WO2003046524A1 - Single mode fiber optic evanescent wave refractometer and method of immunoassay measurement of a target component in a fluid - Google Patents

Single mode fiber optic evanescent wave refractometer and method of immunoassay measurement of a target component in a fluid Download PDF

Info

Publication number
WO2003046524A1
WO2003046524A1 PCT/US2001/043337 US0143337W WO03046524A1 WO 2003046524 A1 WO2003046524 A1 WO 2003046524A1 US 0143337 W US0143337 W US 0143337W WO 03046524 A1 WO03046524 A1 WO 03046524A1
Authority
WO
WIPO (PCT)
Prior art keywords
light
coupler
fiber optic
optical fiber
optic coupler
Prior art date
Application number
PCT/US2001/043337
Other languages
French (fr)
Inventor
Charles M. Adkins
David W. Gerdt
Martin C. Baruch
Original Assignee
Adkins Charles M
Gerdt David W
Baruch Martin C
Priority date (The priority date is an assumption and is not a legal conclusion. Google has not performed a legal analysis and makes no representation as to the accuracy of the date listed.)
Filing date
Publication date
Application filed by Adkins Charles M, Gerdt David W, Baruch Martin C filed Critical Adkins Charles M
Priority to PCT/US2001/043337 priority Critical patent/WO2003046524A1/en
Priority to AU2001297803A priority patent/AU2001297803A1/en
Publication of WO2003046524A1 publication Critical patent/WO2003046524A1/en

Links

Classifications

    • GPHYSICS
    • G01MEASURING; TESTING
    • G01NINVESTIGATING OR ANALYSING MATERIALS BY DETERMINING THEIR CHEMICAL OR PHYSICAL PROPERTIES
    • G01N21/00Investigating or analysing materials by the use of optical means, i.e. using sub-millimetre waves, infrared, visible or ultraviolet light
    • G01N21/75Systems in which material is subjected to a chemical reaction, the progress or the result of the reaction being investigated
    • G01N21/77Systems in which material is subjected to a chemical reaction, the progress or the result of the reaction being investigated by observing the effect on a chemical indicator
    • G01N21/7703Systems in which material is subjected to a chemical reaction, the progress or the result of the reaction being investigated by observing the effect on a chemical indicator using reagent-clad optical fibres or optical waveguides
    • GPHYSICS
    • G01MEASURING; TESTING
    • G01NINVESTIGATING OR ANALYSING MATERIALS BY DETERMINING THEIR CHEMICAL OR PHYSICAL PROPERTIES
    • G01N21/00Investigating or analysing materials by the use of optical means, i.e. using sub-millimetre waves, infrared, visible or ultraviolet light
    • G01N21/17Systems in which incident light is modified in accordance with the properties of the material investigated
    • G01N21/41Refractivity; Phase-affecting properties, e.g. optical path length
    • G01N21/45Refractivity; Phase-affecting properties, e.g. optical path length using interferometric methods; using Schlieren methods

