|Publication number||USRE36746 E|
|Application number||US 09/154,926|
|Publication date||Jun 27, 2000|
|Filing date||Sep 16, 1998|
|Priority date||Feb 23, 1996|
|Also published as||CN1212028A, EP0958406A1, US5681486, WO1997031136A1|
|Publication number||09154926, 154926, US RE36746 E, US RE36746E, US-E-RE36746, USRE36746 E, USRE36746E|
|Inventors||Herbert S. Goode, Jr., Jean A. Nielsen, Larry E. Nitzsche|
|Original Assignee||The Boeing Company|
|Export Citation||BiBTeX, EndNote, RefMan|
|Patent Citations (14), Non-Patent Citations (1), Classifications (8), Legal Events (4)|
|External Links: USPTO, USPTO Assignment, Espacenet|
The invention relates to the surface treatment of metals and metallic alloys to remove surface scales that arise naturally or from heat treatment processes. More particularly, the invention relates to a method of subjecting the surfaces of titanium and titanium alloy aircraft components to a reactive plasma to remove these surface scales.
Titanium and its alloys are used in the fabrication of aircraft. These metals are used to form not only the outer skin of the aircraft, but also internal support structures because of their light weight and high strength. In order to achieve desired physical properties, the titanium alloys are first heat treated. However, heat treatment results in the formation of a dense, tightly adherent oxide on outer surfaces of the metal. This oxide ranges in thickness from about 0.001 to about 0.010 inches and must be removed before subsequent machining, forming or joining operations. Scale covered parts cannot be joined by welding. Alpha case is difficult to machine, causing excessive tool wear and breakage. Also, alpha case scale can cause cracking of the titanium that may result in catastrophic failure.
Generally, in current methods, the oxide scale is removed through treatment of the metal in a series of chemical baths. Some of these chemical baths contain concentrated alkaline solutions while others contain highly toxic and corrosive acids, including nitric acid and hydrofluoric acid. As a consequence, the baths and ancillary equipment that come into contact with these corrosive chemicals must be fabricated from expensive exotic materials that are resistant to attack.
In order to remove the surface oxide scale, the heat treated titanium alloy is immersed in each of the chemical baths for a period of time. The time of immersion is estimated to allow sufficient time for the scale to dissolve in the acids, without significant intergranular attack on the underlying titanium alloy substrate. Such estimates are, at best, inexact, sometimes resulting in overimmersion accompanied by some resultant intergranular attack, or underimmersion, and at other times resulting in the retention of a residual thin scale layer. In some instances, some surfaces of the same aircraft component may be overexposed (and hence etched) on some portions of its surface, and underexposed (and hence retain a thin scale layer) at other portions of its surface. To minimize these effects, parts are sometimes designed with excessive material in areas that will be over-etched, or the areas are covered with masking composition during part of the cycle. Also, the part may be inverted at least once during the etching cycle since upper portions of the part etch faster than lower submerged portions. Some of the hydrogen generated during acid-etching may also migrate into the alloy structure causing "hydrogen-embrittlement"--a serious problem that reduces fatigue strength significantly. To minimize this problem, treated parts may have to be baked to remove the hydrogen. In addition to all of these problems, the chemical bath treatment system generates a hazardous waste containing heavy metal ions that must be disposed of in an environmentally acceptable manner. Such disposal is becoming increasingly costly.
There exists a need for a process of removing the dense oxide scale that forms on titanium and titanium alloy components used in the aircraft industry. The method should generate no, or very little, hazardous waste for disposal. Furthermore, it should be cost effective, allowing rapid cleaning of large components. The process should be controllable to avoid significant intergranular attack of the underlying metal, while at the same time completely removing the surface scale.
The invention provides a method of removing the oxide scale produced by the heat treatment of crystalline titanium and titanium alloys. The method is particularly well suited for the removal of such scales from large titanium or titanium alloys substrates, such as aircraft components. Moreover, the method generates very little hazardous waste, in comparison with the chemical bath immersion technique. The method is cost-effective and removes scale at a rate of at least about 0.0001, and preferably at least about 0.0005 to about 0.002, inches per hour.
The method includes heating the surface scale-covered titanium or titanium alloy substrate to a temperature that is sufficiently high to promote reaction of chemical components of the scale at commercially useful rates with a plasma generated from a gas that produces fluoride ions, such as CF4 and SF6, and the like. Usually, the substrate is heated to a temperature in the range from about 100° C. to about 600° C. The plasma reacts with the scale, removing the oxide scale and any alpha case. Importantly, this is achieved without intergranular attack on the underlying crystalline titanium or titanium alloy substrate. The plasma reaction self-terminates when the plasma has reacted with the scale and the plasma encounters the underlying metallic substrate. Consequently, the invention provides a method that is not only capable of removing the surface scale, but is also capable of doing so uniformly, on all surfaces of the substrate.
