywell International Inc.Bi-directional and multi-axial fabric and fabric composites
US7211291Oct 16, 2001May 1, 2007Honeywell International Inc.Flexible fabric from fibrous web and discontinuous domain matrix
US7235285 *Apr 2, 2003Jun 26, 2007Toyo Boseki Kabushiki KaishaHigh strength polyethylene fibers and their applications
US7279441Nov 21, 2003Oct 9, 2007Btg International LimitedCompacted olefin fibers
US7288493Jan 18, 2005Oct 30, 2007Honeywell International Inc.Body armor with improved knife-stab resistance formed from flexible composites
US7600537Sep 16, 2005Oct 13, 2009Honeywell International Inc.Reinforced plastic pipe
US7601416Dec 6, 2005Oct 13, 2009Honeywell International Inc.Fragment and stab resistant flexible material with reduced trauma effect
US7629277 *Nov 23, 2005Dec 8, 2009Honeywell International Inc.Frag shield
US7687412Aug 26, 2005Mar 30, 2010Honeywell International Inc.Flexible ballistic composites resistant to liquid pick-up method for manufacture and articles made therefrom
US7727914Aug 8, 2006Jun 1, 2010E. I. Du Pont De Nemours And CompanyFlexible penetration resistant article
US7892379Sep 29, 2008Feb 22, 2011Milliken & CompanyMoldable fabric with unidirectional tape yarns
US7919418Jun 28, 2007Apr 5, 2011Honeywell International Inc.High performance ballistic composites having improved flexibility and method of making the same
US7960024Jan 27, 2009Jun 14, 2011Milliken & CompanyMulti-layered fiber
US7964050Jun 4, 2008Jun 21, 2011Barrday, Inc.Method for processing a composite
US7964518Apr 19, 2010Jun 21, 2011Honeywell International Inc.Enhanced ballistic performance of polymer fibers
US8021592Apr 24, 2007Sep 20, 2011Propex Operating Company LlcProcess for fabricating polypropylene sheet
US8029633Jan 27, 2009Oct 4, 2011Milliken & CompanyMethod of forming a consolidated fibrous structure
US8052913May 21, 2004Nov 8, 2011Propex Operating Company LlcProcess for fabricating polymeric articles
US8080486Jul 28, 2010Dec 20, 2011Honeywell International Inc.Ballistic shield composites with enhanced fragment resistance
US8114507Jan 27, 2009Feb 14, 2012Milliken & CompanyMulti-layered fiber
US8119549Jan 27, 2009Feb 21, 2012Milliken & CompanyConsolidated fibrous structure
US8132494Apr 10, 1991Mar 13, 2012Honeywell International, Inc.Ballistic resistant composite article having improved matrix system
US8133537May 3, 2011Mar 13, 2012Milliken & CompanyMethod of forming a multi-layered fiber
US8147957Jan 27, 2009Apr 3, 2012Milliken & CompanyConsolidated fibrous structure
US8236711Jun 12, 2008Aug 7, 2012Milliken & CompanyFlexible spike and knife resistant composite
US8267001 *Dec 4, 2007Sep 18, 2012Battelle Memorial InstituteComposite armor and method for making composite armor
US8268439Oct 18, 2011Sep 18, 2012Propex Operating Company, LlcProcess for fabricating polymeric articles
US8293353Nov 25, 2008Oct 23, 2012Milliken & CompanyEnergy absorbing panel
US8309478Nov 30, 2011Nov 13, 2012Milliken & CompanyConsolidated fibrous structure
US8443706Sep 7, 2011May 21, 2013E I Du Pont De Nemours And CompanyTriaxial braid fabric architectures for improved soft body armor ballistic impact performance
US8613242 *Oct 24, 2012Dec 24, 2013Peters Security International, Inc.Anti-ballistic shelters
US8652570Nov 16, 2006Feb 18, 2014Honeywell International Inc.Process for forming unidirectionally oriented fiber structures
US8658244 *Jun 25, 2008Feb 25, 2014Honeywell International Inc.Method of making colored multifilament high tenacity polyolefin yarns
US8689671Sep 27, 2007Apr 8, 2014Federal-Mogul World Wide, Inc.Lightweight armor and methods of making