Definitions

  • This invention is in the field of chemical and biological assay and is useful for measurement of variables which are addressable through sensitive measurements of the index of refraction.
  • Evanescent wave spectroscopy is not new. It is a variant of internal reflection spectroscopy and many configurations are thoroughly described in a text by N.J. Harrick. The concept works generally through the illumination of an optical interface which is in contact with a sample material; interaction with the sample occurs through evanescent wave sampling. Some configurations operate near the angle of total internal reflection and the sample index is tested either by measurement of the critical angle or by measurement of light loss as the solution index changes. Additional methods are provided through measurement of evanescent wave adsorption.
  • the light intensity is low and suitable sensitivity is obtained by multiple exposures to the sample interface, usually by geometric constructions which provide multiple
  • single mode fibers only support one propagating mode Therefore random interference is impossible and no modal redistribution occurs due to envnonmental factors.
  • Another significant advantage of single mode fibers is that more than 90% of the optical energy can be forced into the evanescent field and that field surrounds the entire space immediately
  • Interferometric approaches are usually the most sensitive available, however they require exceptional mechanical stability.
  • the interferomet ⁇ c technique suffers because the optical signal rotates due to biref ⁇ ngence in the bent fiber and path stability becomes a phenomenal problem.
  • the single mode fiber optic coupler sensor is also an interferometric device, of sorts However, the two legs of the interferometer (the two propagating supermodes) are both contained within the device itself Because of this, the device is self-referencing and the noise associated with path instability is completely avoided
  • Gerdt and Herr proposed a method for immunoassay using the single mode fiber optic coupler sensor in conjunction with a surface coating of specific monoclonal or polyclonal antibodies to detect small concentrations of target antigens
  • the invention relates broadly to a fiber optic sensor device, advantageously, a refractive index measurement device
  • a light emitting member transmits light pieferably coherent light, to a light splitter
  • the light splitter splits the light into a first portion that is transmitted to a first
  • the coupler preferably is formed from a plurality of single mode fiber optic fibers
  • a first output optical fiber member emerges from the first fiber optic coupler waist region
  • the light splitter is positioned to insert light into the first fiber optic coupler input optical fiber member
  • a reference fiber optic coupler includes an input optical fiber member and an optical fiber member having a waist region
  • the reference fiber optic coupler is enclosed in a potting medium stable reference of constant refractive index
  • a reference output optical fiber member emerges from the reference fiber optic coupler waist region
  • the first fiber optic coupler and the reference fiber optic coupler are single mode couplers
  • the light splitter member inserts a second portion of the split light into the reference fiber optic coupler input optical fiber member
  • a light measu ⁇ ng member is optically coupled to receive light emitted from the first output optical fiber member and the reference output optical fiber member
  • the light measu ⁇ ng member can be a light meter for measu ⁇ ng the magnitude of light
  • a sum difference device processes the measured light emitted from the first output optical fiber member and from the reference output optical fiber member whereby the value de ⁇ ved said measured light emitted from said first output optical fiber member is independent of va ⁇ ations in light from said light emitting member
  • the device of the present invention can be used for the immunoassay measurement of a target component Light output from two 01 more of the sample coupler optic fibers are
  • the presence or concentration of the target component is determined by measu ⁇ ng changes in the output of light from the two or more optic fibers of the sample coupler due to the specific binding of the target component to the first immunoassay component as compared to the light reference value
  • the step of measu ⁇ ng changes in the output light preferably comp ⁇ ses a plurality of measurements made over a predetermine time interval and dete ⁇ nining the rate of change of the light output
  • the step of compa ⁇ ng preferably includes companng the rate of change of the light output as an indication of the concentration of the target mate ⁇ al in the fluid
  • the present invention advantageously includes an immunoassay method for dete ⁇ mning a target analyte in a fluid sample
  • the method does not use labeled reagents and is based upon measu ⁇ ng changes in refractive index in an evanescent field surrounding a fiber optic coupler relative to light changes in a reference fiber optic coupler surrounded by a medium of stable refractive index
  • the method includes immobilizing an antibody or antigen capable of specifically binding to the target analyte on the fiber optic coupler and illuminating at least one of the plurality of optical fibers to provide the surrounding evanescent field with a first portion of light from a light splitter
  • a first refractive index of the surrounding evanescent field is obtained by measu ⁇ ng a first ratio of light output by the fiber optic coupler
  • the fluid sample is brought into contact with the target fibei optic coupler such that any target analyte in the fluid sample specifically binds to the immobilized antibody or antigen
  • a second refractive index of the surrounding field is obtained by measu ⁇ ng a second ratio of light output by the target fiber optic coupler
  • the reference coupler is illuminated with a second portion ot light trom the light splitter to dete ⁇ nine a illumination reference level by measuring light output trom said rereience coupler
  • FIG. 1 is a schematic illustration of the system of the present invention
  • Figure 2 is a graphic illustration of the va ⁇ ation in the coupling coefficient with elongation du ⁇ ng the fab ⁇ cation of the biconical fused tapered couplers
  • Figure 3 is a graphic illustration of the variation in the coupling coefficient vs solution
  • Figure 4 is a graphic illustration of the va ⁇ ation in differential retardance and sensitivity vs solution index of refraction for couplers drawn to different initial values in air
  • Figure 5 is a graphic compa ⁇ son of predicted values for coupling coefficient v. solution index of refraction and measured values for va ⁇ ous solutions
  • Figure 6 is a graph of measured value for sensitivity for coupler pulled to initial value of 0 500 in air and potted vs an identical coupler pulled to an initial value of 0 500 in air and unspotted,
  • Figure 7 are graphs of FFT's of calculated values for sinusoidal va ⁇ ation in coupling coefficient as the optical source wavelength is modulated
  • a single mode optical fiber is comp ⁇ sed of three concentnc components
  • the central component is called the core and is comp ⁇ sed ot a mate ⁇ al, usually quartz, with an index of refraction near 1 46
  • the core contains almost all of the propagating light and is sized just large enough to contain only one propagating mode, the fundamental
  • the core is surrounded by a concentnc region called the cladding
  • the index of refraction of the cladding is slightly depressed relative to that of the core so that a guiding interface exists between the two regions
  • the cladding is of sufficient size that the propagating mode in the coie is unaffected by
  • the quartz components of the fiber are packaged in a third layer of a plastic mate ⁇ al which provides a hemietic seal and protects the fiber du ⁇ ng handling. This layer is called the buffer
  • the fiber diameter is reduced from an initial value near 125 microns to about 15 microns
  • the o ⁇ ginal core diameter is reduced in proportion As the core is reduced, it can no longer contain the propagating mode and light spills into the surrounding cladding. After fabrication, almost all of the light resides in the original cladding