Advantageously, the method of the invention may be carried out in certain commercially available plasma generation chambers, especially when suitably modified in accordance with the invention. Preferably, but not necessarily, the plasma chamber is supplied with either radiation, inductive, kinetic, or conductive heating means so that a titanium or titanium alloy substrate placed within the chamber may be heated to within the desired temperature range, as explained above. Thereafter, the heated component is subjected to plasma that reacts with and removes the surface scale.
The foregoing aspects and many of the attendant advantages of this invention will become more readily appreciated as the same becomes better understood by reference to the following detailed description, when taken in conjunction with the accompanying drawings: the FIGURE is a schematic cross-sectional view showing a titanium alloy substrate with one side of its upper surface exposed for etching, and the other side of the upper surface covered with an adhered silicon mask.
The invention addresses a significant problem in the surface treatment of heat-treated titanium, and titanium alloys, for removal of thick scales of oxide and alpha case formed during the heat-treatment process. According to the invention, the oxide scale, and alpha case, if any, is readily removed without significant generation of hazardous waste byproducts.
Advantageously, the method of the invention can be practiced using conventional equipment, with suitable modification. Thus, for example, the plasma descaling step may be conducted in any suitable chamber for generation of a plasma from a gas able to produce fluoride ions. The chamber may optionally be modified, by installation of convective, inductive, or radiation heating means, to first preheat the substrate to be treated to a temperature in the range from about 100° C. to about 600° C., preferably about 150° to about 550° C., most preferably about 220° to about 520° C. Otherwise, the titanium or titanium alloy substrate may be preheated in an oven and then transferred to the plasma chamber.
Optionally, in accordance with the invention, the surface of the heat-treated titanium or titanium alloy substrate to be descaled is first cleaned using conventional techniques to remove surface grime and dirt. Since the titanium, or titanium alloy, has been heat-treated, the metal is in crystalline form and the surface scale is tightly adherent to this underlying crystalline metal. Typically, an oxide scale ranges in thickness from about 0.001 to 0.010 inch. Moreover, in some instances a thin scale or layer of alpha case also forms at the surface of the heat-treated metal. This alpha case layer typically has a thickness in the range from 0.001 to about 0.007 inches. As explained above, in order to prepare the metallic part for subsequent machining, forming or joining operations, the surface scales, whether oxide, alpha case, or both, must be removed.
In accordance with the invention, the cleaned metallic substrate is first heated to a temperature in that temperature range where a plasma formed from a fluoride-ion producing gas, such as CF4 or SF6 gas, will react with and remove the scale without intergranular attack on the underlying crystalline metal substrate. Preferably, the substrate is heated to a temperature in the range from about 100° C. to about 600° C., more preferably to a temperature in the range from about 150° C. to about 550° C., and most preferably about 200° C. to about 520° C.
The substrate is optionally preheated outside the chamber and then placed in the chamber, or is heated inside the chamber by radiative, conductive, inductive, or kinetic methods. As is conventional, the chamber is then evacuated to a pressure of about 2 to about 10 Pascal, preferably less than 8 Pascal. Then, the water-free gas from which the plasma is formed, is introduced into the chamber at a flow rate sufficient to produce a useful concentration of fluoride ions. Thus, for instance, for a 6.3 liter volume chamber the flow rate is from about 20 to about 80 standard cubic centimeters per minute fluoride ion-producing gas, along with lesser amounts of water-free oxygen and/or argon at the flow rate of from about 1 to about 5 standard cubic centimeters per minute. The gas from which the plasma is formed may be selected from any of the gasses that produce a fluoride ion when subjected to a radio frequency discharge. Thus, for example, the fluoride ion-producing gas is exemplified by fluorocarbons, sulfur fluorides, phosphorous fluorides, and the like. Preferably, the power concentration is at least about 1.0 watt per centimeter for SF6, and at least about 0.5 watts per centimeter for CF4.
By controlling the temperature of the substrate, descaling may be achieved without intergranular attack of the underlying crystalline metal. Optionally, thereafter, the temperature of the substrate may be carefully raised to allow light etching of the substrate surface. Advantageously, however, in accordance with the invention, the plasma reaction self-terminates when the plasma has reacted with all the scale, whether oxide or alpha case, and the plasma encounters the underlying crystalline metallic substrate. Since alpha case forms unevenly over the surface of the metallic substrate, the removal of the alpha case results in a surface that has a certain roughness, by microelectronic standards. However, the surface finish is excellent by aerospace standards.
Importantly, aerospace titanium pans to be welded typically have a surface finish of Ra ranging from about 30 to about 60. This surface finish range is achieved using the plasma descale process of the invention alone, without further treatment. The prior an chemical tank immersion processes, described above, typically produce rougher surfaces, surfaces having Ra's in the range about 40 to about 120.