US8820493Oct 19, 2010Sep 2, 2014Foster-Miller, Inc.Shock energy absorber
US8871333Jul 30, 2012Oct 28, 2014Ian MacMillan WardInterlayer hot compaction
US9010230Dec 23, 2013Apr 21, 2015Shieldpro, LlcAnti-ballistic shelters
US20040092183 *Feb 3, 2003May 13, 2004Shalom GevaAntiballistic composite material comprising combinations of distinct types of fibers
US20040113324 *Nov 21, 2003Jun 17, 2004Btg Internationl LimitedOlefin polymers
US20040209537 *Jun 26, 2003Oct 21, 2004Sung-Man JungFunctional high-strength adhesive sheet, manufacturing system and method thereof, and functional high-strength steel plate attached with the adhesive sheet
US20040237763 *Jun 2, 2003Dec 2, 2004Ashok BhatnagarCorrugated ballistic armor
US20040239002 *Oct 8, 2002Dec 2, 2004Ward Ian MProcess for fabricating polypropylene sheet
US20040258909 *Apr 8, 2004Dec 23, 2004Honeywell International Inc.Polyethylene protective yarn
US20110159233 *Apr 17, 2008Jun 30, 2011Marissen Roelof RMethod of producing a curved product comprising drawn polymer reinforcing elements and product obtained thereby
US20120291621 *Dec 7, 2010Nov 22, 2012Battelle Memorial InstituteComposite armor and method for making composite armor
US20130098233 *Oct 24, 2012Apr 25, 2013Peters Security International, Inc.Anti-ballistic shelters
CN1758012BSep 2, 2005May 5, 2010北京玻钢院复合材料有限公司Armoured material and its shaping method
EP0494269A1 *Sep 14, 1990Jul 15, 1992Custom Papers Group Inc.Ballistic-resistant articles and method of manufacture thereof
EP2497618A2Mar 27, 2008Sep 12, 2012Honeywell International Inc.Method to apply multiple coatings to a fiber web and fibrous composite
EP2505954A2Nov 28, 2007Oct 3, 2012Honeywell International Inc.Spaced lightweight composite armor
WO1987003674A1 *Oct 28, 1986Jun 18, 1987Allied CorpMulti-layered, flexible, fiber-containing articles
WO1989006190A1 *Jul 11, 1988Jul 13, 1989Allied Signal IncBallistic-resistant composite article
WO1992010363A1 *Dec 6, 1991Jun 25, 1992Allied Signal IncFlame resistant ballistic composite
WO1999036606A1Jan 19, 1999Jul 22, 1999O Oakley Etheridge JrBallistic-resistant textile articles made from cut-resistant fibers
WO2007115057A1Mar 29, 2007Oct 11, 2007Honeywell Int IncMolded ballistic panel with enhanced structural performance
WO2008016362A2 *Aug 8, 2006Feb 7, 2008Du PontFlexible penetration resistant article
WO2008054372A2 *Sep 26, 2006May 8, 2008Milliken & CoMoldable fabric with unidirectional yarns
WO2008061170A1Nov 15, 2007May 22, 2008Honeywell Int IncProcess for forming unidirectionally oriented fiber structures
WO2013036751A2Sep 7, 2012Mar 14, 2013E. I. Du Pont De Nemours And CompanyTriaxial braid fabric architectures for improved soft body armor ballistic impact performance
WO2014064013A1 *Oct 18, 2013May 1, 2014Borealis AgFiber-reinforced composite
Classifications
U.S. Classification442/135, 264/271.1, 428/911, 428/902, 442/170, 264/257
International ClassificationB32B27/32, F41H5/04, F41H1/02, D01F6/00
Cooperative ClassificationY10T442/291, Y10T442/2623, Y10S428/911, Y10S428/902, C08J5/046, C08J2323/04, F41H5/0485, F41H1/02, B32B27/32
European ClassificationF41H1/02, B32B27/32, F41H5/04F4, C08J5/04L
Legal Events
DateCodeEventDescription
Mar 19, 1982ASAssignment
Owner name: ALLIED CHEMICAL CORPORATION; COLUMBIA RD. & PARK A
Free format text: ASSIGNMENT OF ASSIGNORS INTEREST.;ASSIGNORS:HARPELL, GARY A.;KAVESH, SHELDON;PALLEY, IGOR;AND OTHERS;REEL/FRAME:003979/0339
Effective date: 19820318
Dec 22, 1986FPAYFee payment
Year of fee payment: 4
Oct 31, 1990FPAYFee payment
Year of fee payment: 8
Dec 15, 1994FPAYFee payment
Year of fee payment: 12