  • the original cladding becomes the new core, and whatever surrounds the fused region, the sample solution, becomes the new cladding. As a result, the division of power between the
  • Bures, et. al. calculate the coupling ratio in terms of: the wave number
  • V kr ⁇ n — 'I , ., I
  • e is the wavelength of the illumination
  • r is the ratio of core
  • n cme and n clad ⁇ n are the indices of refraction of the core
  • cladding respectively designates a partial denvative, and K o and K are modified Bessel
  • the figuie demonstrates that the correlation between coupling ratio and solution index is not unique
  • a means is required to quantitatively define a unique value of index relative to a single measurement of the coupling
  • Figure 4a illustrates the va ⁇ ation of the differential retardance, e, vs the solution index for the same two couplers pulled to initial values of the coupling ratio, 0 500 and 1 00
  • the measured function is monotonic, however, its measured value must be de ⁇ ved from the measurement of the coupling ratio, which is not Since the retardance contains many cycles (N*2 ⁇ ) it is still impossible to uniquely determine the index from the measured value
  • Figure 4b illustrates the first partial de ⁇ vative of retardance relative to wavelength at constant index
  • This curve relates the signal change (retardance) that would result from changes in wavelength at constant values of solution index
  • the amount of change in signal (retardance) from the two couplers would depend on the index of refraction in each If one of the couplers was immersed in a standard mate ⁇ al of known index (the reference), the index of unknown sample could be uniquely and quantitatively dete ⁇ nined by the latio between the change in signal amplitude of the unknown and the change in signal amplitude of the reference
  • This ratio is uniquely defined for all values of index below the index of retraction of the coupler itself At this value, dependent on the mate ⁇ al in the optical fiber, the light becomes ungmded and escapes Measurements are not possible above this value
  • the coupling ratio, a is the fraction of the total power in the coupler coupled into channel 2
  • the coupling ratio, a , and the retardance, e can be de ⁇ ved from measurements of the channel power levels, and calculated from the difference between the two channels, A , divided by the sum of the two channels, O
  • a preferred embodiment of the evanescent wave refractometer system is schematically desc ⁇ bed in Figure 1 It is comp ⁇ sed of a pigtailed optical source (laser or light emitting diode) d ⁇ ven by a controller, a thermoelect ⁇ c (Peltier) cooler and its the ⁇ noelect ⁇ c controller, a splitter (a 1 x N "tree" coupler with approximately equal outputs), a coupler used to measure the sample characte ⁇ stics, a potted coupler used as a stable reference, detectors and transimpedance amplifiers for each channel of optical output and sum/difference processing for the sample and reference channels.
  • An oscillator that also provides a refeience signal for the dual channel Phase Sensitive Detector modulates the source controller
  • a plotter, logger, scope, or other display apparatus is used to capture the measurement output.
  • Instantaneous values of retardance were calculated and the vanation in amplitude at the fundamental modulation frequency was de ⁇ ved from it using the Fast Four ⁇ er Transform method
  • the ratio of signal amplitudes for that measurement is plotted on Figure 6 to illustrate the accuracy of the method
  • the ratio of modulation signal amplitudes for the sample and reference predict the index of refraction for the sample without the uncertainty produced by using the coupling coefficient by itself.
  • a single mode fiber optic system has been constructed for quantitative measurement of chemical and biological reaction va ⁇ ables which are available through direct measurement of the solution index of refraction
  • Such vanables include measurement of reaction extent and reaction kinetics through measurement of the solution index of refraction which is dependent on concentrations of the products and reactants Further, through application of selected components to the sensing surface, concentrations of specific target components can be quantitatively measured with the extremely high sensitivity required for use in immunoassay
  • the system is based on the fundamental properties of a biconical, fused tapered coupler as desc ⁇ bed by Gerdt As a pair of single mode optical fibers are fused and drawn, optical power in the first fiber of the pair will couple into the second fiber of the pair This division of power in the fibers is reflected in the coupling ratio (1 e the coupled power as a percentage of the total power in the pair of fibers )
  • the coupling ratio is dependent on the degree of elongation in the fusion zone, the separation of the fiber cores, the wavelength of the illumination, and the index of refraction in the environment surrounding the fused and elongated portion of the fiber (i e the w ist) If a coupler is diawn to and Initial Value (IV) of the coupling ratio in air and fixtured in a stable housing, any further change in power division is a function ot the wavelength and the index of lefraction in the sensing region
  • the p ⁇ ncipal noise source in the system is the optical source, typically a solid state laser or light emitting diode
  • the noise is low frequency and demonstrates a 1/f characte ⁇ stic which is well documented in the literature
  • a feature of the noise is that it contains components in both the amplitude domain (intensity noise) and n the frequency domain (frequency noise)
  • the evanescent wave sensor as described by Gerdt, et. al. provides means to remove the intensity noise component through application of a well known difference/sum technique to the differential outputs of the sensor. It, however, amplifies the frequency noise component which appears in the measurement of the coupling ratio which the fundamental output of the device.
  • the proposed system provides additional means to remove the frequency noise component in the output by comparison of the measured coupling ratio of the sample sensor with that of a stable reference, simultaneously illuminated by the optical source.
  • the stable reference is an additional coupler which has been potted in a material of known index. Its output signal, also sampled through the same difference/sum technique, varies only with the wavelength of the source and allows the frequency noise component to be subtracted from the measurement, thus eliminating optical system noise components to the limits of the detection apparatus.
  • the output from the evanescent wave sensor as described by Gerdt, et, al. is measured in te ⁇ us of the coupling ratio. This ratio is transcendental and repeats the same value at multiple values of the sample solution index of refraction. Thus the measurement of a single value of the coupling ratio cannot be uniquely correlated to a value of solution index if the measurement is not continuous (e.g. if there is a rapid change or if the measurement is lost du ⁇ ng inte ⁇ nediate
  • the inclusion of the stable reference in the measurement system allows quantitative evaluation of the sample index of refraction as a simple ratio of the variation in the signal from the sample sensor vs. the simultaneous signal variation from the stable reference as the source wavelength is changed.
  • the frequency of the optical source is modulated (e.g. by intensity modulation of the laser or light emitting diode) then and a c technique of measurement is obtained by which the index of refraction in the sample can be continuously and unambiguously measured as the ratio of signal levels in the sample channels relative to the signal levels in the stable reference.
  • the a/c technique allows the use of the homodyne detection scheme which moves the sampling measurement out of the high noise environment at low frequencies and provides means for substantial signal / noise improvement through application of phase sensitive demodulation to the much larger signal levels which become available.