The surface produced by the descaring process of the invention is suitable for dye penetrant inspection. Importantly, since the titanium substrate is not exposed to hydrogen during the process of the invention, the risk of hydrogen embrittlement does not arise. Moreover, the need for subsequent baking cycles to remove entrapped hydrogen is eliminated.
The following example illustrates the method of the invention and is not limiting of the invention as described above and claimed herebelow.
Two samples of heat-treated titanium alloy were descaled, one in SF6 and the other in CF4 plasmas. Each sample measured 0.5×1.5 inches and was 0.125 inches thick. Since the 6.3 liter volume plasma chamber used for descaling was only able to accept 5-inch wide wafers, each sample 10 was adhered to an upper surface of a 5-inch silicon wafer 12 with photoresist material 14 in order to lead the sample into the chamber, as illustrated in the FIGURE. Moreover, in order to provide a comparison between the descaled and original surfaces, one side of the upper surface 10a of each sample was covered with a strip of silicon 16 adhered to the face of the sample with photoresist 14 to provide a mask, while the other side 10b was exposed to the plasma.
The descaling with CF4 was carried out with a flow rate of 45 ccs per minute of CF4 through the chamber, along with 2 ccs per minute of oxygen. The plasma descaling was carried out for in periods of 30 minutes, that included 6 cycles at 200 watts, 6 cycles at 300 watts, and thereafter a further cycle at 300 watts. The total descaling time was 6 hours and 30 minutes.
The SF6 descaling was carried out with a flow rate of 45 ccs per minute of SF6 and 2 ccs per minute of oxygen for a total of 2 hours. The descaling included 3 15-minute cycles at 350 watts, 4 15-minute cycles at 400 watts, and a final 15-minute cycle at 400 watts.
Each sample was descaled until its surface appeared visually clear, and free of surface scale. Scale removal was confirmed by cross section of the specimens and examination at 1,000 times magnification. No intergranular attack was visible.
While the preferred embodiments of the invention have been illustrated and described, it will be appreciated that various changes can be made therein without departing from the spirit and scope of the invention.
|Cited Patent||Filing date||Publication date||Applicant||Title|
|US3239440 *||Nov 23, 1964||Mar 8, 1966||Titanium Metals Corp||Electrolytic pickling of titanium and titanium base alloy articles|
|US3468774 *||Dec 9, 1966||Sep 23, 1969||Rohr Corp||Electrolytic descaling of titanium and its alloys|
|US3632490 *||Nov 12, 1968||Jan 4, 1972||Titanium Metals Corp||Method of electrolytic descaling and pickling|
|US4288283 *||Jan 8, 1980||Sep 8, 1981||Hitachi, Ltd.||Method of forming a microscopic pattern|
|US5108543 *||Oct 20, 1988||Apr 28, 1992||Hitachi, Ltd.||Method of surface treatment|
|US5176792 *||Oct 28, 1991||Jan 5, 1993||At&T Bell Laboratories||Method for forming patterned tungsten layers|
|US5221424 *||Nov 21, 1991||Jun 22, 1993||Applied Materials, Inc.||Method for removal of photoresist over metal which also removes or inactivates corosion-forming materials remaining from previous metal etch|
|US5354417 *||Oct 13, 1993||Oct 11, 1994||Applied Materials, Inc.||Etching MoSi2 using SF6, HBr and O2|
|US5365515 *||Apr 28, 1994||Nov 15, 1994||Tut Systems, Inc.||Network monitor and test apparatus|
|US5399237 *||Jan 27, 1994||Mar 21, 1995||Applied Materials, Inc.||Etching titanium nitride using carbon-fluoride and carbon-oxide gas|
|US5419805 *||Feb 18, 1994||May 30, 1995||Northern Telecom Limited||Selective etching of refractory metal nitrides|
|US5467883 *||Nov 17, 1993||Nov 21, 1995||At&T Corp.||Active neural network control of wafer attributes in a plasma etch process|
|US5843289 *||Jan 22, 1996||Dec 1, 1998||Etex Corporation||Surface modification of medical implants|
|US5900104 *||Jun 4, 1996||May 4, 1999||Boeing North American, Inc.||Plasma system for enhancing the surface of a material|
|U.S. Classification||148/269, 216/67, 216/77, 216/75, 216/76|
|Apr 27, 2001||FPAY||Fee payment|
Year of fee payment: 4
|Apr 28, 2005||FPAY||Fee payment|
Year of fee payment: 8
|May 4, 2009||REMI||Maintenance fee reminder mailed|
|Oct 28, 2009||LAPS||Lapse for failure to pay maintenance fees|