Abstract

The invention relates broadly to a fiber optic sensor device, advantageously, a refractive index measurement device. A light emitting member transmits light, preferably coherent light, to a light splitter. The light splitter splits the light into a first portion that is transmitted to a first fiber optic coupler having an input optical fiber member and an optical fiber member having a waist region. A first output optical fiber member emerges from the first fiber optic coupler waist region. The light splitter is positioned to insert light into the first fiber optic coupler input optical fiber member. A reference fiber optic coupler includes an input optical fiber member and an optical fiber member having a waist region. The reference fiber optic coupler is enclosed in a potting medium stable reference of constant refractive index. A reference output optical fiber member emerges from the reference fiber optic coupler waist region. The light splitter member inserts a second portion of the split light into the reference fiber optic coupler input optical fiber member. A sum difference device processes the measured light emitted from the first output optical fiber member and from the reference output optical fiber member whereby the value derived said measured light emitted from said first output optical fiber member is independent of variations in light from said light emitting member.

Description

SINGLE MODE FIBER OPTIC EVANESCENT WAVE REFRACTOMETER AND METHOD OF IMMMUNOASSAY MEASUREMENT OF A TARGET COMPONENT IN A FLUID
Field of the Invention
This invention is in the field of chemical and biological assay and is useful for measurement of variables which are addressable through sensitive measurements of the index of refraction. Brief Description of the Prior Art
Evanescent wave spectroscopy is not new. It is a variant of internal reflection spectroscopy and many configurations are thoroughly described in a text by N.J. Harrick. The concept works generally through the illumination of an optical interface which is in contact with a sample material; interaction with the sample occurs through evanescent wave sampling. Some configurations operate near the angle of total internal reflection and the sample index is tested either by measurement of the critical angle or by measurement of light loss as the solution index changes. Additional methods are provided through measurement of evanescent wave adsorption.
In bulk optical systems, the light intensity is low and suitable sensitivity is obtained by multiple exposures to the sample interface, usually by geometric constructions which provide multiple
reflections.
Some multimode fiber optic variants to the theme are described in Harrick's book. They operate on the same principal as the bulk optic devices with extended exposure to the fiber/ sample solution interface provided by the multibounce propagation method in the multimode fiber Sensing is via intensity vaπation at the output
Three construction vanants, based on multimode optical fibers, have been proposed in the literature as candidates for immunoassay In the first, the fiber cladding is stripped to expose the core, and antigens, labeled with fluorophores, are attached to the fiber surface The fluorophores are excited by the evanescent field and can be detected through reduction in the light level of by collection of the fluorescence A second type of fiber optic immunoassay sensor uses a coating deposited on the fiber tip that can be illuminated by an optical pulse, which in turn induces fluorescence which is reflected back up the fiber and detected A third type of fiber optic sensor for immunoassay involves a stπpped fiber core that has antibodies and antigens attached to the core/solution interface This sensor is used as one leg of a fiber optic Mach-Zender interferometer The binding of molecules to the surface duπng attachment of either antibody of antigen suffices to locally change the index of refraction at the core/solution interface This changes the phase velocity of the light on one leg of the device and interference fringes are observed at its output
Still other configurations of immuno ensors have been described such as surface plasmon
resonance iinmunosensors, and grating couplers used as integrated optical chemical sensors These and others are discussed in the book edited by Wolfbeis Velander and Murphy at Virginia Tech have proposed a fiber optic technique for an immunoassay that uses a grating superimposed on the fiber to scatter light into the cladding where it can sample the cladding/air interface An affinity aerogel coating is used to collect and concentrate target antigens which are measured through the absorption spectrum of the returned light Still more methods based on evanescent field absorption in optical waveguides are described by G. Stewart.
Conventional evanescent wave spectrometry has been thoroughly researched and is well known in the literature. The techniques involved are also used in fiber optic sensing. The processes usually rely on absorption processes in regions of waveguides where the evanescent field penetrates the guide. The guides are arranged so that as many reflections as possible illuminate the sample interface. Even so, the places where ray optics allows interaction between the optical species and the sample are comparatively few and the illumination is weak compared to the single mode fiber optic coupler approach.
In large multimode optical fibers, a relatively large number, possibly hundreds, of spatial modes are supported. The modes can and do interfere with each other leading to extensive noise generation at the point of detection (i.e speckle). The detector can't distinguish between intensity vaπations due to the sample and intensity variations that occur due to random inference between the propagating optical modes
In contrast, single mode fibers only support one propagating mode Therefore random interference is impossible and no modal redistribution occurs due to envnonmental factors.
Another significant advantage of single mode fibers is that more than 90% of the optical energy can be forced into the evanescent field and that field surrounds the entire space immediately
surrounding the core.
Interferometric approaches are usually the most sensitive available, however they require exceptional mechanical stability. In the fiber optic case, the interferometπc technique suffers because the optical signal rotates due to birefπngence in the bent fiber and path stability becomes a phenomenal problem. The single mode fiber optic coupler sensor is also an interferometric device, of sorts However, the two legs of the interferometer (the two propagating supermodes) are both contained within the device itself Because of this, the device is self-referencing and the noise associated with path instability is completely avoided
The technique used by Veander and Murphy requires a spec rophotoraeter to read Even m mi nia ture con figurat ion , this is hardl y a "point of care" device use ful in f ield envi ronment s
In a pπor patent, Gerdt and Herr correctly descπbed the significant benefits of the single mode fiber optic coupler sensor relative to current and pπor art The disclosure of the pπor patent, United States Patent 5,494,798, Gerdt and Herr, February 27, 1996, is incorporated by reference herein, as though recited in full To summanze, the benefits include 1 ) the high illumination levels exposed to the sample interface and the high sensitivity which result, 2) the single mode field exposed to the sample and the low noise which results with the elimination of other interfenng modal noise components in the measured signal, 3) a measurement which uses only the vaπation in propagation constant to sense the measurement and is inherently separable from the multitude of intensity noise sources which encumber the measurement, 4) a differential signal output which allows normalization of the measurement and isolation from other noise sources
In their patent, Gerdt and Herr proposed a method for immunoassay using the single mode fiber optic coupler sensor in conjunction with a surface coating of specific monoclonal or polyclonal antibodies to detect small concentrations of target antigens
There are three significant weaknesses in the method proposed which limit the ultimate sensitivity of the device and its use for quantitative measurement The first occurs because the optical source produces noise components in both intensity and frequency In their proposed method, the intensity noise is removed by conventional difference/sum signal processing of the optical output Although the intensity noise components are removed by the method, the frequency noise components are enhanced along with the real signal No method was provided to address this noise component that becomes significant at higher values of solution index of refraction The second limitation occurs because the measured power splitting ratio is transcendental Single measurements of the splitting ratio are not unique and no method is provided to quantitatively assess the solution index of refraction The third limitation occurs because the gain and thus the noise figure in the initial detection stage is limited by the need to accept the full optical signal without clipping at large values ot the coupling ratio which occurs peπodically as the solution index is changed As a result, small signal changes must be measured on a very large background The signal, thus measured, is very small and system sensitivity suffers as the result The proposed system, as illustrated in Figure L, includes a reference channel that addresses these shortcomings of the proposed method of the pπor art
Summary of the Tnvention The invention relates broadly to a fiber optic sensor device, advantageously, a refractive index measurement device A light emitting member transmits light pieferably coherent light, to a light splitter The light splitter splits the light into a first portion that is transmitted to a first
fiber optic coupler having an input optical fiber member and an optical fiber member having a waist region The coupler preferably is formed from a plurality of single mode fiber optic fibers A first output optical fiber member emerges from the first fiber optic coupler waist region The light splitter is positioned to insert light into the first fiber optic coupler input optical fiber member A reference fiber optic coupler includes an input optical fiber member and an optical fiber member having a waist region The reference fiber optic coupler is enclosed in a potting medium stable reference of constant refractive index A reference output optical fiber member emerges from the reference fiber optic coupler waist region The first fiber optic coupler and the reference fiber optic coupler are single mode couplers
The light splitter member inserts a second portion of the split light into the reference fiber optic coupler input optical fiber member
A light measuπng member is optically coupled to receive light emitted from the first output optical fiber member and the reference output optical fiber member The light measuπng member can be a light meter for measuπng the magnitude of light
A sum difference device processes the measured light emitted from the first output optical fiber member and from the reference output optical fiber member whereby the value deπved said measured light emitted from said first output optical fiber member is independent of vaπations in light from said light emitting member
The device of the present invention can be used for the immunoassay measurement of a target component Light output from two 01 more of the sample coupler optic fibers are
measured betore and after surrounding the coupler with the target component Light is measured from the reference coupler to establish a light reference value The presence or concentration of the target component is determined by measuπng changes in the output of light from the two or more optic fibers of the sample coupler due to the specific binding of the target component to the first immunoassay component as compared to the light reference value The step of measuπng changes in the output light preferably compπses a plurality of measurements made over a predetermine time interval and deteπnining the rate of change of the light output The step of compaπng preferably includes companng the rate of change of the light output as an indication of the concentration of the target mateπal in the fluid
The present invention advantageously includes an immunoassay method for deteπmning a target analyte in a fluid sample The method does not use labeled reagents and is based upon measuπng changes in refractive index in an evanescent field surrounding a fiber optic coupler relative to light changes in a reference fiber optic coupler surrounded by a medium of stable refractive index The method includes immobilizing an antibody or antigen capable of specifically binding to the target analyte on the fiber optic coupler and illuminating at least one of the plurality of optical fibers to provide the surrounding evanescent field with a first portion of light from a light splitter
A first refractive index of the surrounding evanescent field is obtained by measuπng a first ratio of light output by the fiber optic coupler The fluid sample is brought into contact with the target fibei optic coupler such that any target analyte in the fluid sample specifically binds to the immobilized antibody or antigen A second refractive index of the surrounding field is obtained by measuπng a second ratio of light output by the target fiber optic coupler
The reference coupler is illuminated with a second portion ot light trom the light splitter to deteπnine a illumination reference level by measuring light output trom said rereience coupler
Brief Description of the Drawings
Figure 1 is a schematic illustration of the system of the present invention,
Figure 2 is a graphic illustration of the vaπation in the coupling coefficient with elongation duπng the fabπcation of the biconical fused tapered couplers,
Figure 3 is a graphic illustration of the variation in the coupling coefficient vs solution
index of refraction for biconical fused taper couplers drawn to different initial values in air, Figure 4 is a graphic illustration of the vaπation in differential retardance and sensitivity vs solution index of refraction for couplers drawn to different initial values in air,
Figure 5 is a graphic compaπson of predicted values for coupling coefficient v. solution index of refraction and measured values for vaπous solutions,
Figure 6 is a graph of measured value for sensitivity for coupler pulled to initial value of 0 500 in air and potted vs an identical coupler pulled to an initial value of 0 500 in air and unspotted,
Figure 7 are graphs of FFT's of calculated values for sinusoidal vaπation in coupling coefficient as the optical source wavelength is modulated
Detailed Description of the Preferred Embodiments of the Invention
A single mode optical fiber is compπsed of three concentnc components The central component is called the core and is compπsed ot a mateπal, usually quartz, with an index of refraction near 1 46 The core contains almost all of the propagating light and is sized just large enough to contain only one propagating mode, the fundamental The core is surrounded by a concentnc region called the cladding The index of refraction of the cladding is slightly depressed relative to that of the core so that a guiding interface exists between the two regions The cladding is of sufficient size that the propagating mode in the coie is unaffected by
vaπations in the environment which might surround the fiber Quartz is susceptible to breakage if it is exposed to moisture, therefore the quartz components of the fiber are packaged in a third layer of a plastic mateπal which provides a hemietic seal and protects the fiber duπng handling. This layer is called the buffer
If the plastic buffer is removed and two fibers are placed adjacent to each other in a furnace of flame, they will fuse When the heated and fused fibers are gently pulled, they will elongate resulting in a reduction of both the fiber diameter and separation between the two cores As this process continues, optical power in one of the fibers will begin to couple into the second fiber As the fibers are pulled still further, the power will transfer completely to the second fiber and then begin to transfer back to the first fiber again, Figure 2 This process will continue indefinitely, the light alternately transferπng from one fiber to the other, until the fibers become too small and break
Light, propagating in the cores of the two adjacent fibers, is descπbed by the wave equation, a physical interpretation of Maxwell's equations applying to electromagnetic phenomena The solution for this model is degenerate and results in two wave functions, one of which is symmetπc and the other anti-symmetric relative to the geometπc center of the pair ot fibers These wave functions are called the two "super modes" The propagating light at any point in the fibers is described by the vector sum of the two super modes and the optical power in each of the fibers is descπbed by the square of their sum The super modes extend beyond the fiber surface and into the surrounding mateπal, however one of the modes extends a little further than the other and as a result, they propagate at different speeds A phase difference, E, is accumulated between the super modes as they propagate over the fused length of the coupler That phase difference depends on the length ot the fused region, the wavelength ot the
illumination, and index of refraction of the core and cladding The division of power between the two fibers is descπbed by the coupling ratio, a , where
a = Sin2 (E)
In the fused region of the coupler, the fiber diameter is reduced from an initial value near 125 microns to about 15 microns The oπginal core diameter is reduced in proportion As the core is reduced, it can no longer contain the propagating mode and light spills into the surrounding cladding. After fabrication, almost all of the light resides in the original cladding
material. The original cladding becomes the new core, and whatever surrounds the fused region, the sample solution, becomes the new cladding. As a result, the division of power between the
two fibers becomes a strong function of the index of refraction in the small volume surrounding the fiber surfaces.
A mathematical model, which approximately descπbes the coupling ratio in terms of the
fused length, the wavelength of the illumination, and the index of refraction of the core and
cladding has been derived and published by J. Bures, S. Lacroix, and J. LaPieπe, ( 1983). In their work, Bures, et. al. calculate the coupling ratio in terms of: the wave number,
2π k = λ the profile height parameter,
Figure imgf000011_0001
the waveguide parameter.
V = kr\n — 'I , ., I
the core parameter,
-{!+<!)
U = 2.405e
and the cladding parameter,
W = (v 2 - U 2 )ϊ then the coupling coefficient can be calculated
Figure imgf000012_0001
and the differential phase, calculated over the interval where Cpp is non zero, is then
the resulting coupling ratio is a = Sιn2(θ)
and the sensitivity is then defined as
Sensitivity = — n = constant dλ
In the preceding deπvation, e is the wavelength of the illumination, r is the ratio of core
separation to the core radius, ncme and ncladώn are the indices of refraction of the core and
cladding respectively designates a partial denvative, and Ko and K are modified Bessel
functions of the second kind
Figure 3, illustrates the vaπation of the coupling ratio, a , with solution index for couplers pulled to a = 0 500 and 1 00 respectively, in air n = I 000 The figuie demonstrates that the correlation between coupling ratio and solution index is not unique A means is required to quantitatively define a unique value of index relative to a single measurement of the coupling
ratio
Figure 4a, illustrates the vaπation of the differential retardance, e, vs the solution index for the same two couplers pulled to initial values of the coupling ratio, 0 500 and 1 00 Here, the measured function is monotonic, however, its measured value must be deπved from the measurement of the coupling ratio, which is not Since the retardance contains many cycles (N*2ό) it is still impossible to uniquely determine the index from the measured value
Figure 4b, illustrates the first partial deπvative of retardance relative to wavelength at constant index This curve relates the signal change (retardance) that would result from changes in wavelength at constant values of solution index If two couplers were simultaneously illuminated from the same source, the amount of change in signal (retardance) from the two couplers would depend on the index of refraction in each If one of the couplers was immersed in a standard mateπal of known index (the reference), the index of unknown sample could be uniquely and quantitatively deteπnined by the latio between the change in signal amplitude of the unknown and the change in signal amplitude of the reference This ratio is uniquely defined for all values of index below the index of retraction of the coupler itself At this value, dependent on the mateπal in the optical fiber, the light becomes ungmded and escapes Measurements are not possible above this value
Measurements, deπved from the evanescent wave refractometer must be made from observation ot the optical power in each of the fiber outputs and from calculations based on those obser ations As has already been discussed, the total optical power in each coupler, b. is
divided between its two output channels Ii and Remembeπng that the coupling ratio, a , is the fraction of the total power in the coupler coupled into channel 2
a = Sιn2(θ)
then the power in the channels is
/, = /0(l -Λιι2 (/9))
and I2 = I0Sιn2 {θ) The coupling ratio, a , and the retardance, e , can be deπved from measurements of the channel power levels, and calculated from the difference between the two channels, A , divided by the sum of the two channels, O
Δ. = tn1{θ))- I0(l - Sιn1{θ)) Σ n2(θ))+ I0(l - Sιn 2(θ))
from which it can be shown that the coupling ratio
a = 0 5| 1 +
and that
Figure imgf000014_0001
It is apparent that measurements of the coupling ratio of the retardance based on A/O are normalized to the instantaneous optical power and are, therefore immune to intensity noise in the source From the previous deπvation, however, it is also apparent that the measured values are still dependent on wavelength and that another means is required to remove that noise source Inclusion of the second optical channel, the reference, potted in a mateπal of constant index, provides that function
Based on this model, predictions of the \ aπation in coupling ratio vs solution index of refraction for a coupler pulled to an initial value of a = 0 5 in air, n = I 000 is plotted in Figure 5 and the ratio of signals obtained from a wavelength modulated source (relative sensitivity) for a
coupler in air and a coupler in solutions of higher index is plotted as Figure 6
A preferred embodiment of the evanescent wave refractometer system is schematically descπbed in Figure 1 It is compπsed of a pigtailed optical source (laser or light emitting diode) dπven by a controller, a thermoelectπc (Peltier) cooler and its theπnoelectπc controller, a splitter (a 1 x N "tree" coupler with approximately equal outputs), a coupler used to measure the sample characteπstics, a potted coupler used as a stable reference, detectors and transimpedance amplifiers for each channel of optical output and sum/difference processing for the sample and reference channels. An oscillator that also provides a refeience signal for the dual channel Phase Sensitive Detector modulates the source controller A plotter, logger, scope, or other display apparatus is used to capture the measurement output.
A less complicated version of the system is currently in use In this system, output from the transimpedance amplifiers on each of the optical channels are independently collected by the data logger and data analysis is performed "off line" by computer based analysis packages Using the lesser embodiment, a test system was constructed using a sample coupler drawn to an initial value of a = 0 5 in air and a stable reference whose initial value of a = 0 5 in GE RTV12, n = I 420, at the optical wavelength of 1 300 im Data was collected at d c for the coupling coefficient obtained using several mateπals of known index These measurements are plotted on Figure 5 to illustrate the agreement obtained from the uncorrected measurement The value obtained using Hexane, n = 1 3745, shows significant error because Hexane rapidly attacks the tygon tubing used to construct the test apparatus
The optical source was modulated at I Hz and the channel output data on Figure 7 was collected for a sample coupler in air, n = I 000, and a reference coupler potted in GE RTVI 2, n = 1 402 Instantaneous values of retardance were calculated and the vanation in amplitude at the fundamental modulation frequency was deπved from it using the Fast Fourπer Transform method The ratio of signal amplitudes for that measurement is plotted on Figure 6 to illustrate the accuracy of the method The ratio of modulation signal amplitudes for the sample and reference predict the index of refraction for the sample without the uncertainty produced by using the coupling coefficient by itself.
OVERVIEW
A single mode fiber optic system has been constructed for quantitative measurement of chemical and biological reaction vaπables which are available through direct measurement of the solution index of refraction Such vanables include measurement of reaction extent and reaction kinetics through measurement of the solution index of refraction which is dependent on concentrations of the products and reactants Further, through application of selected components to the sensing surface, concentrations of specific target components can be quantitatively measured with the extremely high sensitivity required for use in immunoassay
The system is based on the fundamental properties of a biconical, fused tapered coupler as descπbed by Gerdt As a pair of single mode optical fibers are fused and drawn, optical power in the first fiber of the pair will couple into the second fiber of the pair This division of power in the fibers is reflected in the coupling ratio (1 e the coupled power as a percentage of the total power in the pair of fibers ) The coupling ratio is dependent on the degree of elongation in the fusion zone, the separation of the fiber cores, the wavelength of the illumination, and the index of refraction in the environment surrounding the fused and elongated portion of the fiber (i e the w ist) If a coupler is diawn to and Initial Value (IV) of the coupling ratio in air and fixtured in a stable housing, any further change in power division is a function ot the wavelength and the index of lefraction in the sensing region
Sensitivity and repeatability of the system are limited by system noise The pπncipal noise source in the system is the optical source, typically a solid state laser or light emitting diode The noise is low frequency and demonstrates a 1/f characteπstic which is well documented in the literature A feature of the noise is that it contains components in both the amplitude domain (intensity noise) and n the frequency domain (frequency noise) The evanescent wave sensor as described by Gerdt, et. al. provides means to remove the intensity noise component through application of a well known difference/sum technique to the differential outputs of the sensor. It, however, amplifies the frequency noise component which appears in the measurement of the coupling ratio which the fundamental output of the device. The proposed system provides additional means to remove the frequency noise component in the output by comparison of the measured coupling ratio of the sample sensor with that of a stable reference, simultaneously illuminated by the optical source. The stable reference is an additional coupler which has been potted in a material of known index. Its output signal, also sampled through the same difference/sum technique, varies only with the wavelength of the source and allows the frequency noise component to be subtracted from the measurement, thus eliminating optical system noise components to the limits of the detection apparatus.
The output from the evanescent wave sensor as described by Gerdt, et, al. is measured in teπus of the coupling ratio. This ratio is transcendental and repeats the same value at multiple values of the sample solution index of refraction. Thus the measurement of a single value of the coupling ratio cannot be uniquely correlated to a value of solution index if the measurement is not continuous (e.g. if there is a rapid change or if the measurement is lost duπng inteπnediate
steps in a chemical process). The inclusion of the stable reference in the measurement system allows quantitative evaluation of the sample index of refraction as a simple ratio of the variation in the signal from the sample sensor vs. the simultaneous signal variation from the stable reference as the source wavelength is changed.
If the frequency of the optical source is modulated (e.g. by intensity modulation of the laser or light emitting diode) then and a c technique of measurement is obtained by which the index of refraction in the sample can be continuously and unambiguously measured as the ratio of signal levels in the sample channels relative to the signal levels in the stable reference. Additionally, the a/c technique allows the use of the homodyne detection scheme which moves the sampling measurement out of the high noise environment at low frequencies and provides means for substantial signal / noise improvement through application of phase sensitive demodulation to the much larger signal levels which become available.

Claims

What is claimed is
1 A fiber optic sensor compπsing a light emitting member, a light splitter membet, said light emitting member being positioned to insert light into said light splitter member, a first fiber optic coupler having an input optical fiber member and an optical fiber member having a waist region, a first output optical fiber member emerging from said first fiber optic coupler waist region, said light splitter member being positioned to insert light into said first fiber optic coupler input optical fiber member, a reference fiber optic coupler having an input optical fiber member and an optical fiber member having a waist region, said reference fiber optic coupler being enclosed in a potting medium, a reference output optical fiber member emerging from said reference fiber optic coupler waist region, said light splitter member being positioned to insert light into said reference fiber optic coupler input optical fiber member.
a light measuπng member optically coupled to receive light emitted from said first output optical fiber member and said reference output optical fiber member, and
sum difference means for processing the measured light emitted from said first output optical fiber member and from said reference output optical fiber member whereby the value deπved said measured light emitted from said first output optical fiber member is independent of vaπations in light from said light emitting member
2 The fiber optic sensor in accordance with claim I wherein said potting medium is a stable reference of constant refractive index
3 The fiber optic sensor in accordance with claim I wherein said first fiber optic coupler and said reference fiber optic coupler are single mode couplers
4 The fiber optic sensor in accordance with claim 3, wherein said fiber optic coupler and said reference fiber optic coupler are each formed from a plurality of single mode fiber optic fibers
5 The fiber optic sensor in accordance with claim f wheiein said light inserted into said light splitter membet is coherent light
6 The fiber optic sensor in accordance with claim I wherein said light measuπng member is a light meter for measuπng the magnitude of light
7 The fiber optic sensor in accoidance with claim I wherein said potting medium is a stable reference ot constant refractive index,
said first fiber optic coupler and said reference fiber optic coupler are single mode couplers, and each of fiber optic coupler and said reference fiber optic coupler are each formed from a plurality of single mode fiber optic fibers, said light inserted into said light splitter member is coherent light, and said light measuπng member is a light meter for measuπng the magnitude of light
8 A refractive index measurement device compπsing in combination a sample fiber optic coupler having a sample fusion joint, a reference fiber optic coupler having a reference fusion joint, a light splitter, a light input member position to input light into said light splitter, said light splitter inputting a first predetermined portion of into said sample fiber optic coupler, whereby an evanescent field is produced surrounding said fusion joint, and a second predetermined portion of into said reference fiber optic coupler, a light detector member for detecting light output from said sample fiber optic coupler and from said reference fiber optic coupler and from said reference fiber optic coupler, a difference determination member for processing the measured light emitted from said first output optical fiber member and from said reference output optical fiber member whereby the value deπved trom said measured light emitted from said first output optical fiber member is independent of vaπations in light trom said light emitting member
9 The refractive index measurement device in accordance with claim 8, wherein said fusion joints are single mode couplei s
10 The refractive index measurement device in accordance with claim 9, wherein said coupler
fusion joints are formed from a plurality of single mode fiber optic fibers
1 1 The refractive index measurement device in accordance with claim 8, wherein said reference coupler is potted in a stable reference medium of constant refractive index
12. The refractive index measurement device in accordance with claim 8. said light inserted into said light splitter member is coherent light.
13. The refractive index measurement device in accordance with claim 8, wherein said light detector member is a light meter for measuring the magnitude of light.
14. A method of immunoassay measurement of a target component comprising the steps of: forming a sample coupler fusion joint from a plurality of single mode fiber optic fibers; forming a reference coupler fusion joint from at least one single mode fiber optic fiber; coating the fusion joint of said sample coupler with a first immunoassay component capable of specifically binding to the target component; surrounding the coated fusion joint of the single mode fiber optic coupler with the target component; inserting light into a light splitter, transmitting light from a first split portion of light from said light splitter into one of said
sample coupler optic fibers after coating the fusion joint;
transmitting light from a second split portion of light from said light splitter into said reference coupler optic at least one optic fiber;
measuring light output from two or more of the sample coupler optic fibers before and after surrounding the fusion joint with the target component; measuring light from one or more of said reference coupler at least one optic fiber and
establishing a light reference value; determining the presence or concentration of the target component by measuπng changes in the output of light from said two or more optic fibers due to the specific binding of the target component to the first immunoassay component as compared to said light reference value
15 A method of assay measurement of a target component a fluid, using a device having a target single mode fiber optic coupler, said coupler having a fusion joint of at least two single mode optical fibers, a light sphttei, a reference single mode fiber optic coupler, said coupler having a fusion joint of at least one single mode optical fiber, said fusion joint being in a medium of stable index of refraction, compπsing the steps of unrounding the fusion joint of said target optic coupler with the target component, inserting light said light splitter, inserting light from said light splitter into one of said target coupler optical fibers, inserting light from said light splitter into said reference coupler at least one optical fiber, measuring and summing the output of light trom two of more of the target coupler optical
fibers and tiom said reference couplet at least one optical fibei, before and after suirounding the target coupler with the target component, and
deteπmning the presence or concentration of the target component in the fluid by compaπng changes in the light output levels of said two or more optical fibers due to the target component relative to said reference coupler light output levels 16 The method of measurement in accordance with claim 15 wherein said step of measuπng and summing compπses a plurality of measurements made over a predetermine time interval and further determining rate of change of the light output and said step of compaπng compπses compaπng the rate of change of the light output as an indication of the concentration of the target mateπal in the fluid
17 An immunoassay method for determining a target analyte in a fluid sample, which method does not use labeled reagents and is based upon measuπng changes in refractive index in an evanescent field surrounding a fiber optic coupler, said coupler having a plurality of optical fibers which are first coupled and then drawn to a single mode diameter, comprising immobilizing an antibody or antigen capable of specifically binding to the target analyte on the fiber optic coupler, illuminating at least one of the plurality of optical fibers to provide the suπounding evanescent field with a first portion of light from a light splitter, obtaining a first retractive index of the surrounding evanescent field by measuπng a first ratio ot light output by the fiber optic coupler, contacting the fluid sample to the fiber optic coupler such that any target analyte in the fluid sample specifically binds to the immobilized antibody or antigen, obtaining a second refractive index of the surrounding field by measuπng a second ratio of light output by the target fiber optic coupler, illuminating at least one optical fibers of a reference coupler with a second portion of light from a light splitter, said reference coupler having at least one optical fiber that is drawn to a single mode diameter, said reference coupler being within a medium of stable refractive index, thereby determining a illumination reference level by measuπng light output from said reference coupler
PCT/US2001/043337 2001-11-21 2001-11-21 Single mode fiber optic evanescent wave refractometer and method of immunoassay measurement of a target component in a fluid WO2003046524A1 (en)

Priority Applications (2)

Application Number Priority Date Filing Date Title
PCT/US2001/043337 WO2003046524A1 (en) 2001-11-21 2001-11-21 Single mode fiber optic evanescent wave refractometer and method of immunoassay measurement of a target component in a fluid
AU2001297803A AU2001297803A1 (en) 2001-11-21 2001-11-21 Single mode fiber optic evanescent wave refractometer and method of immunoassay measurement of a target component in a fluid

Applications Claiming Priority (1)

Application Number Priority Date Filing Date Title
PCT/US2001/043337 WO2003046524A1 (en) 2001-11-21 2001-11-21 Single mode fiber optic evanescent wave refractometer and method of immunoassay measurement of a target component in a fluid

Publications (1)

Publication Number Publication Date
WO2003046524A1 true WO2003046524A1 (en) 2003-06-05

Family

ID=21742995

Family Applications (1)

Application Number Title Priority Date Filing Date
PCT/US2001/043337 WO2003046524A1 (en) 2001-11-21 2001-11-21 Single mode fiber optic evanescent wave refractometer and method of immunoassay measurement of a target component in a fluid

Country Status (2)

Country Link
AU (1) AU2001297803A1 (en)
WO (1) WO2003046524A1 (en)

Citations (3)

* Cited by examiner, † Cited by third party
Publication number Priority date Publication date Assignee Title
US4703175A (en) * 1985-08-19 1987-10-27 Tacan Corporation Fiber-optic sensor with two different wavelengths of light traveling together through the sensor head
US5173747A (en) * 1990-09-20 1992-12-22 Battelle Memorial Institute Integrated optical directional-coupling refractometer apparatus
US5494798A (en) * 1993-12-09 1996-02-27 Gerdt; David W. Fiber optic evanscent wave sensor for immunoassay

Patent Citations (3)

* Cited by examiner, † Cited by third party
Publication number Priority date Publication date Assignee Title
US4703175A (en) * 1985-08-19 1987-10-27 Tacan Corporation Fiber-optic sensor with two different wavelengths of light traveling together through the sensor head
US5173747A (en) * 1990-09-20 1992-12-22 Battelle Memorial Institute Integrated optical directional-coupling refractometer apparatus
US5494798A (en) * 1993-12-09 1996-02-27 Gerdt; David W. Fiber optic evanscent wave sensor for immunoassay

Non-Patent Citations (2)

* Cited by examiner, † Cited by third party
Title
GIALLORENZI T G ET AL: "OPTICAL FIBER SENSOR TECHNOLOGY", IEEE JOURNAL OF QUANTUM ELECTRONICS, IEEE INC. NEW YORK, US, vol. QE-18, no. 4, 1 April 1982 (1982-04-01), pages 626 - 665, XP002047671, ISSN: 0018-9197 *
TONGLIN XIE: "Fused 3*3 single-mode fiber optic couplers for fiber interferometric sensors and coherent communications", ELECTRONIC COMPONENTS AND TECHNOLOGY CONFERENCE, 1991. PROCEEDINGS., 41ST ATLANTA, GA, USA 11-16 MAY 1991, NEW YORK, NY, USA,IEEE, US, 11 May 1991 (1991-05-11), pages 46 - 49, XP010044359, ISBN: 0-7803-0012-2 *

Also Published As

Publication number Publication date
AU2001297803A1 (en) 2003-06-10

Similar Documents

Publication Publication Date Title
Potyrailo et al. Optical waveguide sensors in analytical chemistry: today’s instrumentation, applications and trends for future development
US5494798A (en) Fiber optic evanscent wave sensor for immunoassay
US5663790A (en) Method and apparatus for determination of refractive index
Brecht et al. Recent developments in optical transducers for chemical or biochemical applications
US7295294B2 (en) Optical waveguide sensor and measuring apparatus using said optical waveguide sensor, and measuring method using a sensor
US6330064B1 (en) Doubly-differential interferometer and method for evanescent wave surface detection
US5082629A (en) Thin-film spectroscopic sensor
JPH05502733A (en) optical immunoassay
Lieberman Recent progress in intrinsic fiber-optic chemical sensing II
Shriver-Lake et al. The effect of tapering the optical fiber on evanescent wave measurements
EP0196168B1 (en) Fiber optic doppler anemometer
ZA200508065B (en) A fibre optic sensor for measurement of refractive index
WO2013053930A1 (en) Resonant biosensor
Udos et al. Spatial frequency spectrum of SPR-TFBG: A simple spectral analysis for in-situ refractometry
US6480638B1 (en) Single mode fiber optic evanescent wave refractometer
CA1266998A (en) Dielectric waveguide sensors and their use in immunoassays
JP2002350335A (en) Refractive index sensor, sensor system and optical fiber
CN1712929A (en) MZ interference evanescent wave chemical and biological sensor and system with fibre-optical microstructure
WO2003046524A1 (en) Single mode fiber optic evanescent wave refractometer and method of immunoassay measurement of a target component in a fluid
Londero et al. Resonant couplings in U-shaped fibers for biosensing
Betancur-Ochoa et al. Highly sensitive biosensing based on a photonic crystal fiber modal interferometer
Arifin et al. Low-cost high-sensitive plastic optical fiber-based sensor for detection of CO (NH 2) 2 urea
Dahne et al. Detection of antibody-antigen reactions at a glass-liquid interface: A novel fibre-optic sensor concept
Ingenhoff et al. Spectral interferometric sensors for gases and liquids using integrated optical devices
de Fornel Evanescent-field waveguide sensors

Legal Events

Date Code Title Description
AK Designated states

Kind code of ref document: A1

Designated state(s): AE AG AL AM AT AU AZ BA BB BG BR BY BZ CA CH CN CO CR CU CZ DE DK DM DZ EC EE ES FI GB GD GE GH GM HR HU ID IL IN IS JP KE KG KP KR KZ LC LK LR LS LT LU LV MA MD MG MK MN MW MX MZ NO NZ OM PH PL PT RO RU SD SE SG SI SK SL TJ TM TR TT TZ UA UG US UZ VN YU ZA ZW

AL Designated countries for regional patents

Kind code of ref document: A1

Designated state(s): GH GM KE LS MW MZ SD SL SZ TZ UG ZM ZW AM AZ BY KG KZ MD RU TJ TM AT BE CH CY DE DK ES FI FR GB GR IE IT LU MC NL PT SE TR BF BJ CF CG CI CM GA GN GQ GW ML MR NE SN TD TG

121 Ep: the epo has been informed by wipo that ep was designated in this application
122 Ep: pct application non-entry in european phase
NENP Non-entry into the national phase

Ref country code: JP

WWW Wipo information: withdrawn in national office

Country of ref document: JP